Dion Prestia

[Binmans PA 26,589]

9 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Averaging high levels of disposals doesn't make you an A grader.  It's how you use them and the impact that they have on games.  

I'd love to change my tune on him if he came to the club and built on his talent and skills, but right at this minute he is not an A grade player.

I understand that, but consistent clearance winners are A grade in my book. Particularly when they're simply not up and under kicks like Bernie and Jones seem to do.

[Binmans PA 26,589]

9 minutes ago, ProDee said:

Treloar hasn't had an A-grade year, but he's unquestionably a very talented young A-grader in the making.  He doesn't work hard enough defensively, but is a ball magnet, who reads the play very well and kicks goals from the midfield.  While numbers of possessions in themselves don't define a player it's a handy skillset to get your hands on the footy.  Lord knows we've lacked ball magnets over the years.

I prefer Treloar as a talent.  He averages more disposals and has kicked double the amount of goals from virtually the same number of games.  I value goal-kicking mids and think Treloar will continue to increase this metric.

I dispute Prestia is a better kick.

Fair enough.

[Mach5 4,490]

I think Prestia has been close to A grade in the past, but I'm just not convinced he can get back there.

I'd want him if the price is right, but I don't know what GC are asking, nor what others are offering.
That will make a big difference.

[Watts the matter 1,235]

4 hours ago, AdamFarr said:

I understand that, but consistent clearance winners are A grade in my book. Particularly when they're simply not up and under kicks like Bernie and Jones seem to do.

You must be watching a different Prestia to most people. Kicking is one of his downfalls.

[SaberFang 7,141]

Was catching up with his manager in Melbourne yesterday. Feeling in the industry is apparently that both Prestia and O'Meara are leaving GC this year.

Melbourne made a huge play last year and are still interested, according to Purple.

Watts, on The Footy Show, joked he wasn't the list manager but said they are doing a great job with recruitment and would be "stupid not to look at a guy like Prestia, he's a great midfielder of the comp. So yeah, fingers crossed."

[DemonLad5 1,642]

Not willing to cough up picks with high value for players whom we have multiple in his position. Not to mention he'll want a fair bit of dollar. Rather go after Hurley, Hibberd and an outside mid with great disposal. I'd be happy to trade our future picks now as I'd like to be contending rather than developing in the next few years

[Neitz the Great 525]

Yeah as said above this was on the afl website 

"Uncontracted Gold Coast midfielder Dion Prestia also spent the week in Melbourne, meeting with manager Marty Pask as he looks to decide his home for 2017."

 

[mattjm 151]

13 hours ago, AdamFarr said:

I understand that, but consistent clearance winners are A grade in my book. Particularly when they're simply not up and under kicks like Bernie and Jones seem to do.

no offence AdamFarr. but you are a pleb. bernie is a top 3 kick at the club and would be an A grade boot at any club in the league. he has a laser like boot, not up and under at all. he can hack it long in wet or slippery conditions, but that is smart and experience adapting to conditions. it doesn't backfire

Edited June 16, 2016 by mattjm

[Binmans PA 26,589]

25 minutes ago, mattjm said:

no offence AdamFarr. but you are a pleb. bernie is a top 3 kick at the club and would be an A grade boot at any club in the league. he has a laser like boot, not up and under at all. he can hack it long in wet or slippery conditions, but that is smart and experience adapting to conditions. it doesn't backfire

Read the post properly next time. I said his kicks from clearances were up and unders. Go and watch the replay against Hawthorn for a perfect example of what they both do too often.

[Akum 2,660]

14 hours ago, AdamFarr said:

What grade would you class Treloar? He's a better kick and decision maker than Treloar, IMO.

Didn't think much of Treloar as a team player on QB. Nothing specific to go on, just a general impression. 

Thought there was a huge gap in class between him & Pendles, who drove the Pies good 1st quarter by working hard to bring team-mates into the game, but who fell away after Q1 because when we tightened up in the midfield, the likes of Treloar preferred to blaze away rather than looking to give the ball to Pendles for a more incisive clearance. 

With Pendles firing in the first, they got 4 goals. With Treloar as their most prominent mid for the other 3 quarters, they got 4 goals, definitely 1 and perhaps 2 from umpiring shockers. 

[dazzledavey36 49,555]

I do wonder whether Prestia has had a verbal agreement with the Dees bit like Dangerfield the year before he joined the Cats.

Prestia would have wanted to do the honourable thing and play out till his contract is over so maybe he has already said that he will join once his contract is up.

[Ted Lasso 17,199]

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I do wonder whether Prestia has had a verbal agreement with the Dees bit like Dangerfield the year before he joined the Cats.

Prestia would have wanted to do the honourable thing and play out till his contract is over so maybe he has already said that he will join once his contract is up.

While i think this is how it will play out i do believe dion has a decision to make, other clubs potentially offering more money and so on. Dees won't pay overs

[Scipio 5,900]

8 hours ago, AdamFarr said:

Read the post properly next time. I said his kicks from clearances were up and unders. Go and watch the replay against Hawthorn for a perfect example of what they both do too often.

This is definitely true. The same can be said about Viney and so many clearance players, because that's the nature of the contest around centre bounces and stoppages. 

But apparently none of this matters AF because you have been deemed a 'pleb'. It's all over.

Edited June 16, 2016 by Django

[PaulRB 6,048]

We don't have the picks to get Dion and Hibberd, unless we get Hibberd as a uncontracted free agent... 

Whod be preferred of those two, if we had to choose? 

[jumbo returns 6,593]

I've cooled on Prestia too.

There's a young fella on our list who's ready to make comeback....Gus Brayshaw, anyone?

[Goodvibes 3,596]

12 minutes ago, PaulRB said:

We don't have the picks to get Dion and Hibberd, unless we get Hibberd as a uncontracted free agent... 

Whod be preferred of those two, if we had to choose? 

If you were told we could have both and give up a 2016 second rounder for Hibberd and a 2017 first rounder for Prestia, would you do it? If both players wanted to come to Melbourne and we were keen, we'd find a way.

[ChaserJ 4,025]

9 hours ago, Akum said:

Didn't think much of Treloar as a team player on QB. Nothing specific to go on, just a general impression. 

Thought there was a huge gap in class between him & Pendles, who drove the Pies good 1st quarter by working hard to bring team-mates into the game, but who fell away after Q1 because when we tightened up in the midfield, the likes of Treloar preferred to blaze away rather than looking to give the ball to Pendles for a more incisive clearance. 

With Pendles firing in the first, they got 4 goals. With Treloar as their most prominent mid for the other 3 quarters, they got 4 goals, definitely 1 and perhaps 2 from umpiring shockers. 

Have watched a fair bit of Treloar going back to his Stingray days.  No doubt has the potential to be absolutely top notch, but would still say he has a way to go. At the moment he is very much a one way player.  He’d be a better all-round mid if he ran even half as hard defensively as he does offensively. I’d go as far to say that he’s a liability in this area.  All well and good if you’re at a club that surrounds you with hard working mids who can cover (Hawks, Sydney), but was Collingwood have a number of downhill skiers in their midfield at the moment, so poor defensive transition and accountability is the norm (with standout performances against Geelong and Brisbane proving to be the exception).

 

Makes me appreciate some of Petracca’s pressure acts on Monday, he’s not only is electric with ball in hand, he’s very active with his pressure when the ball’s in his area.

 

For a purely attack focused midfielder, Treloar can be a scrappy on occasion.  Whether it’s cleaning up decision making or execution of skill could be debated, but he generally gets the ball to where it needs to go, and he gets plenty of it and runs well with ball in hand.

[Skuit 9,382]

11 minutes ago, ChaserJ said:

Have watched a fair bit of Treloar going back to his Stingray days. 

Had you nicknamed your foetus 'Adsy' by any chance?

[mo64 5,267]

What I find perplexing about this entire thread is that posters seem to base their opinion solely on our teams last performance. After a win, Prestia is surplus to our requirements. After a loss, we need more midfield depth, so Prestia is a necessity.

People are also forming an opinion of Prestia's capabilities based solely on this season, after coming of a knee reco. I reckon he's been pretty good considering he's playing in a team that has been a rabble.

We are a middle of the road team, and if a very good player like Prestia expresses interest in playing for us, we should do everything within reason to get him.

 

[whatwhat say what 19,876]

on treloar, i was having a discussion with a pies mate about him v tyson and their relative worth.

 

i would think they're reasonably commensurate? he thinks treloar is way ahead (as he should be, really, as he's on double the pay packet).

 

i, for one, want prestia at the dees in 2017 and beyond as he's clearly a very, very good player and he would clearly benefit our side.

[ChaserJ 4,025]

2 hours ago, Skuit said:

Had you nicknamed your foetus 'Adsy' by any chance?

Sadly no.

[ChaserJ 4,025]

2 hours ago, DemonAndrew said:

on treloar, i was having a discussion with a pies mate about him v tyson and their relative worth.

 

i would think they're reasonably commensurate? he thinks treloar is way ahead (as he should be, really, as he's on double the pay packet).

 

i, for one, want prestia at the dees in 2017 and beyond as he's clearly a very, very good player and he would clearly benefit our side.

Dom's last two weeks have been exceptional, and what he does do when he's going well is bring others into the game as well (so much like Simon Black).  We haven't quite seen it week in, week out yet.  When that happens, his value will sky rocket. At the moment, Treloar's level of output is more consistent, so I'd have him ahead.

[Akum 2,660]

2 hours ago, DemonAndrew said:

on treloar, i was having a discussion with a pies mate about him v tyson and their relative worth.

i would think they're reasonably commensurate? he thinks treloar is way ahead (as he should be, really, as he's on double the pay packet).

i, for one, want prestia at the dees in 2017 and beyond as he's clearly a very, very good player and he would clearly benefit our side.

Would Treloar v Viney be a better comparison?

Agree about Prestia.

[Biffen 12,444]

Vince ,Viney and Jones are a grade, elite , grouse , top notch etc. 

They would walk in to any team.

[ManDee 7,093]

3 minutes ago, Biffen said:

Vince ,Viney and Jones are a grade, elite , grouse , top notch etc. 

They would walk in to any team.

Russian bobsled?   - or bobsleigh - also the Russians may need some drug free athletes, you may be right.

Edited June 17, 2016 by ManDee