Simon Goodwin era starts today

[rjay 25,197]

The Goodwin era really starts this Saturday against the Saints.

As a first year coach I think he's been a little too anxious to make his mark.

He's put it on the line and I think some of his decisions over the preseason will mean he doesn't get the honeymoon period most new coaches get.

Players and the media will be watching...

Win/Loss will be crucial early in the season otherwise pressure will mount quickly.

Good luck Simon.

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

On 24/02/2017 at 2:04 PM, rjay said:

I know most won't agree but I think Goodwin has made a few 1st year coach missteps to date, I will keep them to myself as I don't want to get into side issues.

Absolutely. Even if he hadn't, he will yet.

A a first year coach  (albeit with a long apprenticeship) of course he will take some false steps. Almost by definition!

Look at Steve Smith as OZ cricket captain. Has made some howlers. But you can see him learning as he goes. He's improving all the time. (But pls don't refer to the 3rd Test in Injah.)

Goodwin hasn't got an A on his report card yet. Let's see how his decisions on Watts, Spencer, Jetta, etc, etc, turn out before we condemn him to death, or deify him.

But no alarm bells going off yet, nor should there be.

[Willmoy1947 4,165]

I'm just waiting to say "Goodwin Goodwin" first, because that's nice......

[pinkshark 950]

On 14/09/2016 at 8:18 PM, Lord Travis said:

Said the succession plan has been smooth process unlike a team across the road (dig at Malthouse to Buckley transition).

The succession plan will be proved a success if he achieves more than ten wins I reckon.  He has it all ahead of him.  I like others on here have seen a few things that make me a wee bit nervous.  I don't reckon he's handled Watts right.  The co-captains idea is ridiculous.  But most of what I have seen and heard from him is just normal pre season talk/mantra.  All the conjecture and BS is over.  It's money time now for Goody and I hope he brings it.

[Lucifers Hero 40,426]

A fascinating insight into our new coach, some new news, some things we already knew.  http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/melbourne-demons-coach-simon-goodwin-living-the-dream-despite-painful-memories-20170323-gv4y5c.html

I hope that one day when everyone is retired we learn a lot more about the transition from Roos to Goodwin.  It goes like this:  Goodwin: "I'm sure I was bloody frustrating at times but he handed over training really early and deferred to me in so many ways – list management, trade decisions – and we spoke at length about strategy and our different views. He'd always challenge me but he showed a lot of patience."  Roos explained it this way: "There were a few meetings where I'd just say: 'Mate I believe in what you're doing just go your hardest.' And he knew that.

Its easy to underestimate Roos' impact in the successful transition.  Goodwin could not have had a better teacher.

Tomorrow, Goodwin stands on his own two feet.  Hope the team give your reign a better start than the farewell game they gave Roos at Kardinia Park last year.

Good luck, Goody.  Go Dees

 

[dazzledavey36 55,453]

Just a typical true blue aussie bloke. Loves a beer, loves his mates, loves his fishing and probably still has a punt or two every now and then.

Its no wonder the players love him. Id like my coach too if he was inviting me and the boys over for a beer and a barby!

All the best Goody!

[Juicebox 628]

On 22/03/2017 at 6:47 PM, pinkshark said:

The succession plan will be proved a success if he achieves more than ten wins I reckon.  He has it all ahead of him.  I like others on here have seen a few things that make me a wee bit nervous.  I don't reckon he's handled Watts right.  The co-captains idea is ridiculous.  But most of what I have seen and heard from him is just normal pre season talk/mantra.  All the conjecture and BS is over.  It's money time now for Goody and I hope he brings it.

 Re Watts and the co-captaincy 

Only time will tell whether they were good 'coaching' moves or not. Besides, us supporters don't know the full story or what goes on behind closed doors that led Goodwin to make his decisions.

whaddaya say we back the guy in at least until his coached a game or two?

 

 

[Dee Gee 148]

4 hours ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

A fascinating insight into our new coach, some new news, some things we already knew.  http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/melbourne-demons-coach-simon-goodwin-living-the-dream-despite-painful-memories-20170323-gv4y5c.html

I hope that one day when everyone is retired we learn a lot more about the transition from Roos to Goodwin.  It goes like this:  Goodwin: "I'm sure I was bloody frustrating at times but he handed over training really early and deferred to me in so many ways – list management, trade decisions – and we spoke at length about strategy and our different views. He'd always challenge me but he showed a lot of patience."  Roos explained it this way: "There were a few meetings where I'd just say: 'Mate I believe in what you're doing just go your hardest.' And he knew that.

Its easy to underestimate Roos' impact in the successful transition.  Goodwin could not have had a better teacher.

Tomorrow, Goodwin stands on his own two feet.  Hope the team give your reign a better start than the farewell game they gave Roos at Kardinia Park last year.

Good luck, Goody.  Go Dees

 

I don't get stuck into Caro as much as most people, but her article states that Goody is the 28th Melbourne Coach when he's the 31st. Sloppy journalism.

[Members' Wing 1,106]

48 minutes ago, Dee Gee said:

I don't get stuck into Caro as much as most people, but her article states that Goody is the 28th Melbourne Coach when he's the 31st. Sloppy journalism.

Well it depends whether you count caretaker coaches. Wouldn't call it sloppy journalism.

[Dee Gee 148]

7 minutes ago, Members' Wing said:

Well it depends whether you count caretaker coaches. Wouldn't call it sloppy journalism.

I would.

[puntkick 325]

10 minutes ago, Members' Wing said:

Well it depends whether you count caretaker coaches. Wouldn't call it sloppy journalism.

Words F"n fail me !

[640MD 3,482]

1 hour ago, Dee Gee said:

I don't get stuck into Caro but her article states that Goody is the 28th Melbourne Coach when he's the 31st. 

Bugger the sloppy journalism    what a fantastic number to coach at.   Take your teeth out Goody and win a bag of games, its up to you

Every time I think of Barras   I think of the picture of him watching the flight of the ball after just kicking it, off the ground, arms splayed out, grin on his face and no teeth.   Go Dees

[Akum 2,660]

Re Watts & co-captains & picking Weid:

Don't mind him making mistakes - in fact, if he doesn't make mistakes, he's probably not doing it right.

As long as he puts his hand up when he does - like he expects the players to do - and learns from them.

The last guy who was confronted with the task of transitioning from Assistant Coach to Head Coach was constitutionally incapable of acknowledging his mistakes & learning from them. It's a tough gig.

Hope Goody's made of better stuff.

[Members' Wing 1,106]

9 hours ago, puntkick said:

Words F"n fail me !

Pardon?

[tiers 2,860]

Interesting to hear Roosy's comments on Foxtel. We played the width of the ground and kicked short into the forward line. Fundamental change to game style but it left us vulnerable down the corridor when they scored easy goals on the rebound.

Couldn't we have done it last year and stopped kicking it to Jesse on three in the goal square? Still, it is a new year and we will be in the 8 for sure.

[pinkshark 950]

On 24/03/2017 at 6:00 PM, Juicebox said:

 Re Watts and the co-captaincy 

Only time will tell whether they were good 'coaching' moves or not. Besides, us supporters don't know the full story or what goes on behind closed doors that led Goodwin to make his decisions.

whaddaya say we back the guy in at least until his coached a game or two?

 

 

I'll back him in all day mate.  I just reckon co-captains is new age BS.  Jones is our captain.  Simple.  And I'm Watts's biggest fan.

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

Possible emerging trend after two rounds.

First round, quarter time, when it looked like unravelling. Goodwin got them reset and back on the job.

Second round, three quarter time. Same thing.

Whether mental or gameplan, in previous years once the tone of the day was set, it stayed that way.

This is a pleasant new experience. Although I don't want too many games where Goodwin needs to "change the tone".

[Dockett 32 1,239]

Really like the way Goody handles himself in Media interviews. Thought the latest one on the MFC site was very composed, despite a couple of moronic questions.

Happy the footy is in his hands,

[binman 44,182]

22 minutes ago, Dockett 32 said:

Really like the way Goody handles himself in Media interviews. Thought the latest one on the MFC site was very composed, despite a couple of moronic questions.

Happy the footy is in his hands,

He has a a funny way about him in interviews. Sort of over practised. A bit stiff or uncomfotable with lots of repittive messages, for example he loves the word journey.

But ut is endearing. He often seems to be about to start laughing. And he did when asked about the relevance of last years shelacking by the cats having batted away the same sort of questions the previous two weeks. No relevance.chaps

[hells bells 2,023]

On 4/3/2017 at 10:44 AM, Ted Fidge said:

Possible emerging trend after two rounds.

First round, quarter time, when it looked like unravelling. Goodwin got them reset and back on the job.

Second round, three quarter time. Same thing.

Whether mental or gameplan, in previous years once the tone of the day was set, it stayed that way.

This is a pleasant new experience. Although I don't want too many games where Goodwin needs to "change the tone".

It's been a similar trend through the JLT games this year and the pre-season games last year.  

Play well, get challenged, tweak things, get the result.  

[puntkick 325]

Many decry Brad Scott for what he's done at north.

Many acclaim what Chris Scott has done at geelong.

Watch Goody eclipse both of them today in 3 games !

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Why I love about goody is he isn't scared to throw things around, he seems to have total buy in, which hasn't happened in years