will all our assistants be gone

[dees189227 11,315]

Will any of our assistants be saved. I reckon Scott West is still a good person to have around unless the new coach has someone better in mind. I think Josh could be replaced and Brian Royal is an experienced person but I think in todays footy we need someone fresh out of the game.

Should it be a case of wipe the slate clean and bring in fresh voices?

[beelzebub 22,754]

its a good question. As Todds job sort of sits outside the immediate coaching circle he'l be there. As to others.. , well many senior coaches like to pick their own.

Id imagine the current lot might be sprucing up their CV's

[e25 5]

Depends entirely on the incoming coach.

Not worth discussing until that is sorted.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Will any of our assistants be saved. I reckon Scott West is still a good person to have around unless the new coach has someone better in mind. I think Josh could be replaced and Brian Royal is an experienced person but I think in todays footy we need someone fresh out of the game.

Should it be a case of wipe the slate clean and bring in fresh voices?

That will surely depend entirely on the Coach we get to take over. It will be interesting whether we get a 'Term Coach', or if we go with a short term WamBam hit & Run Coach for one Year.

I wouldn't mind a 1Year coach, to put the cleaners through the "crushed velvet", on our list & then starch everthing within reach.

[jumbo returns 6,619]

I don't think any will survive. Brian Royal will be the first to be shown the door.

Edited August 5, 2011 by jumbo returns

[rpfc 27,692]

I don't think any will survive. Brian Royal will be the first to be shown the door.

That's your opinion based on your opinion that Royal isn't a good defensive coach.

I feel that they will all go.

It's a shame but the tar brush is wide and sicky...

[angrydee 842]

Successful clubs turn assistants over every 2 - 4 years. Fresh ideas, enthusiasm etc. They should all be turfed. Mark Williams has been there for 11 years.

[jumbo returns 6,619]

That's your opinion based on your opinion that Royal isn't a good defensive coach.

I feel that they will all go.

It's a shame but the tar brush is wide and sicky...

Royal was there during the Danners years and struggled then too.

[Sir Why You Little 35,343]

Once Dean was terminated that is it for all our contracted coaches.

That's the rub of the green.

[old dee 23,256]

Once Dean was terminated that is it for all our contracted coaches.

That's the rub of the green.

You would doubt any of them would be thinking of long service leave!

[Sir Why You Little 35,343]

You would doubt any of them would be thinking of long service leave!

Long service in AFL is calculated on a weekly basis.!!!

[Nasher 33,246]

I reckon the lot of them are cactus. Bailey might've been the one who took the fall for 186, but he's not the only one who got hit by the splatter. If they weren't all tarnished before, they are now.

[beelzebub 22,754]

Well the coaching merry go round will be cranked up to a blur this seasons end...lol

[Swampfox 190]

I would expect it would be a necessity for the incumbent senior coach to add his team of assistants

Bernie Quinlan is the perfect example of what happens when you don't

I would expect some to be asked to stay but not all

If you have a harmonious and productive working environment good things happen

The days of the coach who does everything aka Grant Thomas are long gone

[Deeoldfart 7,864]

The new coach, whoever that might be, will want to hand pick his own entourage. Even if it were Tod Viney, I expect he would want to hand-pick his own lieutenants.

[Kento80 83]

I reckon the lot of them are cactus. Bailey might've been the one who took the fall for 186, but he's not the only one who got hit by the splatter. If they weren't all tarnished before, they are now.

Love it Nasher.

I'd happily see them all go. Obviously Bailey is the head coach, but I only see decline not improvement through all parts of our game, and that to me says that the assistants aren't doing a very good job. Quite obviously I may be well wrong, but that is what I take from my observations, and if I'm correct then they all have to go.

[Ned 156]

I read this morning that Royal is contracted for three years. Please, please tell me it's not true. From the outset his appointment reeked of a spot at the club needing to be filled and him being the last assistant coach available as no other club wanted him.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

All the assistants will be gone at year end. They wont survive the incoming coach and fallout.

And its unlikely they would sign an assistant coach for 3 years when the head coach was up for one year....Hmmmm.

[Range Rover 1,935]

All assistants can consider themselves unemployed as of the sound of the final siren in round 24.

[gOLLy 401]

Must go....Have to be gone.

[darkhorse72 1,795]

yeah 1 read the 3 years as well for Royal.

BUt the new coach will have the final say and I would clan the place out if I was him. The only assistant that really impressed me was Wellman and he got pinch!

[demonique 314]

That's your opinion based on your opinion that Royal isn't a good defensive coach.

I feel that they will all go.

It's a shame but the tar brush is wide and sicky...

well, the back line certainly hasn't covered itself with glory since Wellman shot through.

it was a big strength last year for us, this year, totally disorganised!!

[BAMF 3,920]

Will any of our assistants be saved. I reckon Scott West is still a good person to have around unless the new coach has someone better in mind. I think Josh could be replaced and Brian Royal is an experienced person but I think in todays footy we need someone fresh out of the game.

Should it be a case of wipe the slate clean and bring in fresh voices?

Why do you think West should stay? Why do you think Royal and Josh Mahoney should go?

In every loss we have been thrashed in the midfield. Why do people think he should be spared? Because he was a great player?

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

yeah 1 read the 3 years as well for Royal.

BUt the new coach will have the final say and I would clan the place out if I was him. The only assistant that really impressed me was Wellman and he got pinch!

Agree. Getting Wellman was an absolute coup. Losing him was a very big loss.