hate to see this happen a young kid. dreadful news

Sounded like we were super keep on him in the draft too. Makes you appreciate how much luck can be involved.

Poor bugger. Hopefully he’s able to get through this adversity and come back bigger and better.

Devastating for the poor kid.

4 minutes ago, adonski said:

Shocking news for the kid. He can take example from our own Christian Petracca who also suffered a torn ACL in his first year at the club, worked hard to come back (and from the experience of some of my own family members who have undergone that surgery, it’s hard work) and win a Norm Smith, a premiership medallion and acclaim as one of the great players of our game.

Good luck Jagga!

Terrible luck for the kid, but this should shorten the rising star odds for Langford. 

Poor kid. He will be a great player, just delayed a year.

Awful news

Other then our new draftees, Jagga was the one I was excited to watch this year.

 

Hopefully he follows the Petracca pathway, for his sake.

Rotten luck for Jagga Smith.

My heart goes out to him. I have injured my ACL in my knee playing footy in the past and know how tough it is to recover.

I was definitely keen on the Demons to draft him, but the Blues had the earlier pick in the draft and snapped him up.

I wish him all the best with his recuperation. ❤️

Fingers crossed for our own Andy Moniz-Wakefield and his injury diagnosis. 🤞🏻

Edited February 23Feb 23 by Supreme_Demon

Yes rotten luck. 
even if you do not run a two year old yearling in a Melbourne cup   You can still have unfortunate occurrences.

good luck AMW at least you had 12 months or more conditioning but still hurt your knee.   let’s not put too much pressure on our man Harvey.

Shocking luck

he was running laps later, amazing 

Whether young or old, I never like to see season ending injuries, but this being Carlton (and the AFL's darlings), they may get the SSP extended and that might be good for us, considering the possibility of losing AMW for the year 

8 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Shocking luck

he was running laps later, amazing 

i remember when simon tregenza did his acl he actually got thru the following half of the next week before they realised something was really, really wrong

1 minute ago, Demon_spurs said:

Whether young or old, I never like to see season ending injuries, but this being Carlton (and the AFL's darlings), they may get the SSP extended and that might be good for us, considering the possibility of losing AMW for the year 

the ssp won't be extended

it's now a case of waiting til the mid season draft to be able to bring a player on to the list, if determined that it's worthwhile doing so

4 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

the ssp won't be extended

it's now a case of waiting til the mid season draft to be able to bring a player on to the list, if determined that it's worthwhile doing so

Probably not this year, but clubs are pushing the AFL for next season: https://www.afl.com.au/news/1271028

48 minutes ago, Demon Disciple said:

How I hope you haven’t just karma’d us into a disaster year.

My Blue-supporting brother made a special effort to avoid gloating about all our issues in 2024 as a football karma consideration. To his full credit, he didn't even gloat about not gloating.

So I'm doubly conscious that ' VNightCityLegend' is inviting all kinds of karma bus, and we should collectively admonish him to ensure the trouble only heads to Tottenham.

Carlton's supporter base has always had a healthy flavour of superstition and they must be right on edge at the moment after losing Newman, now Jagga, and the major scares to Walsh and Curnow.

I suspect Carlton would have seriously considered Jagga even if he'd done the knee before the draft, and he's still got a long and likely shining career ahead of him, but there is something really unpleasant about seeing a kid take a hit like that. All the best to him.

Hate Carlton but also hate to see any young man having a serious injury while trying to make a career in the AFL. Hopefully he comes back bigger and stronger.

Edited February 23Feb 23 by Jibroni

 

2 minutes ago, Jibroni said:

Hate Carlton but also hate to see any young man having a serious injury while trying to make a career in the AFL. Hopefully he comes back bigger and stronger.

Agreed. Preferably playing for someone who isn’t Carlton

 

40 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

i remember when simon tregenza did his acl he actually got thru the following half of the next week before they realised something was really, really wrong

Yes i vaguely remember that now, that you mention it, incredible when you think about it, being a tear, it would depend on the length i suppose…

I remember when Petracca did his knee at this same time of the preseason in his first year. He went on to have a great career but at the time it felt like the sky was falling. Early picks are such a huge investment.

Hopefully he can recover like tracc did.