Jack Grimes

[biggestred 4,377]

Anyone know what happened to Jack Grimes?

I saw him coming off the ground at the end on crutches

[hrob 2]

I think he broke his foot in the first quarter.

[titan_uranus 22,775]

Some sort of foot/ankle injury, hopefully it's not serious.

What I liked was that he started in the centre at the first bounce. That was a good sign.

[Jaded No More 59,138]

Was on crutches post game but no bandage on the foot. You'd think if it was broken he'd have been in hospital getting x-rays and a cast/boot.

Perhaps just bad bruising?

Fingers crossed because I reckon Bail's game today was good enough to give Grimes more runs in the middle.

[rhaz 342]

Navicular is complicated. I hate to make the comparison, but it's similar to Matthew Egan's bad break which in the end, force him to retire.

Dont you dare be saying things like this around here. I dont care if its true, i dont want to hear it!

[ox_5 163]

Grimes has broken his navicular bone. Would be surprised if we saw him back this year.

Navicular is complicated. I hate to make the comparison, but it's similar to Matthew Egan's bad break which in the end, force him to retire.

Where did you hear this news???? How would they know without having done an xray?

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

Grimes has broken his navicular bone. Would be surprised if we saw him back this year.

Navicular is complicated. I hate to make the comparison, but it's similar to Matthew Egan's bad break which in the end, force him to retire.

Your source?

[Eth 4]

Your source?

Definitely definitely need a source for this. Don't scare us with navicular without backing it up.

[Cherrybaby 9]

Your source?

I'm not believing anything until MFC confims the extent of Grime's injury.

[Scipio 5,868]

Didnt hear what the diagnosis was exactly, but think Richo had said after heading into the rooms it would take too much work to get him back out today, but he would be there next week. Hopefully I heard right..

[demonglory 60]

Grimes has broken his navicular bone. Would be surprised if we saw him back this year.

Navicular is complicated. I hate to make the comparison, but it's similar to Matthew Egan's bad break which in the end, force him to retire.

What do evidence do you base this on?. You need to supply this before making such far reaching statements>>>>>>>>>

[jayceebee31 688]

Grimes has broken his navicular bone. Would be surprised if we saw him back this year.

Navicular is complicated. I hate to make the comparison, but it's similar to Matthew Egan's bad break which in the end, force him to retire.

If this is a made up remark you should be banned for life.

[darkhorse72 1,760]

I always find it interesting that the worst news from an unknown source, comes from members with a low number of posts

[Scipio 5,868]

I always find it interesting that the worst news from an unknown source, comes from members with a low number of posts

I hope you arent stupid enough to think that just because a person has not been a member of this online forum for long means they are not reliable or that their posts have no crediblity.

[Kento80 83]

I hope you arent stupid enough to think that just because a person has not been a member of this online forum for long means they are not reliable or that their posts have no crediblity.

A lot of people are stupid enough to think that.

[deanox 8,782]

DeeTermination, you would be naive if you think that members who have a track record of posting over a longer period of time, and who have a known history of being reliable, are better believed than an unfamiliar member with limited posts, particularly when they post such a comment, and then fail to respond to follow up questions.

This doesn't mean that new members are less reliable or credible, it means the rest of us are unaware how credible they are.

Think of trusting a 4 year old friend versus a recent acquaintance. You may not rule them out, but if unsubstantiated so may not trust them straight up.

[Sir Why You Little 34,937]

All i'm saying is my sources have reported a broken foot - for most of you that know anything about anatomy, a broken foot almost always means the navicular as it is kind of a wedged bone, can't move under pressure and often takes a lot of stress at it's skinniest point. So it's not anything different to a 'normal' broken foot.

And most of the time, a broken foot isn't all that bad, similar to a broken arm or something, wait for the bone to heal, which doesnt take long as it's a very small (but vital) bone. The only issue is the inability to perform any weight bearing tasks.

EDIT: completely understand the mis-trust, been on this thing for not long compared to most of you lot, however love the dees and i wouldn't go around making up [censored] and bull stories just to [censored] off my fellow supporters.

Jimmy Stynes will fix that Bone... B)

[Kento80 83]

All i'm saying is my sources have reported a broken foot - for most of you that know anything about anatomy, a broken foot almost always means the navicular as it is kind of a wedged bone, can't move under pressure and often takes a lot of stress at it's skinniest point. So it's not anything different to a 'normal' broken foot.

And most of the time, a broken foot isn't all that bad, similar to a broken arm or something, wait for the bone to heal, which doesnt take long as it's a very small (but vital) bone. The only issue is the inability to perform any weight bearing tasks.

EDIT: completely understand the mis-trust, been on this thing for not long compared to most of you lot, however love the dees and i wouldn't go around making up [censored] and bull stories just to [censored] off my fellow supporters.

No offence, but I hope your source is a fool Don't know that I could stand another season without Grimes, and I'm sure it would be heartbreaking for him too. Let's hope he's ok.

[Scipio 5,868]

All I was saying was please don't judge a poster who has a low number of posts as uncredible just for that reason, it doesnt give us new guys much of a go at it. Point taken re the trust issue.

[jayceebee31 688]

All i'm saying is my sources have reported a broken foot - for most of you that know anything about anatomy, a broken foot almost always means the navicular as it is kind of a wedged bone, can't move under pressure and often takes a lot of stress at it's skinniest point. So it's not anything different to a 'normal' broken foot.

And most of the time, a broken foot isn't all that bad, similar to a broken arm or something, wait for the bone to heal, which doesnt take long as it's a very small (but vital) bone. The only issue is the inability to perform any weight bearing tasks.

EDIT: completely understand the mis-trust, been on this thing for not long compared to most of you lot, however love the dees and i wouldn't go around making up [censored] and bull stories just to [censored] off my fellow supporters.

I appreciate the edit section of your post. I am not saying you are right or wrong with your prognosis however I would have thought that Xrays would have to be done before confirmation. The media had stated early it was an ankle injury.

[Jaded No More 59,138]

Have a look at the video of the team singing the song post match.

Grimes joins in, and I can't really tell if he's on crutches. He is definitely not on two crutches, possibly just one.

Can't have a broken foot if he's up singing the song. Anyone who has broken anything from the hip down before would tell you that standing up singing is not top of your priority list. Unless you are really high on Morphine. So fingers crossed!

[Allen Jakovich 516]

Yeah was about to post the same thing Jaded. Looks like he's walking without crutches to me.

Besides you would need scans for a navicular fracture so I call bs.

[monoccular 16,399]

Grimes has broken his navicular bone. Would be surprised if we saw him back this year.

Navicular is complicated. I hate to make the comparison, but it's similar to Matthew Egan's bad break which in the end, force him to retire.

thanks demonwithin - is that Mr demonwithin, FRACS (Ortho)???

Always glad of an expert opinion and prognosis even before xrays, scans etc.

You must be a wizz!!!!

Did you do Matthew Egan's operation??

[Crompton's the man 635]

Don't pretend to know too much about it but Bruce Reid ( EFC doctor) told me that they always bind ankle/foot injuries to limit swelling unless it's broken in which case they don't.

Someone probably has a microscope to see how the foot is being bandaged post-game

[Red Sox 2]

As soon as he's finally starting in the middle, he's injured.