The Trade/Draft Rumour Mill

[PaulRB 6,119]

I reckon we'll get a mid first round pick (pick 9)... which we'll trade to Tigers for Dusty.

[whatwhat say what 20,427]

Commission doesn't even sit to evaluate until Monday.

FWIW, I don't think we'll get one. I thought we would, but the afl media management strategy has been to indicate that we ain't getting one.

[Hannibal 5,814]

I think these sorts of comments really miss the point about where we are actually at. It is fact our club has been appallingly badly managed where we have wasted raw talent through our own stupidity and incompetence. It stands to reason then if we have a regime and coaches who know what they are doing, and are highly competent. The improvement could be anything - 30%?, 50% ? 100%. Personally I think it will closer to100% than 50%.

The upside is enormous JUST BY THE IMPROVEMENT IN OUR CURRENT PLAYING GROUP.

We should look at our midfield in that light, not in the light of their competence of 2013 - it will be like chalk and cheese.

No point missed, just stating facts.

If you want a discussion on the midfield's "potential upside" then start a thread and I may contribute.

[Wormburner 674]

Anyone know what the status is on Watts signing?

[rjay 24,201]

we're not getting a priority pick. I can confirm that from Chris Langford who sits on the Commission. End of.

Pick 2 it is

No. We just got Paul Roos as senior coach. That in itself is worth a priority pick. Major reason the afl cited we don't need one is the port adelaide example.

Well Chris should keep his own council until the decision comes down if that's true.

...and the Port logic is what comes out of KB's mouth, makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.

Very dubious about this being correct.

Does this mean ANY team from now on can't get a pick because one team turned it around in a year? No logic in that.

There's no way they would use that as a "major reason".

Spot on 'stuie'. No logic at all.

If true it looks like the PP is decided on the crystal ball at AFL HQ. If it shows a good season ahead then no PP.

[alias275 259]

watch this space....................

I think he won't stay at the Tiges, & I think its interesting this breaks just after Conca signs on for 3 is it? Tigers won't have the money he wants I'm sure... hmmn, then GWS says no thanks...

"corralled"

now, where is that giant Budweiser gone?

He has a meeting with Brisbane and the papers say Essendon are now looking to get him. You're probably right dee-luded, Richmond don't want him either, someone has to take him.

[dee-luded 2,958]

He has a meeting with Brisbane and the papers say Essendon are now looking to get him. You're probably right dee-luded, Richmond don't want him either, someone has to take him.

I think its all swings & roundabouts, imo the writings arte on the wall.

I think the AFL don't want anarchy breaking out anytime soon, & they're feverishly plugging dykes all over the country.

I think a very sensible outcome will behold all.

[tonatopia 278]

Obviously dusty loves the Charlie, and everyone knows.

[samcantstandya 973]

You talk about the longevity of our forward line, then propose trading our top pick for 2 guys who have 2 years left in them at best?

You talk about the longevity of our forward line, then propose trading our top pick for 2 guys who have 2 years left in them at best?

I don't like short term fixes recruit young guns & develop now that we have a coach who knows how 2 build a team.

[Moonshadow 16,621]

Obviously dusty loves the Charlie, and everyone knows.

I'd love for one of our guys to get a Brownlow as well.

[Grimes is Great 183]

Jamie Bennell has been upgraded to West Coasts senior list.

[Little Richard 5,943]

Jamie Bennell has been upgraded to West Coasts senior list.

So after many long years of substance abuse, the drugs have finally taken their toll on the brains of the Eagles football department. Well done guys.

[Canplay 575]

Apparently Cross met with Roos today anyone know how that went today??

I've heard that Cross is very keen on joining Carlton - has good relationship with Mick Malthouse & sees more chance of playing finals next year - just a matter of if Blues are prepared to make offer.

[Craig Drinker 179]

Jamie Bennell has been upgraded to West Coasts senior list.

Has skills but lacks ticker. Not as petrified as Isaac Weetra or Travis Cloke in his early days but he may work as an outside player at West Coast?

[dazzledavey36 49,818]

I've heard that Cross is very keen on joining Carlton - has good relationship with Mick Malthouse & sees more chance of playing finals next year - just a matter of if Blues are prepared to make offer.

I dont understand he complained the other night that he wanted more run through the middle yet wants to go after Cross... I just hope he sits down with Roos and sells to him about joining the dees.

His professionlism and training standard would be a massive boost for the club.

[dee-luded 2,958]

I've heard that Cross is very keen on joining Carlton - has good relationship with Mick Malthouse & sees more chance of playing finals next year - just a matter of if Blues are prepared to make offer.

IMO if Cross plays in the navy blue Robinson or McLean misses.

Edited September 20, 2013 by dee-luded

[DemonOX 8,578]

What will happen if we can't get any midfielder from another club?

We will be in the same spot of bother we are now.

Will be really disappointed if this happens.

[Redleg 38,615]

What will happen if we can't get any midfielder from another club?

We will be in the same spot of bother we are now.

Will be really disappointed if this happens.

Well according to some, like Damian Barrett, that would be just great.

[CBDees 3,162]

Judging by the growing string of Clubs publicly declaring themselves not interested in Martin and the stand-off between his knucklehead manager and RFC, maybe we should rethink conjuring up a deal. If we thought of a fair package for him, maybe we can convince him to nominate for the pre-season draft, where we will be in pole-position to snap him up (especially in the light of GWS's official statement that they are not interested). Injecting him into our midfield without needing to trade or use a first-round draft pick has immense appeal. I am sure that Roos could devise a management plan to overcome any possible cultural differences between him and the rest of the list.

[Ted Lasso 17,318]

Judging by the growing string of Clubs publicly declaring themselves not interested in Martin and the stand-off between his knucklehead manager and RFC, maybe we should rethink conjuring up a deal. If we thought of a fair package for him, maybe we can convince him to nominate for the pre-season draft, where we will be in pole-position to snap him up (especially in the light of GWS's official statement that they are not interested). Injecting him into our midfield without needing to trade or use a first-round draft pick has immense appeal. I am sure that Roos could devise a management plan to overcome any possible cultural differences between him and the rest of the list.

To be perfectly honest i'd still just rather not have a dick head at our club haha, if he is willing to leave a club that's clearly on the rise bigtime to chase money from teams that are miles behind them it makes you ask questions of that persons mindset.

[jackaub 1,402]

Including Trengove and Toumpas (both of whom may surprise next year)!

I reckon i would be surprised!

[CBDees 3,162]

To be perfectly honest i'd still just rather not have a [censored] head at our club haha, if he is willing to leave a club that's clearly on the rise bigtime to chase money from teams that are miles behind them it makes you ask questions of that persons mindset.

Fair point however how much is him and how much is his knuckehead manager. He appears the sort of guy who is easily-led and incapable of making his own lifestyle decisions (as evidenced by choosing to tatoo his neck)>

[Ted Lasso 17,318]

Fair point however how much is him and how much is his knuckehead manager. He appears the sort of guy who is easily-led and incapable of making his own lifestyle decisions (as evidenced by choosing to tatoo his neck)>

The manager is probably not helping but i haven't heard many good things about Dusty, even the Richmond members i know are happy for him to just walk so for me it's not that surprising noone wants him, he needs to sort out his management quick smart.

if Roosy feels he can sort him out he is a very talented player, infact i'd go as far as saying he is as talented as anyone on our list.

[Dynamic Demon 17]

It amazes me that so many are willing to judge the guy without knowing all the facts. It's so easy hiding behind the names you create for this site. Remember, the AFL / VFL is littered with players that have made bad choices in life. Cousins, Gardner, Fisher, Swan, Hall even the great Gary Ablett. Years ago it was Banks and Millane. Martin has made bad decisions for reasons none of us know, but he is an outstanding footballer with a lot more to give. What has happened to him recently maybe just the wake up call he needs.

[Ted Lasso 17,318]

It amazes me that so many are willing to judge the guy without knowing all the facts. It's so easy hiding behind the names you create for this site. Remember, the AFL / VFL is littered with players that have made bad choices in life. Cousins, Gardner, Fisher, Swan, Hall even the great Gary Ablett. Years ago it was Banks and Millane. Martin has made bad decisions for reasons none of us know, but he is an outstanding footballer with a lot more to give. What has happened to him recently maybe just the wake up call he needs.

Maybe so, but we are trying to build a culture so we can't afford to roll the dice yet while there are safer options going, wait til we're a strong team again, then we can look at risks like this.