Pick 9: Who do we take? (Poll)

[Redleg 38,132]

…and when Acres or Sheed or whoever we pick is taking the game apart for us we can let him know about it.

The one problem I have with some of the reporting on Kelly is the DH who said we had 2 chances to get him. Well technically that is correct but lets just see how he stacks up against Hogan who we did take in his place the first chance.

That DH is Denham.

[rjay 24,090]

That DH is Denham.

I gave him a bit more credit than that, he's falling for the line I think was from a HS DH. Should have known better.

[McQueen 17,864]

1. Freeman

Salem

Crouch (Roughie)

[Slartibartfast 16,042]

Another trashing of us by Denham.

Gosh, I'm wounded.

[Slartibartfast 16,042]

It wouldn't surprise me if we chose someone else completely. Very little information has been getting out in the last few months, so I think there's a bit of guesswork in relation to the phantom drafts for out pick. Most has been based on us needing speed, therefor we must be after Freeman or Salem.

Acres has been very much off the radar of casual draft watchers due to injury, but those who have seen him rave about him. I hope he's the one we read out at 9.

Surely the only benefit in any bluffing would be to get Collingwood to take someone at 6 who they thought would be available at 10 because we wanted to try and insert someone into the draft ahead of us.

It would be surprising if Acres was a consideration to either there so I'm struggling to see the point.

[rjay 24,090]

Surely the only benefit in any bluffing would be to get Collingwood to take someone at 6 who they thought would be available at 10 because we wanted to try and insert someone into the draft ahead of us.

It would be surprising if Acres was a consideration to either there so I'm struggling to see the point.

No ones talking about bluffing, just that we might not pick who the media and so called draft experts think we will.

[Tony Tea 2,792]

How many Demonlanders have seen these kids play? And subsequent to that, how many of the Demonlanders who have seen these kids play are good judges of a footballer?

[bing181 8,267]

How many Demonlanders have seen these kids play? And subsequent to that, how many of the Demonlanders who have seen these kids play are good judges of a footballer?

It goes without saying, posters here are all excellent judges of footballers.

[Redleg 38,132]

Gosh, I'm wounded.

Didn't say it was a mortal blow, just more of the same from a bloke who clearly doesn't like us.

Hopefully we can turn it around and get some respect in the footy industry.

[Redleg 38,132]

Wonder who will be the first poster to knock our pick and how long it will take after the selection is made?

[bandicoot 1,395]

Going off videos only, Salem is the one I like. Looks to have the whole package. Good skills and very nice lateral movement.

Haven't we been burnt enough in the past by undersized skinny players. Salem might never grow into his body

[spirit of norm smith 13,519]

Demonland in 2012 wanted Ollie Wines ... and his form warranted that in 2013.

Freeman seems to be our pick in 2014

[ChaserJ 4,015]

How many Demonlanders have seen these kids play? And subsequent to that, how many of the Demonlanders who have seen these kids play are good judges of a footballer?

Yes to the first, and a somewhat biased yes to the second.

Regardless, I'm fairly certain Demonland will embrace whoever is chosen at pick 9…and swiftly call for their castration shortly after the first time their turnover leads to an opposition goal.

[demonoid 317]

Haven't we been burnt enough in the past by undersized skinny players. Salem might never grow into his body

he is listed as 81kg. Afl.com calls him a solidly built mid. Hardly slight is he?

[dee-luded 2,958]

Denham slammed us in the paper for trading a Brownlow medallist in Kelly. He has him already winning one. He says every other club's recruiter says we were mad with our trade. That is not the case, as I spoke to another official of another club whose recruiter disagrees and doesn't have Kelly in his best three mids. Another trashing of us by Denham.

If we were already around 7th or 8th on the ladder & rising, maybe we would have held onto P2?

but we're not & we need more quality depth with some years experience, than just one more 18 Yr old.

now we'll get an 18 Yr old, & have Tyson as well. this is the way to fast track our restocking of the list with quality.

these journo's are in paper print for a reason, because they're not in demand in the running of clubs. they make up stories suitable for the fiction dept'.

[Little Goffy 12,813]

Koldasnij... Kolaedoscopeshij, Collidosnaj...

Scrabble.

But only if we can get both of them. I invoke the Feebey Rule.

If there's no K-schnizzle available, then I'd be keen on Freeman, or Salem, or Aish, or Bontempelli, or Sheed, or Lennon, or Taylor. Not sure about Crouch - I get too confused, there are too many of them around at the moment.

Blurting that list out is a great illustration of the wisdom of going 2 to 9. We will get a quality midfielder, one or another.

[The Red Fox 216]

Demonland in 2012 wanted Ollie Wines ... and his form warranted that in 2013.

Freeman seems to be our pick in 2014

Majority of Demonland preferred Toumpas over Wines pre-draft. That all changed round 1.

[Glenn Molloy 494]

I am only going on TAC cup vision so I defer to the recruiters but to me, if Scharenberg slides, we should definitely take him...otherwise it's Salem for mine. Moves well and his kicking looks sublime. I'm sick of watching turnover merchants wearing the red and blue!!

[Freddy Fuschia 666]

Almost every phantom draft has Sheed going to WCE at 11. Most have some variance with other choices but nobody seems to think that a club would bite the bullet and take a risk with this player at 7 or 9 for eg.

Why?

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

Not Salem. Anyone but Salem

[jackaub 1,402]

Majority of Demonland preferred Toumpas over Wines pre-draft. That all changed round 1.

Majority of Demonland preferred Toumpas over Wines pre-draft. That all changed round 1.

That's entirely correct RF Most wanted Toumpas, some on here were trashed by others for stating the obvious that Wines was ready to go and was what we needed at that time A bit like Martin over Trengove!

[bing181 8,267]

That's entirely correct RF Most wanted Toumpas, some on here were trashed by others for stating the obvious that Wines was ready to go ...

Obvious? What's obvious after 1 season?

Let's wait a couple of years shall we.

[CBDees 3,162]

Majority of Demonland preferred Toumpas over Wines pre-draft. That all changed round 1.

And it may well change back again at the end of this season!

[IvanBartul13 2,564]

Denham slammed us in the paper for trading a Brownlow medallist in Kelly. He has him already winning one. He says every other club's recruiter says we were mad with our trade. That is not the case, as I spoke to another official of another club whose recruiter disagrees and doesn't have Kelly in his best three mids. Another trashing of us by Denham.

Most of these journalists would have lauded Richmond endlessly for a masterstroke had they been able to prize Tyson away from GWS at the end of last 2012. The annoying thing is Barrett and Denham, in particular, can't even get there head around the fact that that the trade wasn't a straight swap of Tyson for Pick 2, nor do they even go close to examining where Tyson would be drafted in this year's draft pool if he was in it, which is one of the the important considerations when assessing the trade before the materials of it have had a chance to play. Tyson could very easily have been picked high in the top 10 given his attributes in this draft pool. Kelly is class so the likelihood is a win-win for both clubs.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Haven't we been burnt enough in the past by undersized skinny players. Salem might never grow into his body

I like him because he is a quick thinker, a very good mover, is balanced and can get the ball moving to the boot in the blink of an eye and it goes where intended. He also has that fast twitchy elastic movement that enables him to change direction quickly. I see this skill set transferring very well to the senior AFL game, better than most. I think his skill set will hold up.

He is also strong and hits the ball at speed and keeps his balanced. I could see him at half back until he finishes his apprenticeship before moving. As for body shape he is exactly the size an 18 year old mid should be.

Work ethic and his willingness to compete can't be fully gauged from watching a couple of games and some highlights.