My 3 word player analysis V Carlton

[joeboy 3,166]

Jones - consistently found targets

Viney - bullocking and courageous 

McDonald - outstanding until injured

Fritsch - great first half

Oliver - courageous and tireless 

Preuss - finally justified selection

Harmes - important but fumbly

Salem - continued impressive season

Neal-Bullen - just a game

Petracca - brilliant in bursts

Frost - heart in mouth

Hunt - took his chances

Brayshaw - disappointing season continued 

Weideman - failed to impose

Lewis - was rarely sighted

Hibberd - rarely inspired confidence 

May - safe and composed

Hannan - some rare glimpses

Dunkley - deer in headlights

Petty - quiet before injury 

Lockhart - was he playing?

Hore - will be missed

[Return to Glory 8,448]

Jones - some disastrous turnovers

Petty - showing positive signs

[KingDingAling 3,758]

Viney - Cannot knock endeavor 

Oliver - Big last quarter

Preuss - Good back up

Fritsch - Turn over merchant 

Hannan - VFL level player

ANB - Delist after season

Brayshaw - Lucky we're short (injuries)

Petracca - Very good game

Harmes - Solid and consistent 

McDonald - Looked different player

Weideman - Was clunking some (good sign)

Hibberd - Past used by

Salem - Great as always

Frost - Had good patches

Petty - Shows good signs

 

 

[Gorgoroth 13,023]

Viney: always takes on tackles (even when not the best option)

Weid: better at chf

Salem: fumbled twice, weird.

Frost: Dr.Jeckyll and Mr Hyde  

Nibbler: misses goals regularly 

Hunt: cost 4 goals

Hannan: oh he played?

Petty: might have future

Pruess: good game

Jones: good game 

Hibbo: patchy, but solid

Oliver: very good again

Dunkley: good first game

Hore: big loss

Tmac: found form... injured

Trac: play on instinct 

Fritsch: still can’t defend

Brayshaw: lost on wing

Harmes: another solid game

Lewis: past it.

Lockhart: will improve

May: solid again

 

[dimmy 1,308]

Bit harsh on Brayshaw

 His possesion count was low by his standards (which may reflect his role) but I think he had the 3rd highest tackle count ,which is an area he needs to work on. He has been squeezed out of the midfield by rank in that Viney wants in there and oliver's natural position is as a ball magnet . CLArrie was magnificent in the last qtr.

Whilst ANB did have a high tackle/pressure count, he misses too many shots (set and snaps) to be a really top small fwd. Pity, because his effort level is great.

[monoccular 17,575]

Tom McDonald - FMD in fact FMSeason 

Finally after a difficult season he hits good form and !!!

Are there still any non believers in the Curse of Norm Smith?

Edited July 7, 2019 by monoccular

[Lord Nev 13,512]

Mostly agree, only ones I'd change personally are...

Viney - Bullocking but dumb.

Frost - Contract extension time.

Brayshaw - Should be dropped.

Dunkley - Coupla nice moments.

 

[Demon17 5,203]

2 hours ago, joeboy said:

Jones - consistently found targets

Viney - bullocking and courageous 

McDonald - outstanding until injured

Fritsch - great first half

Oliver - courageous and tireless 

Preuss - finally justified selection

Harmes - important but fumbly

Salem - continued impressive season

Neal-Bullen - just a game

Petracca - brilliant in bursts

Frost - heart in mouth

Hunt - took his chances

Brayshaw - disappointing season continued 

Weideman - failed to impose

Lewis - was rarely sighted

Hibberd - rarely inspired confidence 

May - safe and composed

Hannan - some rare glimpses

Dunkley - deer in headlights

Petty - quiet before injury 

Lockhart - was he playing?

Hore - will be missed

Jones. You're joking. 

Dunkley. Some good things under pressure 

May. Saved the game.

Petty. Shows potential 

Frost. Starting 22 in 2020

Neal bullen. B grade

Viney. Not a thinking footballer

Oliver. Leadership in spades

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

1 hour ago, Gorgoroth said:

Viney: always takes on tackles (even when not the best option)

Weid: better at chf

Salem: fumbled twice, weird.

Frost: Dr.Jeckyll and Mr Hyde  

Nibbler: misses goals regularly 

Hunt: cost 4 goals

Hannan: oh he played?

Petty: might have future

Pruess: good game

Jones: good game 

Hibbo: patchy, but solid

Oliver: very good again

Dunkley: good first game

Hore: big loss

Tmac: found form... injured

Trac: play on instinct 

Fritsch: still can’t defend

Brayshaw: lost on wing

Harmes: another solid game

Lewis: past it.

Lockhart: will improve

May: solid again

 

I didn't see the game. How did Hunt in our forward zone cost us 4 goals? Name the occasions please.

[old dee 23,872]

52 minutes ago, Bobby McKenzie said:

I didn't see the game. How did Hunt in our forward zone cost us 4 goals? Name the occasions please.

Very good question Booby I am as mistified as you. Kicked 3 goals including the winner. Not a bad effort for a half forward. 

Edited July 7, 2019 by old dee

[Anti-Saint 245]

Hunt had a handpass late on the wing southern side and we are streaming forward desperate to halt the Hordes from RPC (Royal Parade Cheaters).

Hunt needed to find a team-mate, who had implied pressure so handpass had to hit target (that's an expectation at this level) but ball bounced in front of team-mate (can't recall who) and it was TO - can't recall if RPC got a goal out of it but that was one.

Hunt did take a contested and well judged mark in the third term and then converted but I agree with comment Hunt caused three other TOs.

 

[pitmaster 3,578]

4 hours ago, joeboy said:

Dunkley - deer in headlights

 

 

Errr...three goal assists.

Edited July 7, 2019 by pitmaster

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

1 hour ago, Anti-Saint said:

Hunt had a handpass late on the wing southern side and we are streaming forward desperate to halt the Hordes from RPC (Royal Parade Cheaters).

Hunt needed to find a team-mate, who had implied pressure so handpass had to hit target (that's an expectation at this level) but ball bounced in front of team-mate (can't recall who) and it was TO - can't recall if RPC got a goal out of it but that was one.

Hunt did take a contested and well judged mark in the third term and then converted but I agree with comment Hunt caused three other TOs.

 

So another poster who only  watches the game for errors

[Dame Gaga 2,453]

Oliver - Run, Clarrie, Run!

Hunt - Goal In Time

Trac - Some Great Efforts

Preuss - Welcome To MCG

Marty - Get Well Soon?

TommyMac - 100 Then Out?

Team - Hung In There

 

[rjay 25,093]

4 hours ago, Lord Nev said:

Brayshaw - Should be dropped.

Some of his defensive work & tackling were A grade today.

He saved us on a number of occasions with a hand in or by sticking a big tackle.

Wasn't a big possession game but he played his part...

 

[Fanatique Demon 2,657]

Petty: too many errors

Lewis: better than expected 

[Dockett 32 1,239]

Geez l thought it was a good effort with our injuries.

In years gone by likely to have been a different outcome.

 

[John Demonic 5,850]

Alex-Neal Buggen - Missed gettable shots.

Edited July 7, 2019 by John Demonic

[Gorgoroth 13,023]

9 hours ago, Bobby McKenzie said:

I didn't see the game. How did Hunt in our forward zone cost us 4 goals? Name the occasions please.

Missed a simple handball on the wing that would have put us in the clear and into an empty f50 with numbers advantage, instead he turned it over and they kicked a goal.

Second a poor handball 10 meters out from goal resulted in a scramble instead of an easy goal.

centred the ball at the top of the 50 to an outnumber whilst under no pressure and they ran it down the other end.

He turned the ball over badly with simple skill errors.

He was as bad as he was good.

[Sorry kids 635]

Keep playing

Petty needs games

Dunkley clever skills

Wiedeman future key

[Dee Zephyr 19,269]

Hunt- Clutch under pressure.

[Lord Nev 13,512]

7 hours ago, rjay said:

Some of his defensive work & tackling were A grade today.

He saved us on a number of occasions with a hand in or by sticking a big tackle.

Wasn't a big possession game but he played his part...

Sure, finally decided to lay a tackle once he was put in the middle, but still seems to be struggling to get around to contests. 2 clearances is poor IMO, and his disposal is not any better. Just think he's been 'off' all year and if he's carrying a niggle (which I've heard is the case) he should be sent off to get right for preseason.

 

[binman 43,813]

10 hours ago, Anti-Saint said:

Hunt had a handpass late on the wing southern side and we are streaming forward desperate to halt the Hordes from RPC (Royal Parade Cheaters).

Hunt needed to find a team-mate, who had implied pressure so handpass had to hit target (that's an expectation at this level) but ball bounced in front of team-mate (can't recall who) and it was TO - can't recall if RPC got a goal out of it but that was one.

Hunt did take a contested and well judged mark in the third term and then converted but I agree with comment Hunt caused three other TOs.

 

He missed weed in exactly the same way after that. Cost us a certain goal (he hits the handpass and weed kicks an easy goal from the goal square). It went straight up the other end for a goal.

Not long after he missed an easy target inside 50 by foot, which is par for the course for us, But the problem was that he turned it over in tbe corridor and it got swept down tbe other end. Fortunately not for a goal i don't think.

So, yes as one of the commentators noted he was given a chance to redeem his errors. And all credit to him that he took that chance.

There was another bad mistake that seemed to  escape the commentators attention and demonland's as well. On that last kick by hannan he had hunt and brayshaw on over the top, with hunt being completely in the clear. Should have handball it to him and hunt would have run into an open goal.

[binman 43,813]

2 hours ago, Gorgoroth said:

Missed a simple handball on the wing that would have put us in the clear and into an empty f50 with numbers advantage, instead he turned it over and they kicked a goal.

Second a poor handball 10 meters out from goal resulted in a scramble instead of an easy goal.

centred the ball at the top of the 50 to an outnumber whilst under no pressure and they ran it down the other end.

He turned the ball over badly with simple skill errors.

He was as bad as he was good.

Missed this post. Could have saved myself some time by quoting it!

[Nasher 33,617]

The odd splattered disposal is a feature of Hunt’s game in general unfortunately, particularly by hand. I place him in a similar category to Frost - plays an exciting style of game and does a lot right, but always a chance to do a few things in a game that make your eyes water.

Surprised at the negativity on Jones’ game. I thought he had a pretty tidy game, especially considering he was on for the entire second half without break. Where and when were these terrible mistakes?