Brett Kirk - Roos' successor?

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Just suggested by Barrett on The Footy Show (i know, i know) that the MFC aren't talking to anyone during the season to be Roosy's successor, but will have a list of 6 names by season's end who they will ask to speak to.

Said lock Brett Kirk in as one of those names.

Take it as you will knuckleheads.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Hope Simon Goodwin is also in the mix.

[chook fowler 18,555]

My favourite is Nathan Bassett

[Yossarian 1,808]

Where the f... does he pull a list of 6 names from? How could anyone be positive that at season's end, Melbourne will put together "6 names"?! There might be 7 people worth talking to, but no... it's been decided in April that at some time in September, we'll write down "6 names." Jesus christ.

Is this guy on crack? Seriously... Barrett... come on man. What an absolute plum.

[Sir Why You Little 35,318]

TV junk Fodder...it's April.

[Machsy 2,858]

Because putting a number like that on it, doesn't matter how much the club denies it, it'll be quoted and taken as gospel by the footy media in general.

And it'll give Barrett so much scope to throw up names that he can't possibly be wrong in the end.

At different times he'll name about 5, with at least one spot in reserve in case he gets completely blindsided.

He's full of shite, but you must admit he's pretty good at doing what he does.

Talks absolute crap and it gets lapped up each week, leaving the masses gagging for more...

[Machsy 2,858]

Throughout the season we'll be told the 6 are believed to be Kirk, Ling, Goodwin, Ratten, probably Basset, Burns, Sumich, Bruce, Green and whatever other flavour-of-the-month assistant coach names pop up.

[Yossarian 1,808]

I get why he's doing it. Still shits me.

[jumbo returns 6,618]

Throughout the season we'll be told the 6 are believed to be Kirk, Ling, Goodwin, Ratten, probably Basset, Burns, Sumich, Bruce, Green and whatever other flavour-of-the-month assistant coach names pop up.

I know you're taking the pizz, but if Ratten or Sumich are short listed, I'll....I'll...vomit.

[Pennant St Dee 11,750]

I know you're taking the pizz, but if Ratten or Sumich are short listed, I'll....I'll...vomit.

Agreed on Sumich the guy will be another Neeld, Drum, Waters, Tactically inept

I have also heard Goodwin's name mentioned a few weeks ago as a possibility, but with a view of doing a two year handover role. What weight that holds who knows but source was from someone in footy department circles (neither Bombers or Dees)

[Giles 179]

I've got Barrett on the list already.

[skills32 229]

Well I've got whathisname? The ex Richmond bloke.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Well I've got whathisname? The ex Richmond bloke.

The List Manager. Great football brain.....

[Young Dee 1,303]

I've got Barrett on the list already.

He has just placed himself at the top of Roos list (hit list).

He better watch himself - I for one would not like to have Roos or PJ as an enemy.

[Whispering_Jack 28,118]

Kirk is said to be doing well in his role as an assistant at Fremantle under Roosy's mate Rossy Lyon. The connections are all there.

I liked the way Kirk played the game - he was a clever footballer and off the field he comes across as clever, articulate and intelligent which means that he has some of the ingredients to do well as a modern day coach.

[Carrot Top 947]

I know you're taking the pizz, but if Ratten or Sumich are short listed, I'll....I'll...vomit.

Ratten got a lot out of our ordinary midfield and much more out of an ordinary Carlton.

He is a much better coach than most give him credit for.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

[Gipsy Danger 1,067]

Ratten got a lot out of our ordinary midfield and much more out of an ordinary Carlton.

He is a much better coach than most give him credit for.

An ordinary midfield lead by Chris Judd! bloke didn't win 2 Brownlow's for nothing

[whatwhat say what 20,295]

Ratten got the best out of Brock McLean twice.

He can coach.

Probably not with us tho!

I dare to dream: Bomber Thompson to join Paul Roos next year, grooming Ling and Kirk - cage death match to determine who gets the gig in 2017 and beyond!

[TGR 1,367]

Fact of the matter is that Paul Roos has Sydney-fied Melbourne. That means that the assistant coach must have a strong Sydney connection to continue the path to the holy grail.

Kirk has been raised time and time again on these boards by smart people. You have to then wonder why Melbourne was eager to sign Stuart Dew 6 months ago? Why Kirk wasn't top of the list then? Don't be surprised if the candidate comes from within (Allison, Mathews etc..)

Amazing how the footy public rate coaches. My best picks are the ones that did bloody well with average lists. Bomber Thompson has the footy world fooled IMO. Did nothing until Wells and father-sons gave him a maturing side. He left Geelong, and they aint missing him even though the glory days are long gone. And this Essendon list aint bad. I think it has won 90% of its first 8 rounds in the past 3 years.

If the Sydneyfication of Melbourne didn't eventuate, my choice for an assistant-come-coach is Matthew Lloyd. Honest, strong-mind and is happy to walk against the "Hird".

[What 18,810]

lol

[chook fowler 18,555]

Fact of the matter is that Paul Roos has Sydney-fied Melbourne. That means that the assistant coach must have a strong Sydney connection to continue the path to the holy grail.

Kirk has been raised time and time again on these boards by smart people. You have to then wonder why Melbourne was eager to sign Stuart Dew 6 months ago? Why Kirk wasn't top of the list then? Don't be surprised if the candidate comes from within (Allison, Mathews etc..)

Amazing how the footy public rate coaches. My best picks are the ones that did bloody well with average lists. Bomber Thompson has the footy world fooled IMO. Did nothing until Wells and father-sons gave him a maturing side. He left Geelong, and they aint missing him even though the glory days are long gone. And this Essendon list aint bad. I think it has won 90% of its first 8 rounds in the past 3 years.

If the Sydneyfication of Melbourne didn't eventuate, my choice for an assistant-come-coach is Matthew Lloyd. Honest, strong-mind and is happy to walk against the "Hird".

Think you are under-estimating Bomber. Maybe Geelong are still enjoying the foundations put in place during his reign. Also Essendon seem much more lively than under Hird which plces him in a vulnerable position when he returns.

It seems to me Bomber has a personality that builds good relationships with players - Hird seems more aloof.

[John Crow Batty 8,352]

If things continue on a downward slide at the Swans I believe Kirk will be more likely to replace Longmuir than come to us. If the Swans cannot get their Mojo back within 12 months, they will be looking for another coach. I think Ratten may be worth another try and Bruce will have completed his apprenticeship at the Hawks.

[TGR 1,367]

Also Essendon seem much more lively than under Hird which plces him in a vulnerable position when he returns.

It seems to me Bomber has a personality that builds good relationships with players - Hird seems more aloof.

I'm sure many Hawthorn supporters said similar things about Allan Joyce in 1988 & 1991

Have you watched Essendon between March-May over the past 3 years? This is groundhog season.

Then you top-up with Goddard, then Chapman.

Their recruiting has been pretty good; they have topped up for the window they in; they enjoy the luxury of the most expensive assistant coaches in the league (Thompson, now Craig).

According to Wilson, Lloyd and Co. Thompson was a rambling wreck in August last year. He also left Geelong deceptively when this was totally and utterly avoidable; when the coaching caper "got too much".

It is easy to be jocular when the sun is shining and your team is winning.

[John Crow Batty 8,352]

Couldnt think of a worse idea than this

please god no

We are trying to start a culture shift at the club, any of those soft average non -leader players that were our highest paid players at the club last decade (Bruce, Yze, Green, Robertson etc etc) should never be considered to be our coach, and i hope they aren't hired for any sort of coaching role at the MFC

We need to get out of 50 years of mediocrity, not continue to bring it back to the club

Hasn't stopped Clarkson infecting the Hawks with remnants of our culture.