Jump to content

Christian Petracca a chance to win the 2023 Brownlow Medal?


Supreme_Demon

Recommended Posts

9 minutes ago, loges said:

Well constructed argument however we should note in years gone by players from many positions would win the award and much fewer umpires on the ground 

There isn't an award where the midfielders don't dominate proceedings

Even the coaches very rarely give votes to backmen & forwards.  It's a midfielders medal now as it's hard to standout as a forward and backmen are now part of a zone with flooding a common practice

The only way things will change is if we go back to open forward lines as a staple (and what are the chances of that happening?)

  • Like 2
  • Thinking 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, Supreme_Demon said:

Far out! That was frustrating!

Jack Viney 3 votes against Sydney was a mystery.

Angus Brayshaw 3 votes against North Melbourne was also bizarre.

But oh well.

Lachie Neale from the Lions is a well deserved winner.

Pretty confident Christian Petracca will win the Demons' Best & Fairest this year though at least.

Brayshaw got 9 coaches votes against North I’m pretty sure.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Clintosaurus said:

They can't umpire properly so getting the votes right be impossible.

Nice, realistic connection, there. Is it not time that they became professional and thus, more accountable across the board of their responsibilities? The AFL has deceived us for too long about their respective talents, skills and meritorious service to the game. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, loges said:

Well constructed argument however we should note in years gone by players from many positions would win the award and much fewer umpires on the ground 

It would be interesting to analyse the positions of medal winners over the decades.

I can only recall two full backs - Fred Goldsmith SM 1955, Verdun Howell StK 1959.

Back pocket Bernie Smith Geel 1951, John James Carl 1961; Brad Hardie Foot 1985

CHB - Brian Gleeson StK 1957, Neil Roberts StK1958, Gordon Collis Carl 1964, Ross Glendinning NM 1983

HBF Gavin Wanganeen Ess 1993

CHF Kelvin Templeton Foot 1980

FF Tony Lockett St K 1987

All the others were rucks, rovers, ruck rovers, centres and on-ballers. Not a single set position player since 1993 and not even a single ruckman since 1992. Maybe it is time to reconsider but there are too many conflicting themes to find the truly best solution.

Modern footy surely rewards those who attend as many contests as possible rather than those who "beat their man" and contribute to a result.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

In a way I'm glad tracc didn't win it.

It would have been framed as some sort of consolation. Not by trac or the dees, but by the media. 

To not at last make this years gf is a fail. 

The last thing we need is a consolation to distract from that fact. 

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

48 minutes ago, Macca said:

There isn't an award where the midfielders don't dominate proceedings

Even the coaches very rarely give votes to backmen & forwards.  It's a midfielders medal now as it's hard to standout as a forward and backmen are now part of a zone with flooding a common practice

The only way things will change is if we go back to open forward lines as a staple (and what are the chances of that happening?)

Yup, it gets tiresome.  Accordingly, I consider this year's Brownlow winner to be Toby Greene.  Dude got within 11 votes carrying an entire team on his back from a HFF. 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites


22 minutes ago, Deemania since 56 said:

Nice, realistic connection, there. Is it not time that they became professional and thus, more accountable across the board of their responsibilities? The AFL has deceived us for too long about their respective talents, skills and meritorious service to the game. 

Was discussing this whilst watching the first quarter (Bris and Carlton), they’re professional AND they are part time. That’s an important distinction to be made

On a side note, a good friend of mine was an umpire for 10 years or so with the AFL and post career (roughly 10 years) he has never run more than 2km since. The training is THAT effortful.

Edited by Engorged Onion
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:

Was discussing this whilst watching the first quarter (Bris and Carlton), they’re professional AND they are part time. That’s an important distinction to be made

On a side note, a good friend of mine was an umpire for 10 years or so with the AFL and post career (roughly 10 years) he has never run more than 2km since. The training is THAT effortful.

I haven't run more than 2m for 10 years EO

  • Haha 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Jjrogan said:

Yup, it gets tiresome.  Accordingly, I consider this year's Brownlow winner to be Toby Greene.  Dude got within 11 votes carrying an entire team on his back from a HFF. 

And in the coaches award Toby was 30 votes behind the winner (Butters)

Interesting that the next 5 in the coaches award filled the top 5 in the Brownlow ... in fact the top 6 were the same 6 for each award

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, tiers said:

The result of the Brownlow voting by the umpires might be anomalous compared with the other so called expert awards but, and this is a big but, they are only ones who can see how hard the players are working on the field. It is an award for fairest and best, not for accumulating possessions, and should rightly go to a player who strives the hardest for each possession.

Coaches award votes for the impact on the result which is why, for example, defenders can often win votes for a minimal possession defensive role. This sort of analysis is beyond the umpires on the field and it is no wonder that it throws up different results.

The so called expert awards in the media also appear to be slanted towards favourite or prominent players whose stats sheets are overflowing but who might not have worked as hard or made much of a difference. Think about the "ring-a-rosy" in the backlines that often can inflate stats that have no meaning.

For all the criticism of the umpires voting, there have been no undeserving players (duds) who have won and, in any given year, there are many players who would qualify. There is an element of luck in the result especially when a team has many potential vote winners every week eg Melbourne's Petracca, Oliver, Viney, Gawn.

My own preference would be for a system that selects which player had the most influence on a result (similar to the coaches award) but I acknowledge that this would be too hard to determine by a group of independent umpires in the short time frame after a match.

Leave it alone because there is no demonstratively better system

 

Stop being so reasonable 😉

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There are so many problems with the Brownlow Medal process that it isn't funny. But essentially it's a midfielder's award and Melbourne's elite midfielders take votes off each other. At the Bulldogs Bontempelli is the standout and the only reason he hasn't won the Brownlow is he's playing for a mid-range team that doesn't win enough games. Very hard to get 3 votes if your team has lost the game. Why Neale? Because he's the standout midfielder in a standout team. Clearly be benefitted from Will Ashcroft's season ending early. I feel sorry for Nick Daicos because he deserved to win. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Went to the round 24 Sydney V Melbourne game and there was absolutely no way I left the SCG thinking  Jack Viney was the game winner and the difference maker to warrant him getting the 3 brownlow votes.

Gulden 3, Fritta 2 and Trac 1 should have been the outcome.

Edited by Bring-Back-Powell
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Macca said:

A fair result

Cripps & Viney also polled well above expectations

But the player with the most clearances and 2nd in contested possessions wins the award.  Fair enough

And be careful what you wish for with regards to the umpires not voting on the award ... do we really want biased, dishonest, unfair, compromised people voting on the award?  People like Buckley, Cornes & Robbo?

No thanks

Leave it as it is but I do agree that the stats should be given to the umpires as a guide

Mind you, I've seen plenty of 15 or 20 possession games being the standout and equally, plenty of high possession games having a low impact

The umpires may be placing a high emphasis on clearances & contested possessions (Neale, Cripps, Viney etc)

Yeah I agree that we wouldn't want those types of people voting on the award, so to avoid that risk, I'm happy with it staying with the umpires! 😂

I'd also be reluctant with providing the stats to the umpires at the risk they simply defer to the stats.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


1 hour ago, Jjrogan said:

Yup, it gets tiresome.  Accordingly, I consider this year's Brownlow winner to be Toby Greene.  Dude got within 11 votes carrying an entire team on his back from a HFF. 

There's an idea there - do it like yacht racing. Have the line honours go to the highest vote getter, then have handicaps for various positions.

  • Like 1
  • Thinking 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, tiers said:

It would be interesting to analyse the positions of medal winners over the decades.

I can only recall two full backs - Fred Goldsmith SM 1955, Verdun Howell StK 1959.

Back pocket Bernie Smith Geel 1951, John James Carl 1961; Brad Hardie Foot 1985

CHB - Brian Gleeson StK 1957, Neil Roberts StK1958, Gordon Collis Carl 1964, Ross Glendinning NM 1983

HBF Gavin Wanganeen Ess 1993

CHF Kelvin Templeton Foot 1980

FF Tony Lockett St K 1987

All the others were rucks, rovers, ruck rovers, centres and on-ballers. Not a single set position player since 1993 and not even a single ruckman since 1992. Maybe it is time to reconsider but there are too many conflicting themes to find the truly best solution.

Modern footy surely rewards those who attend as many contests as possible rather than those who "beat their man" and contribute to a result.

Further anamolies but did both Chris Grant (CHF) & Corey McKernan (F/R) get the most votes but miss out due to suspension?  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Jaded No More said:

Sad to see the vitriol directed at Neale online. Like he made the umpires give him votes. Really pathetic. 

Vitriol is at the umps.  Some very bizarre votes were allocated especially the 3s in same games where the player was not in their teams AFL (website) match summary best 5-6, or even in the coaches votes at all.  

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Macca said:

voting on the award?  People like Buckley, Cornes & Robbo?

Since you put it like this, I see your point.

I would leave it with the umpires but maybe take the extra umps of the ground they've added lately and put them in the stands.

Integrity is still there but with increased objectivity.

Or maybe they can review and judge the games post match via video.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, old dee said:

For a long time IMO it has been a centre players award. This year it shows how poor the voting system by the umpires is. The whole thing is devalued. Just a publicity show for the AFL and Media. 

Yep.

Needs to be three awards imv.

> Forwards

> Followers (ruck included of course)

> Defenders

The old Chas is just that.  Very old and dated now.

Need to bring it into the 21st century.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Demonland Forums  

  • Match Previews, Reports & Articles  

    PREGAME: Rd 16 vs Brisbane

    The Demons head back on the road for their fifth interstate trip this season when they head up to Brisbane to take on the Lions under lights on Friday night at the Gabba. Who comes in and who goes out?

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 77

    PODCAST: Rd 15 vs North Melbourne

    The Demonland Podcast will air LIVE on Tuesday, 25th June @ 8:30pm. Join George, Binman & I as we analyse the Demons victory at the MCG over the Kangaroos in the Round 15. You questions and comments are a huge part of our podcast so please post anything you want to ask or say below and we'll give you a shout out on the show. If you would like to leave us a voicemail please call 03 9016 3666 and don't worry no body answers so you don't have to talk to a human. Listen & Chat

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 30

    VOTES: Rd 15 vs North Melbourne

    Captain Max Gawn has a considerable lead over the injured reigning champion Christian Petracca in the Demonland Player of the Year Award. Alex Neal-Bullen, Steven May, & Jack Viney make up the Top 5. Your votes for the loss against the Kangaroos. 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1.

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 43

    POSTGAME: Rd 15 vs North Melbourne

    The Demons almost blew a six goal lead and ultimately hung on to win by three points over the North Melbourne Kangaroos at the MCG and have temporarily jumped back into the Top 8.

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 513

    GAMEDAY: Rd 15 vs North Melbourne

    It's Game Day and it very well could be the last roll of the dice for the Demon's finals aspirations in 2024. A loss to the bottom side would be another embarrassing moment in a cursed year for the Dees whilst a win could be the spark they need to reignite the fire in the belly.

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 709

    THE HUNTER by The Oracle

    Something struck me as I sat on the couch watching the tragedy of North Melbourne’s attempt to beat Collingwood unfold on Sunday afternoon at the MCG.    It was three quarter time, the scoreboard had the Pies on 12.7.79, a respectable 63.16% in terms of goal kicking ratio. Meanwhile, the Roos’ 18.2.110 was off the charts at 90.00% shooting accuracy. I was thinking at the same time of Melbourne’s final score only six days before, a woeful 6.15.51 or 28.57% against Collingwood’s 14.5.89

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 8

    FROZEN by Whispering Jack

    Who would have thought?    Collingwood had a depleted side with several star players out injured, Max Gawn was in stellar form, Christian Petracca at the top of his game and Simon Goodwin was about to pull off a masterstroke in setting Alex Neal-Bullen onto him to do a fantastic job in subduing the Magpies' best player. Goody had his charges primed to respond robustly to the challenge of turning around their disappointing performance against Fremantle in Alice Springs. And if not that, t

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 7

    TURNAROUND by KC from Casey

    The Casey Demons won their first game at home this year in the traditional King’s Birthday Weekend clash with Collingwood VFL on Sunday in a dramatic turnaround on recent form that breathed new life into the beleaguered club’s season. The Demons led from the start to record a 52-point victory. It was their highest score and biggest winning margin by far for the 2024 season. Under cloudy but calm conditions for Casey Fields, the home side, wearing the old Springvale guernsey as a mark of res

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Casey Articles

    PREGAME: Rd 15 vs North Melbourne

    After two disappointing back to back losses the Demons have the bye in Round 14 and then face perennial cellar dweller North Melbourne at the MCG on Saturday night in Round 15. Who comes in and who goes out?

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 509
  • Tell a friend

    Love Demonland? Tell a friend!

×
×
  • Create New...