PREGAME: Rd 21 vs North Melbourne

[kev martin 10,702]

I watched Goody on the 360 show from the YouTube site.

I found his comments about Yze the most interesting. He said he looks after, "mids, stoppages, and offense ". Is that the change we are observing with the ball entry into the 50?

He was asked about having a strong discussion with Gawny at half-time, against Richmond. Leadership, and home truths about effort (I think), made a difference to our game and possibly the season.

Edited August 1, 2023 by kev martin

[Demon Dynasty 17,130]

Rolled Gold opportunity to rest some of our mature champs who've had a big year plus Salo for a freshen up as well (and not saying Salo isn't a champ just that he's had a somewhat diff pathway coming back in)

Set us up beautifully for the final run home

Would love to see May get the chance as well but cant see who covers for him at Casey.

Grundy for Gawn

Dunstan for Viney

Hibbo for Salem with Hibbo taking on McVee's role and Mcvee taking on the higher up Salo role.

Sparrow should be back for Harmes

Edited August 1, 2023 by Demon Dynasty

[ben russell 764]

The talk of resting players against North doesn’t wash with me. We aren’t playing them at the ‘G, we’re playing them in Hobart at a ground where they have become accustomed to playing which will even things out somewhat. Still think we win convincingly but you just don’t flirt with good form.

Only changes that I would like to see are Harmes and/or Jordon for Oliver and/or Sparrow depending on the fitness of the latter two. Happy for Hibberd to find his way in as well, perhaps for one of Jordon/Harmes if both Clarry and Sparrow aren’t quite ready.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,016]

Why on earth would we want to rest anyone? The forward combination of Petty/van Rooyen/Melksham has worked. Just once. They need time to prove they are the real deal and the midfield combination has to be part of that work in progress. Of course, if better players are available they should be picked when available (ie, Oliver/Fristch/Sparrow for Harmes/Woewodin/Jordon, or whoever).

[mauriesy 7,410]

Hey, while we're at it, let's rest the coaches, the trainers and the doctor!

[Damo 3,437]

Everything is a risk. I say we rest those who we then want to 100% for the rest of the season. 

Anyone watch North on Sunday? My god, they are Shiite!

[Demonstone 23,338]

38 minutes ago, ben russell said:

The talk of resting players against North doesn’t wash with me.

Nor I.  You don't flirt with your form nor take any game for granted.

Players will get a week off before the finals if anybody needs a rest.

[layzie 34,336]

I'm sick of seeing the word 'rest'.

[Colm 2,190]

2 minutes ago, layzie said:

I'm sick of seeing the word 'rest'.

Would you prefer “managed”  ? Or like to see “general soreness” thrown in for good measure?

[Nascent 9,320]

Just hoping for us to win and keep the roos to <60.

 

And Petty to kick 10.

[Demon17 5,227]

10 minutes ago, Demonstone said:

Nor I.  You don't flirt with your form nor take any game for granted.

Players will get a week off before the finals if anybody needs a rest.

Spot on,  and our big threat to 2nd spot is Port and it will/may come down to %.  We are 15% ahead and unlikely to see Port bridge that gap but shouldn't be risked they do.  Lets use last 4 weeks to lock away the forward solution for sure.  

We can do subtle rests this week with Sparrow for Viney for example. But only if Jack needs it.

[Deebauched 1,220]

The obsession some posters have for resting players is based on nothing.  MFC is not running a nursing home.

Resting Salem is based on what logic??? Viney ,May and Gawn play if not injured.

Only change would be bringing in Grundy to help in the ruck and possibly Hibberd but who goes out.

Harmes and Jordan maybe.

We're going to need Grundy in September. Gawn is not superman but he is in his thirties. He cannot be expected to play every week like he did against Tigers.

[layzie 34,336]

8 minutes ago, Colm said:

Would you prefer “managed”  ? Or like to see “general soreness” thrown in for good measure?

Some good thesaurus use wouldn't be the worst thing, yes. 

[chook fowler 19,694]

18 minutes ago, Demonstone said:

Nor I.  You don't flirt with your form nor take any game for granted.

Players will get a week off before the finals if anybody needs a rest.

I wouldn't mind a rest as well - my foofer valve is playing up.

[drysdale demon 4,837]

1 hour ago, Demon Dynasty said:

Rolled Gold opportunity to rest some of our mature champs who've had a big year plus Salo for a freshen up as well (and not saying Salo isn't a champ just that he's had a somewhat diff pathway coming back in)

Set us up beautifully for the final run home

Would love to see May get the chance as well but cant see who covers for him at Casey.

Grundy for Gawn

Dunstan for Viney

Hibbo for Salem with Hibbo taking on McVee's role and Mcvee taking on the higher up Salo role.

Sparrow should be back for Harmes

Couldn' see these changes occurring other than Sparrow back in if fit, possibly Oliver.

[Grand New Flag 3,227]

I am told the decision has been made to hold Oliver back until the Carlton game.

It is also my understanding that we studied Geelong's run to the finals last year and compared that to the Dees.  We went in banged up, literally half the team was carrying an injury, we tried to play all players through their niggles.  Geelong on the other hand rested their older and niggled players over the season and had them all fully fit for finals. Not managing our players and playing too many injured players cost us a Premiership (in my view).

As such I expect Melbourne to rest players in the final month as they have during the season (eg Hibbert).  My view is we must rest Gawn.  He has been unbelievable for 3 weeks; we want him playing like this in finals he is pushing 32yo he needs to be rested particularly since we have Grundy ready to go.

I expect Sparrow to be brought back in, a bit of a lottery who goes out for him and I expect Grundy for Gawn. Not sure what to make of Hibbert, I would have brought him in for Dusty when forward last week. In the end our rookie Juddy struggled on a sublime Dusty. Perhaps moving forward Hibbert is a match-up player.  In saying that Juddy does not get dropped.

There will be players that have niggles that we are unaware of.  Don't be surprised to see some unexpected "managed" outs particularly against North and Hawks.  I get the argument about flirting with form, I just think this is a risk that the match committee are happy to take to get our boys full fit for finals.

Edited August 1, 2023 by Grand New Flag

[Demon Dynasty 17,130]

Managing/Resting/General soreness, whatever tickles your fanny folks.

Even if a player's genuinly 'managed' unfortunately they wont be left to their own devices laying back basking on a banana lounge sipping Pina Coladas poolside for days on end 🌴🌞🌴

The HP team will have an individual program layed out to ensure they are 'actively' resting in order to ensure they are primed for their return.

While obviously player in question avoids the heavy hitting/ bruising and potential corkies etc from a full match day hit out and hopefully gets to overcome the bulk of any such issues.

It comes back to the individual players and the coaches / HP crew coming together and discussing needs/wants as we enter this last foray prior to finals.  And who, if any, end up being managed if the window is there should they have potential issues that warrant the active break.

A fair percentage of whether the player does/doesn't would be determined in said discussions as well as the alignment of needs from a match up & coaches perspective in terms of game style, structure, available ins to cover off etc.

Spoke to the Bont about this late last year and he said the seasons were already overly lengthy and about to become even more taxing now with the extra gather round thrown in.  He said any 'in season' breaks are a god send for those in the regular starting 22 in order to make it through while playing a decent brand of footy.

Edited August 1, 2023 by Demon Dynasty

[Demonsterative 3,021]

56 minutes ago, layzie said:

I'm sick of seeing the word 'rest'.

Managed? 😜

[Roost it far 9,533]

Out: Gawn, Viney

In: Grundy, Sparrow

[BDA 23,017]

1 hour ago, layzie said:

I'm sick of seeing the word 'rest'.

Give rest a rest

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,016]

1 hour ago, layzie said:

I'm sick of seeing the word 'rest'.

Depends on context. Works well in this sentence: "We're the best, forget the rest".

[old55 23,833]

49 minutes ago, Grand New Flag said:

I am told the decision has been made to hold Oliver back until the Carlton game.

It is also my understanding that we studied Geelong's run to the finals last year and compared that to the Dees.  We went in banged up, literally half the team was carrying an injury, we tried to play all players through their niggles.  Geelong on the other hand rested their older and niggled players over the season and had them all fully fit for finals. Not managing our players and playing too many injured players cost us a Premiership (in my view).

As such I expect Melbourne to rest players in the final month as they have during the season (eg Hibbert).  My view is we must rest Gawn.  He has been unbelievable for 3 weeks; we want him playing like this in finals he is pushing 32yo he needs to be rested particularly since we have Grundy ready to go.

I expect Sparrow to be brought back in, a bit of a lottery who goes out for him and I expect Grundy for Gawn. Not sure what to make of Hibbert, I would have brought him in for Dusty when forward last week. In the end our rookie Juddy struggled on a sublime Dusty. Perhaps moving forward Hibbert is a match-up player.  In saying that Juddy does not get dropped.

There will be players that have niggles that we are unaware of.  Don't be surprised to see some unexpected "managed" outs particularly against North and Hawks.  I get the argument about flirting with form, I just think this is a risk that the match committee are happy to take to get our boys full fit for finals.

Michael Hibberd.

[Return to Glory 8,453]

Tipping we don't win by over 30 points and it's a lot tougher than most expect. Rest smest. Best side available please

[Wodjathefirst 2,667]

56 minutes ago, Demonsterative said:

Managed? 😜

I reckon ‘managed’ is the word. IF for example say Viney’s shoulder is suspect (I really have no idea but they do) manage him. IF the footy department identifies that a key player is ‘cooked’ for whatever reason manage him. 

Everyone else plays. We have a depth of talent that we can utilise.  We want to win next week and get some percentage if possible, the following week against Carlton we need to win. Get the best team on the park but at the same time ‘manage’ our risks as best we can.

[ManDee 7,319]

1 hour ago, Grand New Flag said:

...... Hibbert..... Not sure what to make of Hibbert.... Perhaps moving forward Hibbert .......

 

Who is this Hibbert?