Having fun, Tom?

[jumbo returns 6,488]

Honestly, get over it.

And if a young 'gun' wanted to come to us in similar circumstances...?

I think we'd be rubbing our hands together with delight.

This Scully sooking is getting very boring.

Nope, not getting over it.

Too boring for you? Don't reply please and I'll return the favour.

[The Big Ticket 94]

there's a reason he was pick 1 and is on good coin.

Please enlighten me. What did he do to deserve all that coin? ONE good game in two years was enough?

[Sir Why You Little 34,493]

I'll bite! He probabaty faked it I sometimes wonder why the cowards don't ask him about it?

There is nothing wrong with that knee, no more injured than any other young midfielder.

We got rolled over. But so did GW$ and their contract is much longer.

[Hulett Packard III 166]

Well, to be honest, Little Tommy is traveling a lot better then Trengove, we are really

stuck with this guy, can not drop the captain, and he can not buy a kick.

A decision will be required shortly and there will

be a few red faces.

Have we done well out of the deal,? depends if we blow both picks on a Silvia and McLean.

Why do some people close their eyes to reality?

Trengove doesn't deserve that bagging. He plays a different role to Scully and is under a lot more pressure as skipper.

Saturday's stats were 10 kicks 11 handballs - hardly useless when compared to Scully's figures unless you want to be selectively supercritical.

There are always one or two Blueys in a crowd so I suppose we need to humour them with facts and logic.

[bush demon 1,891]

I think the problem with TS is that he went out of the way to convey a misleading impression he was staying, so when he went North it undermined our re-build. Anyway, turnover tommy probably is better suited to Kev's shiny suits, and we are certainly better off withthe money in Mitchell Clark's access account.

PS It was all KS's fault anyway; telling in the way he taunted us to go see our boy play at the G recently.

[Demon trucker 1,770]

I think it is telling that he is not in there leadership team the kids dont rate him, after his contract is up he will be asked to tak pay cute a 50%

[Face Your Demons 175]

Just make sure we beat them every time we play them and i'm happy.

[hardtack 10,127]

There is nothing wrong with that knee, no more injured than any other young midfielder.

We got rolled over. But so did GW$ and their contract is much longer.

Are you (and others) still insisting that the MFC didn't have any tests/examinations made of Scully's knee? Are you saying he told the club something along the lines of: "Look, I've got a bit of a chronic knee thingy going on here, so you better give me a rest" and the MFC responded, "No problem Tommy boy... you're our #1 pick, so as far as we're concerned, despite all of the conjecture about your staying or going, your word is good enough for us"?

Sorry, but for me, that just doesn't add up.

Sure, we should be bitter with regards to how and why he left, but to invent scenarios and to suddenly (not necessarily in your case WYL) brand him as an absolute dud, when the same posters would likely be praising his potential if he had remained a Dee, is laughable.

Edited July 16, 2012 by hardtack

[deejammin' 2,065]

This thread would be a lot more poignant if the MFC was pushing hard for finals

[DeeZee 6,733]

I'm completely over the Scully thing now.

We are the big winners out of all this.

The best we can do now is not to mention him,as he is just another opposition player.

Just like Brock the pain has now gone away.

[Guest KingDingAling]

Scully was the last thing we needed anyway, he isnt a man, he is a boy, what use is that to us when we

are crying out for leadership! How could Scully ever lead men? I dont think he'll ever make a man.

I just see through Scully.

He plays tense, like he is always bracing for impact, scared pehaps, has no composure at all,

he rushes too much to get rid of it, he lacks awareness more often than not.

He is a very poor mans Andrew Gaff - apologies to Gaff.

We should be very big winners out of Scully, god bless the kid.

[DeeVoted 582]

Some of youse blokes need to get a grip,honestly.

Of the 20,000 threads (approx) and climbing. The 4 billion posts relating or related too one Tom Scumbag, not one has nailed that MFC

took a double whammy when all this unfolded.,and the all the facts came out.

1st we lost a N01 pick we staged all year to secure, but not only that. The real issue was, we missed out on NSW best developement coach

(Phat Phil), Why else would Pendergast walk, he lost a potential right hand man.

And THAT is why we got 2 (TWO) comp picks.

Clear as day to some,clouded to others.

Edited July 16, 2012 by Deevoted

[thaipantsman 180]

Scully in sizzling form again today with 6 kicks and 10 handballs, the spud played on from a mark and managed to get a goal touched of his boot 2 metres from the goal line, which I enjoyed immensely. Can't you just feel those media maggots warming up their typing fingers to start getting stuck into this guy as everyone wonders why in the name of God he is getting 50 grand a game, which is over 10 grand a kick at the moment. Meanwhile his side is enjoying a fantastic debut year, with 14 losses to go alongside their win over the other hacks, culminating in an average losing margin of 80 points including losses of 162, 129, 119, 94 and 92. Today they played at home and the Crows piled on 18 goals after time. Hope Tommy is loving it.

Mr Curry you are a very bitter Man! Much prefer playing under Sheedy than in this pathetic rabble called MFC.

[thaipantsman 180]

I'm completely over the Scully thing now.

We are the big winners out of all this.

The best we can do now is not to mention him,as he is just another opposition player.

Just like Brock the pain has now gone away.

How true! The more you all keep crying highlights just how bitter you still are. Why constantly bag out on a 20 yo kid that took 6 mill. Melbourne were always going to be a basket case under Neeld and he could see that.

[Mgdee 319]

This guy is amazing not only did he know to sign up 12 months early he also could forsee Neeld being coach of Melbourne in 2012.

That's some brain power.

[QueenC 74]

This thread would be a lot more poignant if the MFC was pushing hard for finals

We'll just bump it back up when that happens......

Went out to Homebush yesterday with a friend who won tickets (that is how they get people to the games up here) and was bored.

Adelaide were fine, professional and at time quite fun to watch. GWS were at times pretty good, but so tiny by comparison.

The issue with Scully is that after all the lying and conning he did to us, watching him fail (and he was stunningly ineffectual) is a bit of a sick thrill.

It's not making the world turn, but theres really no point denying it !!!

Edited July 16, 2012 by QueenC

[Left Field 313]

You all must be thrilled that Bluey has made the trek across from ology :-)

I posted elsehwere about Gaff at WCE. Was he not off contract? Has all of Scully's pace and endurance but can hit a target. Come home factor?

Hoping he hasn't re-signed with WCE recently.

[QueenC 74]

You all must be thrilled that Bluey has made the trek across from ology :-)

I posted elsehwere about Gaff at WCE. Was he not off contract? Has all of Scully's pace and endurance but can hit a target. Come home factor?

Hoping he hasn't re-signed with WCE recently.

Sorry Left Field......

Gaff signs new West Coast deal

http://www.sportsnewsfirst.com.au/articles/2012/04/03/gaff-signs-new-west-coast-deal/

[daisycutter 28,549]

This thread would be a lot more poignant if the MFC was pushing hard for finals

yeah, but i just hate poignant threads.....make me want to cry

[IRW 1,232]

Blueys middle name is Flame.

Its taken him a while to light up on here but its been interesting to watch..

Thus far not one comment on his speling.

Wait until he gets going on Cale....he's 'silk' apparantly

Edited July 16, 2012 by IRW

[QueenC 74]

Blueys middle name is Flame.

Its taken him a while to light up on here but its been interesting to watch..

Thus far not one comment on his speling.

We may well be immune to spelling issues, given the years we've spent with the wonderful creativity of Belzebub !!!

Edited July 16, 2012 by QueenC

[Dee Fan 3,247]

You all must be thrilled that Bluey has made the trek across from ology :-)

I posted elsehwere about Gaff at WCE. Was he not off contract? Has all of Scully's pace and endurance but can hit a target. Come home factor?

Hoping he hasn't re-signed with WCE recently.

Pretty sure Gaff has re signed Leftie.

Bluey just loves to stir the pot doesn't he; what surprises me most is that all of a sudden he can spell most of the words in his posts.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Sure, we should be bitter with regards to how and why he left, but to invent scenarios and to suddenly (not necessarily in your case WYL) brand him as an absolute dud, when the same posters would likely be praising his potential if he had remained a Dee, is laughable.

so youre laughing at a hypothetical scenario you are watching n your head

demon or not I have not seen much star potential from him bar that last quarter in the wet against the dogs

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Mr Curry you are a very bitter Man! Much prefer playing under Sheedy than in this pathetic rabble called MFC.

and losing by 80 every week

[daisycutter 28,549]

Blueys middle name is Flame.

Its taken him a while to light up on here but its been interesting to watch..

Thus far not one comment on his speling.

Wait until he gets going on Cale....he's 'silk' apparantly

could it be bluey is one of your multiple personalities?