Trade Radio Discussion

[DemonOX 8,541]

Just said on SEN that we may be looking at Curnow or Weid for pic 3 and a middy for pic10.

May also bid on a Sydney mid from their academy but cant remember the name.

[DemonOX 8,541]

Sorry but if you get told something then Josh Mahoney says it's completely false 5 minutes later, you should probably question the word of whoever is giving you that information.

Yeah probably but still no need for the abuse.

If you were talking to him face to face would you still say it? That's all I'm saying.

[wattsindawes 57]

Curnow looks like a fyfe/stringer type.. Could get that big body player Roos likes

[wattsindawes 57]

Just said on SEN that we may be looking at Curnow or Weid for pic 3 and a middy for pic10.

May also bid on a Sydney mid from their academy but cant remember the name.

Hopper maybe?

[Scipio 5,868]

Curnow looks like a fyfe/stringer type.. Could get that big body player Roos likes

They are fairly different players IMO. Wouldn't mind either of them though!

[Beats 190]

Just said on SEN that we may be looking at Curnow or Weid for pic 3 and a middy for pic10.

May also bid on a Sydney mid from their academy but cant remember the name.

Mentioned bidding for callum mills(syd), hopper and possibly kennedy(both gws), in that order. I would like this, unless Sydney bring in a ton more picks it pretty much removes them from the draft and possibly mortgages them for next year as well, will pretty much remove gws from the draft as well.

[DemonOX 8,541]

Hopper maybe?

Sorry watts cant remember. Getting old is a bitzh!!

Looks like Beats is onto it.

Edited October 21, 2015 by DemonOX

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

Agr

You're batting 0.500

• very early call on Neeld
• Dangerfield outfield catch last year

picked neeld's exit - bind freddy could have guessed

picked Roos early and first - potentially solid.

Jake Lever a lock at pick 3 - fail

Dangerfield and Kennedy are dees - fail

Trading pick 3 and 10 now - not looking good.

Edited October 21, 2015 by Norm Smith's Curse

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

No need for the abuse Seraph, GNF is just passing on what he has heard.

Just cause he says it doesn't mean it will happen but could maybe be a possibility.

It's crazy that people STILL don't get that what comes out of Mahoney's mouth is not necessarily the reality of what's going on

[Deemotivated 550]

It's crazy that people STILL don't get that what comes out of Mahoney's mouth is not necessarily the reality of what's going on

Agreed

[H_T 2,941]

Trading pick 3 and 10 now - not looking good.

You can rule that out, given what Mahoney stated. Wrong.

[Ethan Tremblay 28,469]

Why would GC do that deal?

[Grapeviney 8,869]

We only give up a top 4 pick if we finish in the bottom 4. Plus, strength of a draft typically refers to how deep it runs - I haven't paid attention to the draft for a few years but typically the top 10 players are similar in talent year to year and it's the depth of talent that varies dramatically.

Also, as it's a picks for picks deal the points system can be applied for analysis:

3(2,234 points), 10(1,395) and 43(378) = 4,007 points

6(1,751), 29(653) = 2,404 points

The points difference is 1,603 points, equivalent to pick 8 (between 7&8). So if we finish 11th or higher we 'win', 12th or lower and we 'lose'.

The day they introduced the points system in the draft was like the day they started teaching algebra at school.

I went from advanced maths class to remedial in about a week, and 30 + years later I'm still trying to figure out what's going on.

[H_T 2,941]

Why would GC do that deal?

Strong hand next year? May get who they want at 6? Who knows there could be a couple of reasons. They got pick 29 from us which they've just used to get Rosa from West Coast. That could be a big part of it too.

Edited October 21, 2015 by H_T

[Middymalt 244]

Melksham if consistent may work and release Salem but we have no idea how Salem will go in the midfield and as for Kennedy we really have no idea what he will bring, it could be good but will need t wait and c.

"Potentially" is the key word in your last sentence.

correct silly post by WB Salems never played in the middle and Kents constantly injured.

[mikeydemon 126]

Strong hand next year? May get who they want at 6? Who knows there could be a couple of reasons. They got pick 29 from us which they've just used to get Rosa from West Coast. That could be a big part of it too.

Also according to the AFL website GC have at least one highly rated academy player coming through next year so the extra first round pick will help them with points

[Chris 2,892]

Why would GC do that deal?

Points for next years academy talent.

[dazzledavey36 48,999]

correct silly post by WB Salems never played in the middle and Kents constantly injured.

Salem played as an onballer at TAC cup and was averaging 140 plus supercoach point which is outrageous.

The kid is capable

[Akum 2,660]

Strong hand next year? May get who they want at 6? Who knows there could be a couple of reasons. They got pick 29 from us which they've just used to get Rosa from West Coast. That could be a big part of it too.

Points for next years academy talent.

Interesting - classic win-win.

So much better than trading with clubs that think they've always got to come out on top.

The coup of the trading period so far, especially as it seems to work very well for both parties.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

correct silly post by WB Salems never played in the middle and Kents constantly injured.

Salem played as an onballer at TAC cup and was averaging 140 plus supercoach point which is outrageous.

The kid is capable

Thank you.

Salem was drafted as a midfielder. He'll slot in very nicely there for us in the coming years.

[DeeMfc 621]

Salem played as an onballer at TAC cup and was averaging 140 plus supercoach point which is outrageous.

The kid is capable

Yep.

With Salem, Viney,Vandenburg, Jones, Kennedy, Kent, Brayshaw, Melksham and Petracca rotating through the midfield they will get the nickname the 'wrecking ball'!

Other teams will be too scared to go for contested possessions.

Inside/outside class from Tyson, Vince, Stretch, Garlett, ANB and Watts.

Edit - forgot Jones!

Double Edit - How the hell could I leave out Vandenburg!!!

Edited October 21, 2015 by DeeMfc

[rjay 23,961]

Yep.

With Salem, Viney, Jones, Kennedy, Kent, Brayshaw, Melksham and Petracca rotating through the midfield they will get the nickname the 'wrecking ball'!

Other teams will be too scared to go for the contested possessions.

Edit - forgot Jones!

Also forgot Tyson...

[DeeMfc 621]

Also forgot Tyson...

He's more the class side of things.

Certainly not forgotten.

I think he has the best chance of a brownlow from our current crop if he can regain last years form and build from there.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Just off topic from the club, but:

What do you guys make of Carlton's deal to send Menzel back to SA for a second round pick and Kerridge, a bloke who played 1 senior game for the Crows in 2015?

I know they are probably sending that pick to GWS for 4 average footballers, but it seems like they are giving up on a bloke who I thought showed a bit of potential and x-factor, something their list seriously lacks.

[Demon Jack 6,342]

On the topic of other trades:

Rosa has been traded to the Gold Coast in exchange for pick 31

Menzel (Carl) has been traded to the Crows for Kerridge and pick 28.