GW$ vs Swans

[frankie_d 1,471]

Watching the match.

Don't want to hear about how young our list is (GW$ - 17 debutants) or getting used to a new game plan. GW$ are having a go - Junior just ran through some Swans bloke in the centre square... good decision to let him go <not>

Makes me worry about how strong our list really is after 4 years of pain.

Roll on Game 1.

[WhateverItTakes 17]

Commentary is starting to irk me. They are only saying good things about GWS and almost jump through the commentary box window with excitement when they get a goal.. must be some kind of deal they have going with Andrew.

[darkhorse72 1,917]

Loved juniors hit...classic footy.

[Sir Why You Little 37,038]

Why is Junior Mac playing for this team?

A coaching position ok fair enough, but playing against other AFL sides for him is just weird.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

It just aint cricket, is it? Although we did get rid of him, so he can do whatever he likes.

Liked Tim Mohr. Why didn't we draft him!

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Sam Reid can't buy a free kick. The ground is awful, sand flying everywhere.

[bing181 9,238]

Sam Reid can't buy a free kick. The ground is awful, sand flying everywhere.

Great to see Junior out there. Cornes looked decent as well. The old guard still flying the flag, both well and truly earned their places.

[Jaded No More 68,915]

Good on Junior. We treated him like crap and tonight shows that he still has some value.

Very sad that we pushed him to play for this disgraceful joke of a club.

He is definitely the only redeeming feature about this orange monstrosity. And the [censored] isn't even playing yet!

On a side note, how utterly ridiculous is the commentary?? They are orgasming over a 4 goal performance. So stupid.

[Dee-licious 1,949]

Hope we are speaking to a few of their managers! Liking the look of Bugg/Kennedy. Wish we picked up Mohr!

[Maldonboy38 6,403]

I reckon the commentary has been good. The interviews before the game and during half time were a bit cringe worthy but the actual game commentary is fine.

GWS

Curtly Hampson will be a gun. All the silky skills with a bit of grunt

Townsend. Really tough and reminds me a bit of Jordie McKenzie in the way he is so dogged.

Ward, Junior, Cornes, David, Rhys Palmer all doining really well.

Backline is good

Forward line is non-existent.

Swans

Some good signs from some younger players.

Lewis Jetta tore GWS apart

Goodes is a superstar, even when he plays an average game.

However, if this is the best they can do against GWS in the first game, I reckon the Swans could take a big dive this year.

Tim Mohr looking strong and composed - did the Dees ever seriously consider him?

I have 4 GWS players in my Supercoach team who have all done well

[Guest oldman emubitter]

It just aint cricket, is it? Although we did get rid of him, so he can do whatever he likes.

Liked Tim Mohr. Why didn't we draft him!

because gws nailed him before anyone else had a crack.

i thought he was very good in the 2 games i saw him in last year

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I put 50 bucks on Sydney to win by 87 so hopefully that happens. Only thing keeping me watching this crap.

[In Neeld We Trust 1]

Watching the Giants this competitive in their first game makes me even more angry about 186.

Was impressed.

Can't wait to see us in round one now.

[Yossarian 1,820]

Just happy round 1 has started.

[Sir Why You Little 37,038]

Yes i think our excuses are well over. No more talking about kids getting games. Our list just has to perform. After 3-4 years of drafting we have about 12 players that we still do not know if they are any good at senior level. 2012 will reveal a lot.

If it doesn't then this list is in big trouble.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,053]

I wouldn't read anything much into this game in terms of scoreline or how competitive the giants were. There were a lot of mitigating factors.

1- Swans played some of the worst football I've ever seen from them.

2- Umpiring was very one-sided. You may have noticed that the Sydney forwards couldn't buy a free. Imagine how the score would have blown out if the frees in marking contests had been payed.

3- The Swans really weren't trying. They were strolling around the field doing training drills for a lot of the night. This of course contributed to point 1.

As for Mohr, I thought he was pretty solid tonight. If I recall, he improved drastically last year. Before that he was never in contention for an AFL spot. He just happened to click at a time when GWS could grab him outside the draft.

[MadAsHell 4,212]

Thankfully I decided to bring round 1 in with Casey-v-Williamstown. Gave the Swans-v-GWS match a miss, although I would of liked to have seen how Junior went.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

I'm just happy $cully didn't get to play their first game. Hopefully he'll miss many more in the future!

[Guest melbman]

Yes i think our excuses are well over. No more talking about kids getting games. Our list just has to perform. After 3-4 years of drafting we have about 12 players that we still do not know if they are any good at senior level. 2012 will reveal a lot.

If it doesn't then this list is in big trouble.

Yep, aggression was the big difference to me. Was it targeted drafting, coaching or both?

Thankfully I decided to bring round 1 in with Casey-v-Williamstown. Gave the Swans-v-GWS match a miss, although I would of liked to have seen how Junior went.

Wish I could say the same. I made the wrong choice hoping to see a blood bath on tv but it didn't happen. :-(

[Pipefitter 2,159]

3 touches for izzy. How many dollars per disposal? The wrestling has more integrity than the afl expansion in western Sydney.

[Ouch! 2,263]

I was watching the game in the background on and off.... did someone forget to mow the ground prior to the game? that surface looked ordinary.

It was not the prettiest game of football, but Sydney don't play pretty nor do they tend to [censored] teams by 100+ GWS battled hard though, and made a better fist of it that GC did in their first couple of games.

[old dee 23,791]

3 touches for izzy. How many dollars per disposal? The wrestling has more integrity than the afl expansion in western Sydney.

Thats 3 more than you know who so far.

[old dee 23,791]

Watching the Giants this competitive in their first game makes me even more angry about 186.

Was impressed.

Can't wait to see us in round one now.

Yes And was less than a couple of other games we played in 2011.

I reckon they might finish second last this year.

[Whispering_Jack 30,136]

I thought it was about what one would expect from a team that plays the Sydney style of game against a team of predominantly first gamers, and five players with previous AFL experience, some past their use by dates. Fortunately, that last point to the Swans made it a simple exercise to work out GWS's percentage at 37.

The Giants have some promising young players and well they should have given the concessions they were granted and the knowledge that their rights to that large group of elite youngsters were virtually inviolable irrespective of their recruiting methods. However, they have no backbone of strong key position players. Cameron looked a prospect but heaven help them if they're relying on him and Setanta up forward. Power and Scully (if fit) will help.

[Cards13 9,117]

I thought it was about what one would expect from a team that plays the Sydney style of game against a team of predominantly first gamers, and five players with previous AFL experience, some past their use by dates. Fortunately, that last point to the Swans made it a simple exercise to work out GWS's percentage at 37.

The Giants have some promising young players and well they should have given the concessions they were granted and the knowledge that their rights to that large group of elite youngsters were virtually inviolable irrespective of their recruiting methods. However, they have no backbone of strong key position players. Cameron looked a prospect but heaven help them if they're relying on him and Setanta up forward. Power and Scully (if fit) will help.

Cameron will be a gun, he is still just a kid but looks really composed.