Cloke and Collingwood - to part or not to part?

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

That Mitch Clark guy who was our best player until he got injured? Yeah I remember him, what of him?

[tonatopia 278]

I would have rather had fevola at $100k a year.

[Biffen 12,946]

That Mitch Clark guy who was our best player until he got injured? Yeah I remember him, what of him?

Hes our full forward next year .

[dee-luded 2,959]

Have to admit wasn't sold early, but front ended last three years on average to decent (not excessive) coin does have plenty of pro's.

No picks to give up

Opposition coaches headache, best tall defender on Clark or Cloke

Draft mids and small forward if available

Fills a lot of holes in our list in 1 off season

Howe/Jurrah third tall

Jamar/Gawn/Martin resting forward think Meth Coast Kennedy/Lynch/Darling/Cox, Pies 2010/11 Cloke/Dawes/Brown/Jolly

Also while we need good mids Clark & Cloke would reak havoc and panic in opposition forward lines with quick deep forward kicks and they both know how to work hard and lead with purpose

If we can heavily front end the Cloke deal, with big $$$ in the first 2 Years then tapering, I'm OK with it. But Not at the expense of Boak being afforded.

[jnrmac 20,180]

No no no no no no AND no.

He's not that good.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

No no no no no no AND no.

He's not that good.

Your right he is not that good but he is good. Good god we need some good players.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

if there was ever any proof of how desperately we need someone like Cloke, how about our 55 inside 50s to Ports 45, yet we copped a thrashing. No targets up forward.

Throw the lot at this guy...

Similar inside 50 stats against the Lions at the Gabba too. We need two pillars - Clark and Cloke.

And a much better engine room.

And a few other things (but, fortunately, no longer a new coach or head of fitness).

[Footynut 302]

Hes our full forward next year .

God forbid injury strikes again and then we have no one to kick to as usual....

[beelzebub 23,382]

Cant see anything in the papers referring to any offer...curious

Youd think theyd be all over this ...the vultures

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Cant see anything in the papers referring to any offer...curious

Youd think theyd be all over this ...the vultures

They're way too busy with the Will Minson contract saga.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Cant see anything in the papers referring to any offer...curious

Youd think theyd be all over this ...the vultures

Can't see where Cloke has signed yet, Nor can I see the same for Boak.

[Undeeterred 3,124]

What people need to realize is that if we get cloke, one of he and clark are going to get the 2nd best defender each week rather than the number 1 defender, the other play will benefit immensely and it will make our mids look a lot better with two towering targets up forward rather than the makeshift targets we have now!

This. ^^

Remember how Cloke tore Rivers a new one last year, because Chip had to go to Dawes instead? Same deal here.

[Dee1987 277]

Rumour going round cloke will go and will go to Carlton with malthouse on bigfooty don't think the can afford him really

[Range Rover 1,935]

Pies have just announced that Cloke's contract negotiation will now be postponed until after the season.

Interesting development. The official line is that they don't want the distraction in the run to the finals but have they been spooked by his poor run of form?

Possibly a massive misjudgement made here by the Clokes. Shoulda tied something away while his stocks were high.

Edited July 24, 2012 by Range Rover

[stuie 7,374]

News just breaking that Collingwood have put contract talks with Cloke ON HOLD til the end of the season...

So, what number will we give him you think?

Edit: Added link: https://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/142534/default.aspx

Edited July 24, 2012 by stuie

[olisik 4,060]

News just breaking that Collingwood have put contract talks with Cloke ON HOLD til the end of the season...

So, what number will we give him you think?

Edit: Added link: https://www.afl.com....34/default.aspx

31

[jackaub 1,402]

It couldn't happen to a more deserving team. I can't help but get the feeling that it's Cloke Sr that is the greedy one, and Travis is just going with his father's wishes. As highly as I rate Cloke, I wouldn't want to see him at the Dees if it meant paying $800k+ for 5 years. That money could be much better invested elsewhere.

Please dont waste MFC money on Cloke he is just not worth it(IMO)

But as usual the Club will, against all sanity, have a go at getting him

I'm praying that they are not successfull. Please in gods name no!

[olisik 4,060]

Please dont waste MFC money on Cloke he is just not worth it(IMO)

But as usual the Club will, against all sanity, have a go at getting him

I'm praying that they are not successfull. Please in gods name no!

You, like many others, fail to see why we are offering what appears to be 'overs' for Cloke.

Besides all the obvious benefits (Structure, contesting marking in forward 50 ect) , we also have to pay NOTHING TO COLLINGWOOD.

Draft picks are priceless and the fact that we have to give up none to Collingwood is the reason why we are throwing so much money into this.

If we were giving up draft picks for a standard 'trade' then their is no way teams would be throwing this type of coin at Cloke.

I hope we get him, Cloke, Viney + 2 - 3 other mids, im watering at the mouth already.

Edited July 24, 2012 by olisik

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Pies have just announced that Cloke's contract negotiation will now be postponed until after the season.

Interesting development. The official line is that they don't want the distraction in the run to the finals but have they been spooked by his poor run of form?

Possibly a massive misjudgement made here by the Clokes. Shoulda tied something away while his stocks were high.

Surely Cloke isn't staying at the pies now. Where he ends up who knows? If the bombers and Carlton miss the 8 and the Pies lose the flag and Cloke at least there will be some positives from this season.

[The Lobster Effect 893]

Surely Cloke isn't staying at the pies now. Where he ends up who knows? If the bombers and Carlton miss the 8 and the Pies lose the flag and Cloke at least there will be some positives from this season.

yeh ablett, ward, scully, etc all put off contract negotiations until the end of the season and then ended up leaving.

are there any recent examples of players doing this but staying at their original club?

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

yeh ablett, ward, scully, etc all put off contract negotiations until the end of the season and then ended up leaving.

are there any recent examples of players doing this but staying at their original club?

I can't think of any. Let the games begin. It isn't cloud cover in London at the moment it's Eddie's head Boiling!

[Range Rover 1,935]

Plenty of Pies fans calling SEN absolutely filthy on Cloke for dragging this out.

Nice to see another club go through what we went through with you-know-who.

Even better that it's the Filth.

He is every chance to be boo'd by his own if he doesn't perform I reckon.

[Biffen 12,946]

I really hope we drive the price of him up to Scully like $$ and then just say "Nah".

This would be the smart option.

He is not a patch on Clark anyway .

[jumbo returns 6,741]

yeh ablett, ward, scully, etc all put off contract negotiations until the end of the season and then ended up leaving.

are there any recent examples of players doing this but staying at their original club?

Cam Bruce?

Jeff Farmer?

Nathan Buckley?

Jason Akermanis?

Not 100% sure, but I think these guys protracted their talks right into October.

[Dee1987 277]

Dont want to be Captin obvious but some of the facts:

1. Both Dees and freo have offered Cloke big contracts with Dees offering by far the most of any club someting like 1.1 over 6-7 years

2. Pies can only offer 4 with with about 800k max.

3. Carlton have shown interest but require Murphy, Judd, Kruzer, Robinson, Gibbs, Jamison all to take pay cuts to get him there!

4. If Cloke really never had any interest in the prospect of coming to the Dees he would of signed immediatley

5, There is still the possibilty of him staying with the Pies, but history tells who wants to have something like this hanging over your head? Ablett, Scully, Ward and co let it drag on until seasons end to inform the were leaving for $$

So im guessing he is seriously thinking about the MFC offer!!!! I would too