Changes for next week

[DeeSpencer 23,508]

You guys know how Alistair Clarkson dropped Brad Sewell? He called it a warning to other players. Sewell was a late inclusion and got 39 touches. I say DO THE SAME WITH BATE.

You know that's the same Alistair Clarkson who stuck with Roughead week after week when he was barely getting a touch earlier in the season.

It's easy to send lessons to the group when you are off to play a Brisbane in Tasmania without Simon Black. They could have sent a lesson to half the side and still got home.

I'd drop Bate if he's not working hard enough and not putting his head over it. At the moment all he is doing wrong is making a few bad decisions, generally when he gets the ball at high half forward, looks to move it on quickly and finds no one up field.

[DeezMan 4]

People are very quick to get on someone's back. So it's Bate this week... poor guy.

We need him up forward as a nice target. When he's on... he's in ripping touch and he's a strong-body booming kick!

[Freak 100]

Dunn dropped? Now I've heard it all.

I would drop Johnson. Yes, he did well..but I believe it was at the expense of Jamar playing well.

OUT: johnson, bail (simply because no-one else is drop-able)

IN: Trengove, Mcdonald

*I don't think Bennell should be dropped. He kicked 2 and in a low scoring game thats fine by me

[agent 99 57]

Out Bate.

In Trengove.

How can anyone want to drop a young exciting Bennell that actually kicked a couple today and has a future even though he has barely played for this club. Then justify what bate (who kicked nothing today) has served up to us this season by wanting him to play next week considering how much more experience he has than Bennell.

Am I the only person seeing this?

[Guest Rojik of the Arctic]

OUT: Bennell, Johnson, MacDonald

Bennell was one of the few players that put-in in the first half, Johnson - even though I am not a fan - was one of the better ones today and JMac II was hard and tough at it all day.

I'd need to calm down a bit and watch the game again before I put up my ideas, but yours just don't make sense.

[bing181 8,228]

Morton looked as soft as ever and contributed little - but then when you are sent to Casey for a lesson and to harden up

Who said Morton was sent to Casey to "harden up", or even sent there for a lesson?

[Hellofatime 83]

I think you have been hard on MacDonald, surely number 3 in the back pocket deserves a rest.

[Hellofatime 83]

On second thoughts, I'd drop Bailey and bring in Malthouse. He gets a team going on the smell of an oily rag. Collingwood on top of the ladder! What would he do with our side?

[gOLLy 401]

Out : Bate, Morton

In : Maric, Tregrove

[deeflog 679]

INS : Trengove, McDonald, Marric

OUT : Morton(soft), Moloney(inj), Bruce(cost us the game)

[jackaub 1,402]

Out Bate in Trengove Bate needs to learn how to play

[mdemonski2 403]

For me

IN: Maric, McDonald, Trengove

OUT: Bennell, Johnson, MacDonald

McDonald & Trengove are automatics for mine, and I believe Maric has done enough to earn a spot in the team, and those of you who saw him play with Casey on saturday would probably agree.

All 3 who I have omitted are unlucky but I saw them as the 3 best suited to miss out. Bennell kicked a few but just doesn't do enough IMO. Johnson had his best game for the season but I've seen him do this several times before and not follow it up. Also with Mike Pyke as Sydney's 2nd ruckman, I believe Jamar will be able to mainly ruck with Dunn providing some support. As for Joel MacDonald he's unlucky as he played a decent game but with Rivers, Frawley, Garland and Bruce already playing down there they will be able to cover Sydney's talls/medium sized forwards.

FB: Garland, Frawley, Bartram

HB: Bruce, Rivers, Bail

C: Morton, McKenzie, Davey

HF: Sylvia, Bate, Maric

FF: Watts, Jurrah, Green

FOLL: Jamar, Moloney, McDonald

INT: Dunn, Jones, Scully, Trengove

EMERG: Bennell, Johnson, MacDonald

Edit: Clarify Johnson omission.

With all due respect, if these are the three players you want to drop, you were definitely watching a different game to the rest of us..

[Dee*ceiving 1,154]

I thought Bennell & Johnson were excellent. MacDonald also good, backed himself to win the ball and carry it many times over.

Bate was better in the second half but I agree his last 2 weeks have been poor. Unfortunately I don't think were in a position to leave him out with Petterd unavailable.

Jones lowered his colours and Jurrah is only running 1 way at the moment -------------> Goal.

1 change for mine

In - Trengove

Out - Moloney (if ijured) otherwise Jones

[Happeninghunts 7]

Bizarre. You have ommitted three of the days better performers.

I agree why would you drop them?

[Happeninghunts 7]

Out: Moloney (inj?), Bate, Jones (sick of watching him run into trouble. He needs to go back to basics at Casey).

In: Junior (if fit), Trengove (if fit), Grimes (if fit). Maric if one of the other 3 aren't fit.

I Concur

[Guest Deefence]

In: McDonald, Trengove

Out: Bartram, Bate.

Let me guess, didn't watch the game, only saw the stats?

Bartram worked harder than anyone else on that field yesterday, and when he was on him, kept Ballantyne to sweet F'A. Ballantyne scored four goals, one from Bruce's stuff up, two from Davey's stuff ups, and one he actually earned.

Bartram plays the team game, week in and week out.

For me, outs: Beamer (Rest)

In: Trengove

[DemonWA 3,536]

Beamer for trengove looks quite likley this week. Pity though cos we could use some toughness against the swans.

I think both Bate and Jones shouldnt be dropped although they both can frustrate me to no end! Seems like they both give their all, but somthimes get carried away with the "take the game on" message from the coaches and run them selves into trouble. Dont think dropping them would actually help them at all - probably better off siting them down and letting them know that maybe for a week or two they should make the easy passesinstead of trying to blaze away brilliantly.

Also, if beamer misses due to the cork, then jones should stay in for his bigger frame around the clearances.

Bennell played well yesterday - keep him in the side for sure

Cale Morton looks like he needs to run a little harder or somthing? Might be a toss up between him and Dunn for the match up on Goodes though?

[titan_uranus 22,811]

Can't see Bate being dropped, even though he deserves it. Bailey's been constantly talking about getting games into our forward line as a unit. He is a part of that forward line, so I'm thinking he stays.

In: Trengove, McDonald

Out: Moloney (inj.), Jones

The danger this week is that our second half will shadow our first, and too many will ignore how unbelievably bad we were in the first half at the expense of our improved second half.

Jones isn't a tagger's bootlace. And he's a liability with the ball. Jones to make way if McDonald's fit (which he should be).

[jacey 333]

Bennell was one of the few players that put-in in the first half, Johnson - even though I am not a fan - was one of the better ones today and JMac II was hard and tough at it all day.

I'd need to calm down a bit and watch the game again before I put up my ideas, but yours just don't make sense.

Agree. Bennell was good. He's effectively playing small forward and with the ball predominantly in freo's half in the first quarter/half, i'm not sure what ppl are looking at. He's one for the future.

Johnson - one of his better days and deserves his spot next week but Miller kicked 5 once too.

Jmac was solid.

Dunn out. Trengove in.

[Red Sox 2]

For me

IN: Maric, McDonald, Trengove

OUT: Bennell, Johnson, MacDonald

OUT - Bennell??? MacDonald????? Johnson??????

Wowee as BT says - not sure where you were watching TD?

I'll say Trengove to return

OUT - Moloney

And agree that Jones needs a spell if Junior returns. Jones & McKenzie playing Juniors role - would you drop Jordie? Nah didnt think so - has to be Jones.

Edited July 19, 2010 by Demon Jack 16

[The Insulter 0]

On second thoughts, I'd drop Bailey and bring in Malthouse. He gets a team going on the smell of an oily rag. Collingwood on top of the ladder! What would he do with our side?

I'll second that one!

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

I'd take Hardwick before Malthouse. But I'd take Bailey before both as it stands.

[stuie 7,374]

OUT: Moloney (inj), Bartram

IN: Maric, Cheney

(Trengove and Junior if they pull through are automatic, and if so then swap Maric and Cheney to emergencies)

Re: Bartram v Cheney - thought Barty was ok on Sunday but just feel like our defence is a bit impotent with Bruce, Rivers, and Bartram all just a bit too similar in their average to poor use of the ball, IMO Cheney is a bit tougher at it and let's face it Bailey wouldn't drop the other two even if they had 30 turnovers.

Re: Maric - if he doesn't come in this week then he must have said something about Baileys wife! Automatic choice for mine.

Would love to see Aussie come in too, but not sure who would make way for him yet, probably needs one more good game for Casey before he forces his way in.

[stuie 7,374]

For me

IN: Maric, McDonald, Trengove

OUT: Bennell, Johnson, MacDonald

OUT - Bennell??? MacDonald????? Johnson??????

Wowee as BT says - not sure where you were watching TD?

I'll say Trengove to return

OUT - Moloney

And agree that Jones needs a spell if Junior returns. Jones & McKenzie playing Juniors role - would you drop Jordie? Nah didnt think so - has to be Jones.

I reckon Junior can come in without one of Jones or McKenzie making way. Would love to see one of Jones, Junior, or Trengove (maybe even Davey) being used behind the ball and giving us someone in defence who is hard at it but can also us the ball to advantage when setting up our attack.

PS - Why all the Bennell hate from people? He's been great for us this year, especially if, like me, you value what players do when they DON'T have the ball, he's one of the few that keeps moving without the ball the whole game.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

On second thoughts, I'd drop Bailey and bring in Malthouse. He gets a team going on the smell of an oily rag. Collingwood on top of the ladder! What would he do with our side?

You have to be kidding... Collingwood one of the richest clubs in the AFL with biggest supporter base and best facilities operating on the smell of an oily rag . Malthouse would want to win this year. He has had 11 years with the everything at his feet and has not a flag at Pieland.

Was you first thought any better?