Changes For Next Week

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,223]

Out: Dawes, Stretch, Salem, Toumpas, Howe, Spencer

In: Hogan, Viney, Jetta, ANB, Watts, Gawn

Edited May 16, 2015 by big_red_fire_engine

[Jaded No More 68,967]

Out: Dawes, Stretch, Salem, Toumpas, Howe, Spencer

In: Hogan, Viney, Jetta, ANB, Watts, Gawn

This but swap Gawn with Jamar

[DeeSpencer 25,765]

Out: Spencer, Bail, Toumpas, Dawes, Michie, Salem, M Jones

In: Jamar, Watts, Harmes, Hogan, Viney, Jetta, Newton

FB: Jetta Dunn Garland

HB: Howe McDonald Grimes

C: Lumumba Jones Stretch

HF: vanders Hogan Brayshaw

FF: Watts Pedersen Garlett

Foll: Jamar Vince Cross

Int: Tyson Viney Newton

S: Harmes

Stick with Billy Stretch. He does a lot right. He isn't getting the ball because team mates can't get it to him!

I'd love to drop Howe. But we don't even know if Jetta will be ready and it looks like Salem will be out. Someone has to play half back and I think it may as well be Howe for another week at least.

[stuie 7,374]

Guessing a bit with injuries etc, but here's my changes for next week....

OUT: Salem (inj), Howe, Spencer, Toumpas, Dawes, Bail
IN: Riley, Watts, Viney, Jetta, Gawn, Jamar

[ucanchoose 1,816]

Out; Watching first halves

In: Look at AirBNB for holiday accomadation

[beelzebub 23,380]

NO! We are in sweet harmony Stuie! FMD.

its strange isn't it lol

[picket fence 17,182]

Rubbing hands together Ah yes sweeeeeet harmony Now Where do I start?? Eh

[bing181 9,248]

I don't know that there'll be that many changes - not exactly a lot of players knocking the door down. Or anywhere near the door.

Spencer will stay in. From the report on the VFL match:

"Mark Jamar struggled throughout and Max Gawn kicked just one goal. Tall utility Jack Fitzpatrick was taken to hospital as a precaution after hurting his neck in the first quarter."

Someone has to come in for Salem, but Hogan will be back, hopefully Jetta. Stretch is a bit out of his depth at the moment, understandably. Roos spoke of tiredness amongst the younger players, especially after 3 heavy weeks against the top sides, so perhaps there'll be some rotations on that basis. Vandenberg and Brayshaw didn't look anything like they did a few games back.

Edited May 16, 2015 by bing181

[DeeSpencer 25,765]

I don't know that there'll be that many changes - not exactly a lot of players knocking the door down. Or anywhere near the door.

Spencer will stay in. From the report on the VFL match:

"Mark Jamar struggled throughout and Max Gawn kicked just one goal. Tall utility Jack Fitzpatrick was taken to hospital as a precaution after hurting his neck in the first quarter."

Someone has to come in for Salem, but Hogan will be back, hopefully Jetta. Stretch is a bit out of his depth at the moment, understandably. Roos spoke of tiredness amongst the younger players, especially after 3 heavy weeks against the top sides, so perhaps there'll be some rotations on that basis. Vandenberg and Bradshaw didn't look anything like they did a few games back.

One of vanders or Brayshaw could/should be the sub then. Stretch looks fine to me. Just hard to find the ball as a hard running Melbourne wingman with no ball movement.

Spencer might need to be dropped because of his sheer ineptitude. Another goal line stuff up this week, so he's 2 from 2 in what should be the easiest job a ruckman has.

[What 18,810]

how did ANB go today?

[Demonic Faves 39]

Out: Spencer, Bail, Toumpas, Dawes, Michie, Salem, M Jones

In: Jamar, Watts, Harmes, Hogan, Viney, Jetta, Newton

FB: Jetta Dunn Garland

HB: Howe McDonald Grimes

C: Lumumba Jones Stretch

HF: vanders Hogan Brayshaw

FF: Watts Pedersen Garlett

Foll: Jamar Vince Cross

Int: Tyson Viney Newton

S: Harmes

Stick with Billy Stretch. He does a lot right. He isn't getting the ball because team mates can't get it to him!

I'd love to drop Howe. But we don't even know if Jetta will be ready and it looks like Salem will be out. Someone has to play half back and I think it may as well be Howe for another week at least.

What dumb stuff you speak. Drop Toump but keep Stretchie. Toump doesn't get enough ball but Stretchies not being fed. Bradshaw gets even less of it. Then again, you would know, just ask.

[bing181 9,248]

How did Watts go??

Article on the AFL site mentions that he was solid - Plapp seems to think he'll be there for a couple of weeks, that it isn't just a one-off.

[DeeSpencer 25,765]

What dumb stuff you speak. Drop Toump but keep Stretchie. Toump doesn't get enough ball but Stretchies not being fed. Bradshaw gets even less of it. Then again, you would know, just ask.

His name is Brayshaw not Bradshaw.

Toump also struggles to get the ball due to the team. Anyone who plays outside midfield or forward in the Melbourne team struggles for opportunity to get the ball.

In my opinion Stretch is getting very little of it but he's using it well, competing really well, he tackles nicely for a little guy. 3 touches in 3 quarters is not a good sign but Toumpas' 11 were no more effective. The dogs are a young team and a young midfield, there should be many more opportunities for Stretch to find the ball and if he does I think he'll use it nicely. I can't say the same for Toumpas.

[Demonic Faves 39]

His name is Brayshaw not Bradshaw.

Toump also struggles to get the ball due to the team. Anyone who plays outside midfield or forward in the Melbourne team struggles for opportunity to get the ball.

In my opinion Stretch is getting very little of it but he's using it well, competing really well, he tackles nicely for a little guy. 3 touches in 3 quarters is not a good sign but Toumpas' 11 were no more effective. The dogs are a young team and a young midfield, there should be many more opportunities for Stretch to find the ball and if he does I think he'll use it nicely. I can't say the same for Toumpas.

Last time I looked, 11 is exactly 8 more than 3. D'OH. But keep going.

[WhyAlwaysMe 237]

Roos out, Goodwin in

Roos has been given everything he has requested & open cheque book, result 6 win 23 lose, Neeld 5 win 28 lose.

we were not competitive for the entire 2nd half of last year & beaten by quarter time many times this year.

his recruiting & management have been fine but his coaching is unconnected.

he remains untouchable & beyond criticism by public & media.

[Soidee 1,496]

Howe's total stats for the past 2 weeks

8 kicks

3 marks

2 tackles

Far koff

Putrid effort drop him!

[Bitter but optimistic 22,242]

His name is Brayshaw not Bradshaw.

Toump also struggles to get the ball due to the team. Anyone who plays outside midfield or forward in the Melbourne team struggles for opportunity to get the ball.

In my opinion Stretch is getting very little of it but he's using it well, competing really well, he tackles nicely for a little guy. 3 touches in 3 quarters is not a good sign but Toumpas' 11 were no more effective. The dogs are a young team and a young midfield, there should be many more opportunities for Stretch to find the ball and if he does I think he'll use it nicely. I can't say the same for Toumpas.

Bradman is what we need!

[WhyAlwaysMe 237]

Bradman is what we need!

i think he's dead

[Thehardtackler 785]

I'm starting to think that Goodwin may know more about the modern game than Roos. We do however need to bring in as many big bodied midfielders as we can over the next 2 years so that we can win the ball at clearances. Spencer won his fair share of hit outs but there was nearly always a Hawthorn player on the end of it.

Edited May 16, 2015 by Thehardtackler

[What 18,810]

I'm starting to think that Goodwin may know more about the modern game than Roos.

I really hope Roos negative boring game plan doesn't rub off on Goodwin

[Moonshadow 17,676]

i think he's dead

No. I saw him last week working at Hungry Jacks

[SaberFang 7,151]

Anyone criticising Roos either has a very short memory, or zero idea about the modern game.

Was he on the field today? No.

Did he draft or recruit half our list? No.

Did he get us into the mess we're in after years of [censored] drafting and [censored] development? No.

Did he do pretty much everything right from the moment he got in the door, including spending a year teaching players how to defend? Yes.

Is it his fault his players are seemingly incapable of following basic instructions or putting in EFFORT? NO.

Edited May 16, 2015 by Lamashtu

[Ted Lasso 19,526]

I still believe Roos has two main goals before the handover

Teach us to defend and be accountable which were improving at

And get this list in the best shape possible for Goodwin to take it somewhere,

Remember he took over a team that was 2 wins 52% and 8 80 plus point losses in the one season

[WhyAlwaysMe 237]

Anyone criticising Roos either has a very short memory, or zero idea about the modern game.

Was he on the field today? No.

Did he draft or recruit half our list? No.

Did he get us into the mess we're in after years of [censored] drafting and [censored] development? No.

Did he do pretty much everything right from the moment he got in the door, including spending a year teaching players how to defend? Yes.

Is it his fault his players are seemingly incapable of following basic instructions or putting in EFFORT? NO.

i haven't seen much defending since the bye last year, who else would be responsible for a side that repeatedly lacks effort?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I still believe Roos has two main goals before the handover

Teach us to defend and be accountable which were improving at

And get this list in the best shape possible for Goodwin to take it somewhere,

Remember he took over a team that was 2 wins 52% and 8 80 plus point losses in the one season

I would add in delist as many spuds as possible and actually recruit decent players to that as well.