Team for Round 1

[Demon Head 281]

I'm not really into selecting teams in position but I am interested in the 22 who will play in round 1.

Any views?

[rpfc 28,433]

I would like to talk about Jack Watts...

I added the ellipsis because my facetiousness is not readily understood.

[double dee 27]

I would like to talk about Jack Watts.

Try any other thread, or maybe just hang around untill this one exceeds 10 posts?

Also there is another thread for this About half way down the front page

[rpfc 28,433]

Couch in.

[In Neeld We Trust 1]

Couch in.

Yes and Gysberts, Watts and tapscott out.

Love those boys, but they need form in the VFL before any AFL action.

[Grandson of a gun 276]

Yes and Gysberts, Watts and tapscott out.

Love those boys, but they need form in the VFL before any AFL action.

Confusing post- or maybe I've had too much tonight and have missed something.

Based on Casey form, injuries and nab I believe the 22 will be

Bartram Frawley Garland Grimes Rivers MacDonald Blease Trengove Davey Watts Martin Green Petterd Clarke Jamar Moloney Jones Gysberts Magner Bennell Bate McKenzie

Tapscott to play one or two more at Casey along with a few others who need to find form.

[rjay 24,928]

Confusing post- or maybe I've had too much tonight and have missed something.

Based on Casey form, injuries and nab I believe the 22 will be

Bartram Frawley Garland Grimes Rivers MacDonald Blease Trengove Davey Watts Martin Green Petterd Clarke Jamar Moloney Jones Gysberts Magner Bennell Bate McKenzie

Tapscott to play one or two more at Casey along with a few others who need to find form.

I think Sellar will play, not sure who in place of but maybe MacDonald or Bennell. They played him on a medium forward against Hawthorn for a reason and he did ok. Just a feeling but time will tell.

[tonatopia 278]

Fb: bartram. Garland. Rivers

Hb: grimes. Frawley. Blease

C: trengove. Moloney. Green

Hf: Howe. Martin. Watts

Ff: Petterd. Clarke. Davey

Fol: jamar. Jones. Mckenzie.

Int: magner. Bate. Gysberts. Tapscott

Emg: dunn. Bail. J.Mcdonald

Full back line are all leadership material

Half back have plenty of run

Midfield is hard, tough, clearence specialists

Half forward line is very versatile, hard to match

Full forward line has a nice balance marking and crumbing

Interchange has 3 midfielders, with tapscott the sub.

This team should be very hard to play against. We should definitely be favorites going into round 1 against Brisbane.

Go dees.

Edited March 25, 2012 by tonatopia

[rjay 24,928]

Interchange has 3 midfielders, with tapscott the sub.

Go dees.

Looks pretty good but Tappy has missed too much footy to start as the sub, he needs a good run. Probably another week at Casey at least.

[tonatopia 278]

I think 35 minutes of afl footy would be perfect for tappy

[JJJ 1,286]

This was surprisingly easy for me.... I had hoped it would be extremely difficult but alas....

The only one I wasnt sure about was Bennell but we need a small with speed down there.

FB: Bennell, Frawley, Garland

HB: Grimes, Rivers, Sellar

C: Trengove, Moloney, Blease

HF: Watts, Howe, Petterd

FF: Davey, Clark, Green

R: Jamar, Jones, Magner

IC: Bartram, Mckenzie, Martin, Tynan

Emerg Bate Bail McDonald

Would love it if in 2 weeks time Gysberts, Morton, Tapscott & Couch were in there....

[rjay 24,928]

I think 35 minutes of afl footy would be perfect for tappy

I get where you are coming from and if it was just one game in isolation I would agree but in the context of a season he hasn't had enough time on the ground. I think he would be better served getting more game time. Sometimes we put too much stake in the first game of the season and whilst I really want us to win it (will be p..off if we lose) and Tappy as a sub would certainly help the cause, we need to think of the season ahead and not just the first game.

[Macca 16,972]

Fb: bartram. Garland. Rivers

Hb: grimes. Frawley. Blease

C: trengove. Moloney. Green

Hf: Howe. Martin. Watts

Ff: Petterd. Clarke. Davey

Fol: jamar. Jones. Mckenzie.

Int: magner. Bate. Gysberts. Tapscott

Emg: dunn. Bail. J.Mcdonald

Full back line are all leadership material

Half back have plenty of run

Midfield is hard, tough, clearence specialists

Half forward line is very versatile, hard to match

Full forward line has a nice balance marking and crumbing

Interchange has 3 midfielders, with tapscott the sub.

This team should be very hard to play against. We should definitely be favorites going into round 1 against Brisbane.

Go dees.

Like your team 'tonatopia'

I'd find room for Sellar in the 22 , Probably have Green in the forward line but he could rotate in there with Watts and/or Davey .

I like your dash off half back (Pies like?) and the "outside the sqaure" thinking with Frawley is good .

Couch is a dark horse too but ya can't fit 'em all in the 22 !

Cheers

Edited March 25, 2012 by Macca

[Arrow 1,257]

Fb: bartram. Garland. Rivers

Hb: grimes. Frawley. Blease

C: trengove. Moloney. Green

Hf: Howe. Martin. Watts

Ff: Petterd. Clarke. Davey

Fol: jamar. Jones. Mckenzie.

Int: magner. Bate. Gysberts. Tapscott

Emg: dunn. Bail. J.Mcdonald

Full back line are all leadership material

Half back have plenty of run

Midfield is hard, tough, clearence specialists

Half forward line is very versatile, hard to match

Full forward line has a nice balance marking and crumbing

Interchange has 3 midfielders, with tapscott the sub.

This team should be very hard to play against. We should definitely be favorites going into round 1 against Brisbane.

Go dees.

Team looks predominately good tonatopia however no disrespect there is no way Sam Blease could play HBF. He is very much an Andrew Gaff type player who runs forward and not incredibly hard backwards. Go to a Casey game and if you see him sprinting back following his opponent I'll pay for your ticket. Other than that very happy with team

[jayceebee31 761]

Team looks predominately good tonatopia however no disrespect there is no way Sam Blease could play HBF. He is very much an Andrew Gaff type player who runs forward and not incredibly hard backwards. Go to a Casey game and if you see him sprinting back following his opponent I'll pay for your ticket. Other than that very happy with team

Don't forget he played HBF in his few games last year.But I agree more suited in other positions.

[dee-luded 2,959]

I'd like to see >

FB: Bartram, Sellar, Rivers

HB: Grimes, Frawley, Garland

C: Petterd, Moloney, Blease

HF: Green, Martin, Jones,

FF: Davey, Clark, Howe,

R: Jamar, Trengove, Magner

IC: Watts, Bate, McDonald, Sub: McKenzie,

Emerg: Bail, Tynan, Bennell,

Bring it on...

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,177]

I'd like to see >

FB: Bartram, Sellar, Rivers

HB: Grimes, Frawley, Garland

C: Petterd, Moloney, Blease

HF: Green, Martin, Jones,

FF: Davey, Clark, Howe,

R: Jamar, Trengove, Magner

IC: Watts, Bate, McDonald, Sub: McKenzie,

Emerg: Bail, Tynan, Bennell,

Bring it on...

I think thats pretty close.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Is Blease a walk up starter? I thought he would have had a run for Casey on the weekend.

[drdrake 3,174]

Is Blease a walk up starter? I thought he would have had a run for Casey on the weekend.

No, but I think he will play. My line up, Bennell as Sub in case Grimes can't run out the game.

Bartram Frawley Rivers

Grimes Garland MacDonald

Trengove Jones Bate

Howe Watts Petterd

Martin Clark Davey

Jamar Moloney Magnar

Green McKenzie Blease

Bennell

Sellar Dunn Couch

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

FB: Bartram - Frawley - Garland

HB: Grimes - Rivers - Blease

C: Jones - Trengove - Green

HF: Tapscott - Watts - Howe

FF: Petterd - Clark - Davey

R: Jamar - Moloney - Magner

I: Martin - Bail - Bate

S: Tynan

E: McKenzie - Bennell - Sellar

FYI: I dont think Sellar has a matchup against Brissy, I think he will be brought into the team when they have 2 gorillas and we need some extra strength.

Tynan deserves a game. His NAB cup was very good for a first year player.

[hardtack 10,537]

FB: Bartram - Frawley - Garland

HB: Grimes - Rivers - Bennell

C: Jones - Trengove - Bate

HF:Petterd - Watts - Howe

FF: Green - Clark - Davey

R: Jamar - Moloney - Magner

I: Martin - Bail - Dunn

S: McKenzie

E: Tapscott - Blease - Sellar

Nield has played Bennell every NAB Cup game and he was not playing for Casey on Saturday evening, so I think we can safely assume he will be a starter on Saturday. I think Tappy and Blease will get one more run at Casey before coming in unless it's decided that Grimes needs a bit longer, in which case one of them will go straight into the back line. For me it's a toss up between Dunn and Sellar as to who will be the emergency, but I feel Dunn may get the nod and go onto the Interchange bench.

Edited March 26, 2012 by hardtack

[Fat Tony 5,231]

Garland - Rivers (Longer/Leuenberger) - Bennell

Grimes - Frawley - Bail

Watts - Jones (Rich) - Trengove (Rockliff)

Howe – Clark - Petterd

Dunn - Green - Davey

Jamar – Moloney - Bartram (Black)

Magner – Martin - McKenzie

Tynan

Notes:

• I wouldn’t take too many underdone players into the game. Grimes would be the only one I would risk and I would also play Tynan as sub as insurance.
  
• I think we are already too slow in the midfield with Moloney, Magner, Jones, Trengove and McKenzie. For this reason Couch, Bate and Gysberts miss out and Davey will have to spend time in the midfield.
  
• Bartram’s kicking in the backline slows our transition into attack. I would play him as a hard tag on Black.
  
• Dunn is fit and played ok against Hawthorn. I would give him a chance to recapture his 2010 form given that Sylvia and Jurrah out.
  
• Three tall defenders are enough and four leaves us too slow on the rebound. Seller unlucky to miss.
  
• We are weak in the small backs department. Hopefully Bennell can improve and make the role his this year.
  
• Watts should be played on the wing until he gets strong enough to play KPF.
  
• Blease hasn’t done enough to earn a spot.
  
• Nicholson was a bit disappointing in the preseason, but I think he will be better on the bigger grounds. Not sure of his fitness.
  

Edited March 26, 2012 by Fat Tony

[Hannibal 5,814]

FYI: I dont think Sellar has a matchup against Brissy, I think he will be brought into the team when they have 2 gorillas and we need some extra strength.

Merrett ? Since Brown went down Merrett has gone forward. Resting rucks ? I prefer our structure with Sellar in the side.

FB: Bartram, Sellar, Rivers

HB: Grimes, Frawley, Garland

C: Watts, Moloney, Jones

HF: Green, Martin, Howe,

FF: Petterd, Clark, Tynan,

R: Jamar, Trengove, Magner

IC: Couch, Dunn, McKenzie, Sub: Blease,

Emerg: Morton, Strauss, Tapscott

This is the team I'd like to see, but I doubt I will.

I'm a little over players like Bate, JMac, Davey, Bennell, Bail, Dunn (scrapes in), etc.

I like what Couch and Magner bring to the side and I really like Tynan - he's hard, but has some class. The sooner we get Strauss and Tapscott into the side the better, but they probably need another game, or two at Casey.

Watts is presently better suited to a wing than a key forward role, so let's see what he's got in round one up the field at AFL level.

[rpfc 28,433]

I think a few outsmart themselves when doing a positional 22. I think we need around 10 mids to rotate through the middle and I can see Couch being apart of that for Rd 1.

Key Backs (5) - Frawley, Garland, Grimes, Rivers, and Batram.

Key Forwards (5) - Clark, Davey, Howe, Martin, and Watts.

Ruck (1) - Jamar

Mids/Rotation players (10) - Moloney, Magner, Trengove, Jones, Bate (FWD), Green (FWD), McKenzie, Bail (DEF), Petterd (FWD), and Couch.

Edited March 26, 2012 by rpfc

[rpfc 28,433]

I'm a little over players like Bate, JMac, Davey, Bennell, Bail, Dunn (scrapes in), etc.

If you have condemned Davey, Dunn should be a vacant lot by now.

I'm losing patience with Aaron, but Dunn has nothing but half a season a few years ago to fall back on.

I have no idea what Bail is doing on that list...