My 3 word player analysis V StKilda

[joeboy 3,163]

Gawn - stood up outstandingly

May -  an elite performance 

Langdon - prolific and indefatigable 

Oliver - slightly off key

Petracca - was the difference 

Salem - reliable and tight

Rivers - calm and composed

Hibberd - some important clearances

Wagner - rarely looked confident 

Brown - important in fourth

Brayshaw - continues to confound

Tomlinson - jury is out

Viney - couldn’t get going

Melksham - continued disappointing season

Jones - age has wearied 

Lever - reliable and effective 

Weideman - ten minute performance 

McDonald - slow , not terrible 

Spargo - little to commend

vandenBerg - not a wingman

Hannan - couldn’t justify inclusion 

Pickett - played little part

 

[Flower Magic 776]

Oliver - last quarter brilliant

[At the break of Gawn 4,460]

Brown definitely deserves another week. He also looks as quick as Usain Bolt compared to Tmac out there.

[dimmy 1,307]

Wagner : Did his job

Melksham : important link

Salem : best game tonight

[Devil In Disguise 2,278]

Harsh on Wagons. Was solid with good disposal.

[spirit of norm smith 16,228]

Oscar - slow AND terrible

[spirit of norm smith 16,228]

Vandenburg - lost the plot

Hannan - headless chook syndrome 

[spirit of norm smith 16,228]

May - a bloody superstar 

Petracca - nearly A grade

Viney - in the trenches

[Die Hard Demon 1,224]

Melbourne - Too many passengers 

[layzie 33,729]

Pretty much bang on. I was not confident about Wagner but I thought he played a decent game in the end.

While it wasn't Gawn's best performance he certainly battled hard and did everything possible.

[rjay 24,836]

Langdon - love this guy

MFC - get another Langdon

[nosoupforme 3,085]

Petracca      4 great goals

May              His best performance

Oliver            Great last Quarter

Langdon       Is all class

Lever            Back to best

Wagner        give him credit

Rivers           is our future

Gawn           Lead us well

Oscar           Played his role

Viney            gives his all

Salem           consistent as always

Brown          presented all day

spargo          missing in action

                      Rest team effort

 

 

 

 

 

[Dr.D 1,771]

Gawn - didn't appear hampered

May -  Worth every cent

Langdon - Continued underrated season

Oliver - Slow first half

Petracca - 2 or 3 (votes)

Salem - important final kick

Rivers - Looks a find.

Hibberd - has found form

Wagner - just a game

Brown - easily surpassed McDonald 

Brayshaw - disappointing from start

Tomlinson - one needed mark

Viney - resorted to tagging

Melksham - lost lateral movement

Jones -  very costly mistake

Lever - much improved performance 

Weideman - 2 goal quota

McDonald - Casey scorpion reserves

Spargo - very uninspiring display

vandenBerg - makes us slower

Hannan - cant hit scoreboard 

Pickett - starting to worry

[Sir Why You Little 36,939]

Brown: earnt his spot ( in a low scoring game)

[Dame Gaga 2,453]

Trac - Star to Supernova

May - Here There Everywhere

Max - Kept Keeping On

Salem - Kept His Cool

Spargo - Some Good Tackles

Lever - Mopped Up Spillage

Weid - Sparkled At Times

Brown - Steady And Composed

 

 

[Coq au vin 755]

Watch the game again. This was Tomlinson’s best game for us so far. He played very well.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Viney shut down Steele when he went to him.

A huge reason we won the game.

[CBDees 3,167]

10 hours ago, joeboy said:

Gawn - stood up outstandingly

May -  an elite performance 

Langdon - prolific and indefatigable 

Oliver - slightly off key

Petracca - was the difference 

Salem - reliable and tight

Rivers - calm and composed

Hibberd - some important clearances

Wagner - rarely looked confident 

Brown - important in fourth

Brayshaw - continues to confound

Tomlinson - jury is out

Viney - couldn’t get going

Melksham - continued disappointing season

Jones - age has wearied 

Lever - reliable and effective 

Weideman - ten minute performance 

McDonald - slow , not terrible 

Spargo - little to commend

vandenBerg - not a wingman

Hannan - couldn’t justify inclusion 

Pickett - played little part

 

A bit harsh on Wagner. I thought he worked his way into the game well and played his part in an increasingly accomplished back half.

[58er 6,372]

25 minutes ago, Coq au vin said:

Watch the game again. This was Tomlinson’s best game for us so far. He played very well.

Absolutely agree esp in last quarter!!

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

May - absolute super hero

 

 

[D4Life 2,435]

12 hours ago, joeboy said:

Gawn - stood up outstandingly

May -  an elite performance 

Langdon - prolific and indefatigable 

Oliver - slightly off key

Petracca - was the difference 

Salem - reliable and tight

Rivers - calm and composed

Hibberd - some important clearances

Wagner - rarely looked confident 

Brown - important in fourth

Brayshaw - continues to confound

Tomlinson - jury is out

Viney - couldn’t get going

Melksham - continued disappointing season

Jones - age has wearied 

Lever - reliable and effective 

Weideman - ten minute performance 

McDonald - slow , not terrible 

Spargo - little to commend

vandenBerg - not a wingman

Hannan - couldn’t justify inclusion 

Pickett - played little part

 

Oliver - lifted in last

Viney - stopped Steele influence

Spargo - some tackling pressure 

Wagner - better than usual

Tomlinson - some good things

[BW511 2,635]

We can’t expect to be a real threat until we can get consistent effort across the park. A lot of passengers each week and it costs us too often, this week we got off lucky

[titan_uranus 24,963]

Oliver - critical last quarter

May - another AA performane

Viney - tagging role worked

vandenBerg - having no impact

Jones - unfortunately played terribly

13 hours ago, Die Hard Demon said:

Melbourne - Too many passengers 

Melbourne - won despite passengers.

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,762]

1 hour ago, titan_uranus said:

Oliver - critical last quarter

May - another AA performane

Viney - tagging role worked

vandenBerg - having no impact

Jones - unfortunately played terribly

Melbourne - won despite passengers.

I don't understand this point about passengers.

You don't get that defensive structure without everyone on board.

We had players that made mistakes with ball in hand and some of those might miss a game next week, but we shut down a very good running team with a stunning 18-man defence.

One example I would give is Brayshaw. Had a quiet night but he ran constantly from east to west to combat the Saints spread and switch. That's not a passenger in my view.

On a side note, another point I would make is that defensive efforts are not always reflected in tackles or any other stat. Sometimes corralling and forcing a kick to an advantageous position is better than a tackle.

Don't get me wrong, this performance was far from perfect and we have plenty of players that need to get better around the ball and with ball in hand, but you don't get a performance like that from May, for example, without everyone pulling their weight, defensively.

[binman 42,500]

17 minutes ago, Cheesy D. Pun said:

 

One example I would give is Brayshaw. Had a quiet night but he ran constantly from east to west to combat the Saints spread and switch. That's not a passenger in my view.

 

Agree, looked to be really busting a gut all night. There was one where he didn't quite get to the ball carrier but put on just enough pressure to impact the kick inside 50 which we marked.

Won't get a stat but that is exactly what we need from every player. And didn't get from every player last week

Edited August 30, 2020 by binman