Would we welcome Brett Ratten back?

[Moonshadow 16,558]

IF... The Blues finish outside the 8, is there a chance he might get the flick? Club going backwards and all of that. They have a history of cutting what they perceive as their losses.

KB on SEN this morning has them finishing 9 or 10, for what his opinion is worth. Not the easiest run home to the finals.

Should we have a go at getting him back as midfield coach (and p!ss off Brian Royal) if he's available?

I liked very much what he did for us previously.

Comments?

[Miles from Nowhere 199]

Oh yeah. especially if it got us the Royal flush.

[Sir Why You Little 35,288]

Of course. He was a great midfielder. And he got ours firing in 2004.

Yes.

[satyricon 267]

What is it with Brian Royal bashing

So far this season he has had at his disposal

Jones - if he continues with form should win B & F by a street

McKenzie - is McKenzie

Moloney - injured and out of form at various stages

Morton - trying to teach him midfield role

Magner - 11 AFL games

Grimes - only just got his body right for the middle

Watts - see Morton

Howe - see Morton

Bail - injury, in and out

Trengove - getting him to do more of a tagging role for his education

Bate - in and then out

Jamar - no real back up for him, working like a trojan

Martin - injury, in and out

Green - injury, out of form

Gysberts - injured

Evans - injured

Gawn - injured

Couch - they don't think he is quite ready

Taggert - injured

Jetta - injured

Tynan - injured

So perhaps he knows what he wants in there, just not getting it at the moment, let's wait and see, he has had 11 games as Midfield Coach, he did an alright job with the St Kilda mids once he had sorted out a few issues, most are still going strong

I am so looking fwd to next years midfield if we can fix the bodies, Viney, Taggert, Gysberts, Trengove, Jones, Magner, Couch, Jamar and Gawn

Edited June 21, 2012 by satyricon

[Guest bluey]

Well, yeh, I mean our midfield is deplorable, mainly due to the personnel.

Our forward line is hopeless because the mids do not give us a decent amount of ball.

Our back half is useless because the mids can not contain the ball.

With an average midfield even Dunne and Bater would be good players.

Nothing to do with Choco, just appalling recruiting.

Look at the stats from Molloney, Mckenzie and Magner, basically playing with three men short every week.

[deeflog 679]

would have him back in a heart beat, our midfield has never worked like it did when he was there

[jayceebee31 692]

No room for Ratten at our club right now . not even as an Assistant. The current coaching panel need at least next year if not two more to develop our list the way they have started 2012 off. If this doesn't happen we will have wasted this year for nothing. This year is a learning curve for all and we need to have stability in this area to move on.

[Little Richard 5,913]

Absolutely

[Sir Why You Little 35,288]

There is room for Ratten as an assisstant if the club thinks it is of benefit.

$$$ talk. Nothing is forever set in stone.

[Viney12 196]

Loved what Ratten did with out midfield, and was dirty when he left

I advocated him as a potential senior coach for us, but it's looking potentially though as he isn't quite up to grade as the man

Would love him back as a mid coach, don't see it happening

[Guest Gotzy15]

For the record I love brett ratten and he is by far my favourite coach in the afl. I can't believe the criticism he is copping atm and I think he's always been undeservedly under the pump at carlton. Love the emotion and energy from the bench. Was brilliant when in control of our midfield group and would have him back in a heartbeat!!

[Chook 14,646]

At the moment, I'd prefer a stab in the eye with a rusty fork over a Brian Royal-led midfield, so obviously getting Ratten back would be a huge benefit. But it won't happen. The blues will come home with a wet sail and win at least one final, thus keeping Ratten safe for at least another year.

[Johnny Karate 559]

Can we get Scott Thompson back too? Ratten's 1 year stint as midfield coach resulting in demigod status around here never ceases to crack me up. Along with Brian Royal is the antichrist. Maybe we should invent a time machine, go back to 2000 & get that guy who turned our midfield from 14th to 2nd in a year with the loss of Todd Viney! Yeah let's get that guy - What was his name? Brian something?

[Nasher 33,240]

Can we get Scott Thompson back too? Ratten's 1 year stint as midfield coach resulting in demigod status around here never ceases to crack me up. Along with Brian Royal is the antichrist. Maybe we should invent a time machine, go back to 2000 & get that guy who turned our midfield from 14th to 2nd in a year with the loss of Todd Viney! Yeah let's get that guy - What was his name? Brian something?

Gah. Read the thread and was going to post exactly this. Thunder stealer!

A million times Like.

[beelzebub 22,692]

This Filed<<<<<<< Green <<<<<< That Field

[Maldonboy38 6,089]

Yes. If the Bues let him go - and I reckon they will - swoop and grab him asap.

And for those who cannot understand why so many are "down" on Brian Royal as our midfield coach, read Demonland over this season and amid all the emotional stuff-and-nonsense, what is the consistent theme? That our midfield is our problem. Our midfield was better last year when Royal was not the midfield coach and they are almost the identical set of players.

[beelzebub 22,692]

Yes. If the Bues let him go - and I reckon they will - swoop and grab him asap.

And for those who cannot understand why so many are "down" on Brian Royal as our midfield coach, read Demonland over this season and amid all the emotional stuff-and-nonsense, what is the consistent theme? That our midfield is our problem. Our midfield was better last year when Royal was not the midfield coach and they are almost the identical set of players.

ah yes....but a different senior coach with most likey differing instructions. These ones seem to be takign a whiles to stick. thats all I can gather about it all

[Nasher 33,240]

And for those who cannot understand why so many are "down" on Brian Royal as our midfield coach, read Demonland over this season and amid all the emotional stuff-and-nonsense, what is the consistent theme? That our midfield is our problem. Our midfield was better last year when Royal was not the midfield coach and they are almost the identical set of players.

And since then, absolutely nothing else whatsoever has changed of course other than Royal becoming the midfield coach.

[Viney12 196]

Can we get Scott Thompson back too? Ratten's 1 year stint as midfield coach resulting in demigod status around here never ceases to crack me up. Along with Brian Royal is the antichrist. Maybe we should invent a time machine, go back to 2000 & get that guy who turned our midfield from 14th to 2nd in a year with the loss of Todd Viney! Yeah let's get that guy - What was his name? Brian something?

I don't think Royal is the anti-christ, but the benefit when Ratten was our midfield coach, and the clear drop off after he left was evident

[McQueen 17,864]

All past tanking coaches end up in South Australia.

My tip is he'll be at the Power next year.

[Johnny Karate 559]

Yes. If the Bues let him go - and I reckon they will - swoop and grab him asap.

And for those who cannot understand why so many are "down" on Brian Royal as our midfield coach, read Demonland over this season and amid all the emotional stuff-and-nonsense, what is the consistent theme? That our midfield is our problem. Our midfield was better last year when Royal was not the midfield coach and they are almost the identical set of players.

By that logic Bailey>Viney>Neeld?

I've had an about face though. Of course we should get Ratten! Forget the last 5 matches of 2004 where our midfield got smashed, he'd shrewdly teed up his first gig at Nar Nar Goon 4ths. I would worry too much about Carlton's 1 finals win under him either. I mean look at their midfield - Chris Judd, Marc Murphy, Kade Simpson & co aren't a patch on the Melbourne class of 04. Give me Godfrey, Ward & Johnstone any day of the week!

[mauriesy 6,894]

Our midfield was better last year when Royal was not the midfield coach and they are almost the identical set of players.

Our midfield's been terrible for years.

[Geddy Lee 582]

Mark Maclure, a lifelong Carlton man, just stated Ratts will not be there next year. I'd welcome him back. With Viney, 2 new other gun midfielders, Jones, Grimes and depth players, what might he do with a fresh outlook?

[beelzebub 22,692]

Why would Neeld invite Ratten into the fold . I must be missing something here

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

He will be fired sooner or later so yes absolutely I would take him back. He would probably want to come back too. Players make coaches look good and if our midfield fires up over the next few years it would make Ratts look pretty good for another coaching gig.