Neeld is not the problem

[Dr. Mubutu 866]

"COACHES SHOULDN'T HAVE TO COACH EFFORT AT AFL LEVEL" - Chris Dawes 19/05/2013

Despite all that has been said about Neeld, I refuse to crucify him based on what has been produced by this playing group.

Unless we see week in, week out effort from this lazy as sin playing group, I don't think we can see what Neeld has to deliver.

IT'S THE PLAYERS, STUPID!

[Soidee 1,496]

"COACHES SHOULDN'T HAVE TO COACH EFFORT AT AFL LEVEL" - Chris Dawes 19/05/2013

Despite all that has been said about Neeld, I refuse to crucify him based on what has been produced by this playing group.

Unless we see week in, week out effort from this lazy as sin playing group, I don't think we can see what Neeld has to deliver.

IT'S THE PLAYERS, STUPID!

Of course he is. The players do not respect anything he says or instructs. They are treating him like dog poo, he has no option but to get on with life elsewhere.

[Chook 15,022]

But Neeld says effort is not the issue.

[DemonOX 8,801]

R u on the MFC board Dr M????

Edited May 26, 2013 by DemonOX

[Dr. Mubutu 866]

Of course he is. The players do not respect anything he says or instructs. They are treating him like dog poo, he has no option but to get on with life elsewhere.

And how is this Neeld's fault?

Once again, you've identified that it is the fault of the PLAYERS.

They've already buried one coach. They should not be allowed to do it to another.

[Striker475 696]

Dr. Mubutu:

Is Neeld part of the solution then? Because if not, then he's part of the problem.

[Dr. Mubutu 866]

But Neeld says effort is not the issue.

You really think he hasn't been pulled into line after blasting them after the Brisbane game after round one last year, when he laid into the playing group for lack of effort?

[Dr. Mubutu 866]

Dr. Mubutu:

Is Neeld part of the solution then? Because if not, then he's part of the problem.

IMO, yes.

We've all heard scuttlebutt of how lazy this playing group was circa 2009-11.

The issue is that he has had to enforce standards that should be assumed for professional footballers.

[What 18,810]

WHO THE HELL IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE GAMEPLAN THEN?

Get real.

Neeld IS the problem.

[demonique 314]

"COACHES SHOULDN'T HAVE TO COACH EFFORT AT AFL LEVEL" - Chris Dawes 19/05/2013

Despite all that has been said about Neeld, I refuse to crucify him based on what has been produced by this playing group.

Unless we see week in, week out effort from this lazy as sin playing group, I don't think we can see what Neeld has to deliver.

IT'S THE PLAYERS, STUPID!

He is responsible for the playing group. If he can't get them up for the game?? Well, he has to go !!

End of story !!

The players obviously have no respect for him

We know that the players are so down in confidence and Mark Neeld cannot do anything to change that.

We really do need an experienced coach , because this basket case requires elite know how !

[Young Dee 1,303]

We got rid of 14 players last year - we can't get rid of the whole list.

If we have any chance of a furure it is by giving the players and supporters a clean slate (hope) and that starts with the coach leaving - then players/coaches rs with bad attituteds etc.

[DemonFrog 1,356]

"COACHES SHOULDN'T HAVE TO COACH EFFORT AT AFL LEVEL" - Chris Dawes 19/05/2013

Despite all that has been said about Neeld, I refuse to crucify him based on what has been produced by this playing group.

Unless we see week in, week out effort from this lazy as sin playing group, I don't think we can see what Neeld has to deliver.

IT'S THE PLAYERS, STUPID!

OMG was the coach not involved in 14 changes from last years players list?

Let clear out the decision makers and recruits that gave the MFC the current players list. Because there no point changing the players list if the same type or worse players take their place.

[Dr. Mubutu 866]

He is responsible for the playing group. If he can't get them up for the game?? Well, he has to go !!

End of story !!

The players obviously have no respect for him

We know that the players are so down in confidence and Mark Neeld cannot do anything to change that.

We really do need an experienced coach , because this basket case requires elite know how !

Congratulations on completely missing the point.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,309]

"COACHES SHOULDN'T HAVE TO COACH EFFORT AT AFL LEVEL" - Chris Dawes 19/05/2013

Despite all that has been said about Neeld, I refuse to crucify him based on what has been produced by this playing group.

Unless we see week in, week out effort from this lazy as sin playing group, I don't think we can see what Neeld has to deliver.

IT'S THE PLAYERS, STUPID!

I agree the players need to bear a large part of the responsibility but while Neeld may not be THE problem as Striker said he is not part of the solution either. So Neeld is a hard arse who needs to beat the unprofessional players into line? A coach needs to be more than that and you can't even say he has done that particularly well.

The club can't survive with this constant rubbish served up every week. I've been going week in week out for 25 years since I was 6 and I don't even want to go anymore not because its depressing but because its boring. It's just so bloody predictable what's the point?

[Rob Mac...... 638]

"COACHES SHOULDN'T HAVE TO COACH EFFORT AT AFL LEVEL" - Chris Dawes 19/05/2013

Despite all that has been said about Neeld, I refuse to crucify him based on what has been produced by this playing group.

Unless we see week in, week out effort from this lazy as sin playing group, I don't think we can see what Neeld has to deliver.

IT'S THE PLAYERS, STUPID!

Oh Please Dr Mubutu! Don't quote players as a sign of support for any coach. Players never criticise their coach because he has the power to ruin their careers. [Macca posted great explanations for this 6 weeks ago]

Neelds appalling people skills has contributed greatly to the lack of spirit/effort, and his poor game plan nous kills us too. These are the 2 main things a coach needs!

Plenty else is wrong, but he's a useless coach who should be gone now whether we have a permanent replacement or not.

[bush demon 2,062]

Agree, it's not Neeld's fault. Who shot the Kennedy's? After all, it was you and me, or words to that effect. The club's file? Well, it was stamped by City Hall a few years back when AD put the question what does Melbourne stand for? Post-TV rights deals he may well have regretted that solo instrumental but it is clear that the administration do not regard the minnow victorian clubs, they are a hindrance to the new global game. Is it the players fault? of course it is, but they are just playing for wages after all, and they know they get the same wages as the premiership aspirants regardless of their level of input. they also know they can 'trade' themselves to another club if they get jack of season-on-season losses. is it neeld's fault? of course it is. he came to the club full of elite mindset spin and spun us a new one. he got onto the payroll saying what we needed to hear. sheedy attempted the same heist but got picked up by the scanners. is it the players fault? no, it's not the players' fault etc etc

Having dumped on the Dees, the AFL now has to decide whether they are going to save us. and then footscray, and then stkilda. of course they won't. but they will say they will. by that stage there will be a manageable 14 or so teams in the competition. will the supporters care? no they won't.

[DemonFrog 1,356]

Oh Please Dr Mubutu! Don't quote players as a sign of support for any coach. Players never criticise their coach because he has the power to ruin their careers. [Macca posted great explanations for this 6 weeks ago]

Neelds appalling people skills has contributed greatly to the lack of spirit/effort, and his poor game plan nous kills us too. These are the 2 main things a coach needs!

Plenty else is wrong, but he's a useless coach who should be gone now whether we have a permanent replacement or not.

You have my vote for the next MFC President!

[What 18,810]

OP = clueless

[rjay 25,094]

'Doc', i think the problem is not necessarily the effort but how that effort is applied and that is Neeld's fault. There is no logical sense in the way they are playing at the moment where they leave the middle of the ground open for the opposition to do as they please. We seem to have the bulk of our players in either of the 50 mtr arcs with no one pushing up from either side, we can blame a poor midfield but it is team pressure we lack.

He can't have it both ways either about being in a rebuild and developing players then throwing all structure out the window and pushing everyone back into defence to save the scoreline. Having Howe sit as a loose man on the FB line when all their attack is coming from HB where we have now given them a loose man also makes no sense.

We were lucky today, Freo are not a heavy scoring team. I really fear for next week against the Hawks.

[praha 11,240]

It's VERY easy for the playing group to come out and take the blame, because ALL players are on the SAME LEVEL.

If Garland, or Dawes, or whoever comes out and says, "It's us, not the coach", then they can shoulder the blame collectively, rather than hold a coach accountable for his team playing arguably the worst brand of football the league has ever seen.

[DeeZee 7,445]

We are that bad we should doing two things, play man on man, and tackle .

Freo had that many loose players in the first half it wasnt funny, at least it gives our players a chance to compete.

[Theo 276]

OMG was the coach not involved in 14 changes from last years players list?

Let clear out the decision makers and recruits that gave the MFC the current players list. Because there no point changing the players list if the same type or worse players take their place.

And who agreed to 3 yr contracts for Jamar, Pederson and McKenzie.

Who recruited Gillies, Rodan, Byrnes and Pederson and failed to leave a spot on the list for Jack Hannath.

The Coach.

Edited May 26, 2013 by Theo

[Jarka 767]

I think it would be more accurate to say that 'It's not just Neeld's fault'. Recruiting, list managment and senior management all have to share the blame. How the club let it become to this is staggering, we are not an AFL level team and it will probably get worse before it gets better.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

I think it would be more accurate to say that 'It's not just Neeld's fault'. Recruiting, list managment and senior management all have to share the blame. How the club let it become to this is staggering, we are not an AFL level team and it will probably get worse before it gets better.

Leigh Matthews once said that to win a premiership, everything must align....from the president, to the volunteer who turns the sausages.

Players must take some responsibility.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,309]

And who agreed to 3 yr contracts for Jamar, Pederson and McKenzie.

Who recruited Gillies, Rodan, Byrnes and Pederson and failed to leave a spot on the list for Jack Hannath.

The Coach.

Surely Harrington has to take some of the blame here as well. His role is List Manager and under him the management of the list has been deplorable.