Changes v Essendon

[DemonLad5 1,642]

In: C. Wagner, Stretch, Preuss

Out: May (inj), Sparrow, ANB

Edited March 31, 2019 by DemonLad5

[Dockett 32 1,239]

7 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

May will be injured and Oscar, Frost, KK, Lockhart, ANB, Sparrow don’t really look up to it whilst Weid, Jones, Hunt, Petracca, T Mc and even Hibberd and Fritsch are struggling.

It’s a disaster really. After 6 debuts in 2 weeks I don’t think kids are the answer although we probably need at least 1 more debut with a big bloke.

I’d probably go T Smith, Keilty, Stretch and C Wagner for Weid, May, ANB and Sparrow and move Jones to half back. 

Seems a few are desperately trying to find a spot for Jones to reinvent himself.

Not sure if this is in the best interests of the side. He has had a spot for two weeks and under performed.

If he stays in, like everyone else he must perform.

[Lucifers Hero 39,811]

A bit ominous for Viney?  "...icepack on his troublesome right foot during the post-game interview, but he said the treatment was only precautionary after he underwent ankle surgery at the end of 2018."  https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-03-31/demons-ready-to-bite-in-battle-of-hungry-teams

Viney's 27 possessions at 74.4% eff'y, 8 tackles and 8 inside 50's are a super effort for only 3/4 of the game while still not fully fit.  We needed him to step up this week; such a shame the team couldn't capitalise on his work.

Not suggesting he won't play next week but his ground time is still being managed:  a little over 2.5 qtrs last week and 3 qtrs this week? 

Hope that in our desperation we don't push it too far.

Edited March 31, 2019 by Lucifer's Hero

[IvanBartul13 2,564]

20 minutes ago, McQueen said:

Just get rid of Neal Bullen please. 

His involvements last night were bizarre to say the least and the kid manages to kill momentum like nobody’s business. 

Frustrates the absolute [censored] out of me. 

Comfortably my most disliked player in over 30 years of supporting the club with his unnecessary look away handballs and tackling people in congestion that are going to be tackled anyway.  The worst part of him is that he refuses to put his head in the hole or to bodyline the ball or the players he is tackling.  He misses and doesn't stick so many tackles that would actually mean anything because of this and he never safely wins disputed ball.  An absolutely horrific player who looks half decent when we are dominating but who is a conman of the highest order.

Edited March 31, 2019 by goodoil

[Brownie 5,981]

Not bombing it blindly into the forward line would be my most favoured change.

I remember us doing this early last year. It should have been addressed by quarter time last night ffs.

 

[Laughing Goat 308]

2 hours ago, Demon Dude said:

I think we need to have our wingmen hold space at centre bounces and general play, then look to have our mids kick sideways/short to them to open up our fwd 50 more. We need to get it to the outside so weid and tmac can find the space to get on the lead inside f50.

Atm we are too predictable in our ball movement. Enough of just bombing down the middle from clearances. It just forms a pack inside 50 with all our blokes getting in each others way and then creates a lot of space for the oppo to run it out easily. With our lack of leg speed it plays into opposition hands and they can move it easily down field to score.

We need to spread, take more uncontested marks and move it more deliberately. So I'd be dropping the butcher's and bringing in the better kicks.

Out- ANB, Hunt, Sparrow, May inj.

In- Spargo, Baker, CWagner, hore

B- Jetta  Oscar  hibberd

HB- Salem frost  hore

C- Fritsch  harmes brayshaw

HF- Trac  weid  spargo

FF- Wagner tmac  melk

R- Gawn Oliver  viney

Int- lockhart kk Jones baker

 

 

 

Unfortunately Hore won't come in as he was carry over emergency & didn't play yesterday, so will need to go back to Casey.  Also I have only heard snipit's about Casey's game but apparently Spargo was disappointing........Baker maybe, but don't think so as he has missed a lot of preseason & we want match fit guys coming in.

Keilty, Pruess & Stretch obvious selections

 

[stinga 566]

Sparrow Has had a taste and will be a good player but not yet and cant be carried in a side under performing

Petracca needs to go back to Casey and get some confidence.  Can't mark, can't kick and can't chase and fumbles at the moment.

Neale Bullen - all at sea at the moment and can't get to where the ball is

Hunt - should have been left forward but now lost confidence and needs to go back to casey and played as a forward.  Let him get a couple of bags of goals and then bring him back as a defensive forward.

B Jetta McDonald Keilty

HB Hibbert May Frost

C Viney Oliver Salem

HF Melksham Weid Tim Smith

F Lockhart McDonald Preuss

R Gawn Harmes Brayshaw

Int  KK Jones Fritsch  Baker

Of the doubtfulls 

May gets benefit of the doubt due to corky but has to attack the ball more and no silly free kicks in front of goal

Jetta maybe carrying an injury, but too good to throw out.  He'll come good

Keilty deserves a chance to show what he's got

Frost  Makes blunders but there is a lot of upside when he goes well.  Gives better balance as 3rd tall

Weid - we just have to persevere

Tim Smith - At least he can take a mark and certainly adds pressure

Lockhart -  did enough and you don't drop a kid on 1 game unless he has a shocker

Preuss - The only time their back line looked under pressure was when Gawn went forward and 2 or 3 had to go up against him.  They have to try it at some stage.  McD and Weid are good runners so you don't lose too much defensive run in our forward line.

Jones and Fritta are making mistakes but at least they are getting the ball

KK looked ok but went missing too much.  Deserves at least 2 games.

Baker is a taller and quick midfielder who can't do any worse than  the ones left out.  They might want him to do more game time at casey , but I'd take the chance.

 

 

 

 

[KingDingAling 3,758]

3 hours ago, scarlett said:

Keilty has been playing forward ruck and has been showing enough to be ahead of what pruess showed in jlt. 

Agree completely with leaving t-mac forward, but the effective disposal is also to blame on our key forwards and coaches, they need to make space for each other and charge out and demand the kicker to attempt the kick. Jogging around the forward 50 all flying in the same pack didnt work last year and isnt going to work this year. Which brings my next question, t-mac started well both games leading and taking marks all over the ground, but ran out of gas pretty quick and reverted to wanting it bombed on his head, he was always in the top group in pre season time trials, has his toe taken away his ability to get the miles in taking away one of his top strengths?

Pruess in, would weaken our forward pressure way to much, its poor now. he struggled running out a half in jlt 1, Keilty offered more up forward and competed in the ruck, while smashing pruess around the ground. It would also keep at least 2 kpp playing as forwards stopping the opposition backman outnumbering our talls.

Good observations scarlett.

[Drunkn167 5,093]

Hore will come in for May as he was the carryover.

And for those saying Keilty to play back, he has trained as a Key Forward all preseason and that’s where he’s played the last 4 games. There’s Hore and Petty in front of him so there’s no chance of him playing as a defender. 

Hes had 2 strong games in the VFL and Goody gave Keilty a mention in his presser so hopefully Friday night at the G will finally be his debut.

[scarlett 247]

4 minutes ago, Drunkn167 said:

Hore will come in for May as he was the carryover.

And for those saying Keilty to play back, he has trained as a Key Forward all preseason and that’s where he’s played the last 4 games. There’s Hore and Petty in front of him so there’s no chance of him playing as a defender. 

Hes had 2 strong games in the VFL and Goody gave Keilty a mention in his presser so hopefully Friday night at the G will finally be his debut.

And a deserved debut drunkn. Dec has put himself clearly in front of new recruit pruess. Last year he would have good moments in quarters, so far this year it seems something clicked and is finding himself more involved between those moments. Hope he can continue his trajectory. 

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,396]

Jones is doing a Grimes.

[dazzledavey36 54,944]

I'm glad people on here are starting to realise just how much of a dud ANB is.. its only taken some of you 2 years to finally take notice.

[manny100 1,557]

Inside 50s to burn but fizzled. No clever small with pace to crumb, goal, and apply pressure to the rebounder. Who sorts this out? No outstanding tall to take a mark and goal. Noticed when Gawn rested late first quarter the Cats got easy goals. Maybe bring Preuss in to assist in the ruck and Gawn to play a little more forward. Obviously lacking composure but not sure how to fix this - maybe a confidence thing?

 

[DemonOX 8,791]

Omac needs to go back to the 2s to get some confidence and skills but unfortunately I don’t think it will happen.

Not sure what it is but he has more lives than a cat.  

Edited March 31, 2019 by DemonOX

[DeeSpencer 25,711]

5 hours ago, Dockett 32 said:

Seems a few are desperately trying to find a spot for Jones to reinvent himself.

Not sure if this is in the best interests of the side. He has had a spot for two weeks and under performed.

If he stays in, like everyone else he must perform.

It's not so much about reinventing Jones but using what he still has - experience and ability to know where the ball is going - as well as adding what the team needs which is that experience at half back to make sure the set ups are right and hopefully control possession. 

That said, the wing was always a reinvention for him and I was never convinced it would work. Back or forward made more sense to me. Lewis had that position at half back but if he's out Jones should have a go at it.

We also don't have near 22 players who are performing, so we should be working out which players can contribute in roles that make others better. Be it physicality, leadership, unrewarded running etc.

[spirit of norm smith 16,459]

It’s not really about Manpower and which player is in or out.  

It’s attitude and game plan.

3 simple ins and outs.  

Ins.

1- smart footy. 

2- skilled disposals

3- tackle effectiveness

outs. 

1- bombing the footy inside 50

2- turnovers 

3- fumbles

[Dame Gaga 2,453]

Somebody needs to find the ON switch.

[dazzledavey36 54,944]

Be interesting to see how Brayshaw pulls up. Will be a light week for him with lots of icing up and stationary bike work.

[DV8 2,271]

18 hours ago, KingDingAling said:

Hunt isn't finished at Melbourne. We need his run. We need his run out of our backline, as he was good last week at times. Why did he look so ordinary tonight (among many?). Because we had no structure or game plan running the ball out of our backline. When Hunt looks good its when he has space. How do we get him space? Get the ball in the hands of Salem who can find him space. Tonight Salem locked down Ablett early and we had rushed players like Hibberd and rusty players like May kicking out. So you say Hunt is finished at Melbourne, but take him out and we still lack run, and its not Jayden Hunt's fault that he isn't getting that space.

So you want to move Keilty up forward? Based on what? Its speculative and desperate. Tom McDonald has actually shown something up forward. Keep him there. He isn't our problem. Our problem is our lack of effective disposal inside forward 50. If Tom McDonald had clean disposal coming into him he'd be kicking straight and there would be no problem. MFC have a big problem, but it isn't our players, its our coaching and their lack of structure and planning. We have have the best ruck in the game, the cleanest first touch mid in the game - Oliver - yet we are still hacking it inside forward 50. So something is either going wrong from Gawn to Oliver, or Oliver to forward 50, and if that is no Oliver substitute that for Brayshaw. These guys hack the football when they need to be working as a unit to dispose the ball effectively into our forward 50.

It's not wining the contested ball thats the issue...  it's quality of the clearance away from the contest that's the biggest issue.   And we need receivers in good position so they can run and go with the footy. Delivering well.

We're at our best when TMc plays high through the midzone and pushes back into F50.  He can turn things into mismatches, taking marks on re-entry.

Having Keilty in F50 to take away extra attention on Weide is a good idea.  2 focal points,  as long as they don't crowd one another.

Keilty can give Gawn a chop-out,  allowing Gawn forward for a spell.  Again creating problems for the opposition backs.

 

But we need more mosquito fleet...  and no Tracca forward to slow us up.

[Laughing Goat 308]

5 hours ago, Drunkn167 said:

Hore will come in for May as he was the carryover.

And for those saying Keilty to play back, he has trained as a Key Forward all preseason and that’s where he’s played the last 4 games. There’s Hore and Petty in front of him so there’s no chance of him playing as a defender. 

Hes had 2 strong games in the VFL and Goody gave Keilty a mention in his presser so hopefully Friday night at the G will finally be his debut.

I don't know everything about footy, but what I do know is that the players HATE being carryover! Reason why......because they know that as carryover & missing a week of footy, they have to go back to Casey to re-gain form, momentum, fitness etc.

I will bet my left nut that M Hore will be playing for Casey next week.

Petty & Keilty deserve to play......good luck to them.

[rjay 24,928]

6 hours ago, stinga said:

Sparrow Has had a taste and will be a good player

Sorry 'stinga', he may be a good player down the track but has shown nothing to date that indicates he will be.

As much as I want him to be, wishing won't make it so.

[DeeSpencer 25,711]

3 minutes ago, rjay said:

Sorry 'stinga', he may be a good player down the track but has shown nothing to date that indicates he will be.

As much as I want him to be, wishing won't make it so.

Spot on. Had a couple of nice kicks against Port, competed well in the air, put his head over it and looked like the running wasn't too much for him. I'd say at this stage with any kind of decent development he should be at least a guy who carves out a career. Certainly way too early to say whether he'll be good or not.

We're getting a pretty rude reminder right now that development of players isn't linear.

Petracca, Stretch, Kolo, Fritsch, Weideman, Hunt, ANB, Joel Smith, Oscar are all in that 22-24 year old range and we don't even know what they are or will be over the next few years, yet alone the 18 year olds.

[drysdale demon 4,836]

22 minutes ago, rjay said:

Sorry 'stinga', he may be a good player down the track but has shown nothing to date that indicates he will be.

As much as I want him to be, wishing won't make it so.

he showed enough in the first game he will be okay

[Wiseblood 24,637]

5 hours ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Jones is doing a Grimes.

Yep, he is.... just with 200 extra games under his belt as he gets to the end of his career.  Which is nothing like what Grimes did.  

[dazzledavey36 54,944]

2 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Yep, he is.... just with 200 extra games under his belt as he gets to the end of his career.  Which is nothing like what Grimes did.  

Its a bizzare comment... and a disgrace to even put Jones in the same bracket as Grimes. I thought Jones played well last night.

I still feel he can add to our inside on ball brigade at times though.