MFC Trade Talk 2020

[Stevienic23 1,183]

2 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Wait until next season or try to get him this year? He’s an RFA end of 2021 so personally I’d wait until then. 

Probably comes down to the form of Hibberd to some degree - even then I'd love to have both of them running around for us in form at the same time

[Skuit 10,031]

KPF with contested-marking chops is essential. 

[Lord Travis 10,763]

I like some of the suggestions, but we don't have much currency to trade for a lot them as we don't have a first rounder this year and due to compromised draft our 2nd rounder will be worth bugger all and likely fall into the 30s. We'd need to target free agents, and a KPF is still the biggest gaping hole in our list. A quality KPF would IMO rocket us up the ladder 6-7 places. 

King would obviously be perfect for us as a KPF. Have to trade for him. Don't believe we have currency and don't believe Suns would let him go. He was taken at pick 6, has more than proven his worth, and likely cost two first rounders now.

Laird would be a good get as a quality small for our backline. Again, would have to trade a first rounder for him and we don't have the currency.

Saad, same as above. Good small rebounder for backline, but not free agent so would cost a first rounder we don't have.

Williams would be good get as a half back/midfielder, though his body lets him down at times. He's a RFA, so if the price is right then he's a good target.

Cameron would be a great KPF for us, but he is on the older side at nearly 30 years old. RFA, so if price is right then wouldn't be opposed to getting him across. He's probably the best target despite his age.

Daniher as a KPF is also an option due to free agency status. His body & head may be shot though, so we can't afford to take a massive financial risk for a player who might rarely play. He should be a fallback option only IMO.

There are other young stars out of contract like Bailey Smith and Harry Perryman who look like they're going to be elite, but we don't have currency to land them. I'd be open to trading a quality player to get Bailey Smith across though. He's the exact type of classy rounded goal kicking midfielder we are lacking. Dogs would never let him go though.

[george_on_the_outer 7,691]

People are going to be disappointed during trade period this year.  It is doubtful that Melbourne will be heavily involved.

Why?

Compromised draft:  we have already given away our 1st round this year to be able to select Pickett last year.  At the time the club said that the compromised draft in 2020 meant picks were not in equivalent value to 2019.  Why would we then try to trade back into the same compromised draft?  If the 2021 draft is less compromised, then we may try to trade for future picks...leave that to Jason Taylor and the experts.

Existing list:  There are players who we haven't seen or barely sighted to this point.  Jordon, Sparrow, Rivers, Nietschke, Baker, Petty, Chandler all look to have something to offer, but can't get a game, because of the strength of the list ( or injury).  If list sizes are reduced, there are a good number of others outside this group who can be discarded, so apart from the required number of draftees ( 3 at the moment) we really don't need any more.

Since it is difficult for players outside our top 22 to get a run at the moment, there would be a chance that other clubs may be interested.  However, you are not going to get a high draft pick for those players.  e.g Sam Frost got Pick 50 and Hawks’ future second-round pick - GAVE AWAY Picks 42, 61 and Demons’ future fourth-round pick. Again, what is the point of 2nd, 3rd and 4th rounds picks in a compromised draft, and which we probably don't need or want in any case.

Unless a really good player comes to your club under FA arrangements, you have to give up the equivalent or more to get them.  Gone are the days of "stealing" talent from other clubs.  Even Gold Coast are keeping their high end talent these days. 

[adonski 12,406]

Can we trade the 2021 pick? 

[picket fence 17,435]

On 7/21/2020 at 8:21 PM, Lucifer's Hero said:

Ben Brown is gettable.  kangaroos-are-shopping-ben-brown-to-other-clubs

Sounds like North will test the water and if Brown gets a package that lands them a 1st round pick (#3-#5) they will let him go. 

I believe Barrett is a North supporter so he would have good mail.

I post that for info.  Not interested in going after him.

Edit:  To clarify, Brown is out of contract but not an FA,

Only  one problem ... We traded our first round picks last year. We have almost nothing that would be entertained as far as draft picks at this stage.

[godees 873]

27 minutes ago, adonski said:

Can we trade the 2021 pick? 

Yes

[adonski 12,406]

Another Pickett-esque small & a legit winger with speed and good kick would be ideal

[Deemania since 56 6,714]

On 7/21/2020 at 7:51 PM, Lucifer's Hero said:

Ben Brown is gettable.  kangaroos-are-shopping-ben-brown-to-other-clubs

Sounds like North will test the water and if Brown gets a package that lands them a 1st round pick (#3-#5) they will let him go. 

I believe Barrett is a North supporter so he would have good mail.

I post that for info.  Not interested in going after him.

Edit:  To clarify, Brown is out of contract but not an FA,

I'd think Brown would be an asset; however, there are two things I do not like about him, as follows:

• he fakes, attempts to fake, collapses on contact in front of umpires, rather than standing his ground to gather the ball; and
• he too infrequently goes to the barber shop, floppy, floppy, fuzzy-flop, flapper.

He can kick them, but his possession rate is reducing.

[daisycutter 29,692]

1 brown is more than enuff

[Greendale 350]

Surely we don't have the salary cap space for a player the calibre of Williams? In the last few years we've picked up Lever, May, Tomlinson and Langdon. Add that on top of the likes of Gawn, Oliver, TMac and Trac, and I'd imagine that our cap would be fairly full.

[WA Demon Boy 966]

If we can get Daniher for cheap then by all means - Burgo could fix him 

[Damo 3,373]

Im starting to come around to Ben Brown. He is the right age group and he is solely a FF. But at what cost?

If we swapped Weid for Collingwoods 1st rounder would we get anything more than that pick 15-20 to make the deal with North?

If just a straight swap, would we need to absorb some of his (as I understand it) large contract?

Would we have to add in another player, maybe a midfielder for North to be interested? Brayshaw, Salem? 

It sounds over the odds for Big Benny but if we are truly needing Brown for a flag and Ben King and Cameron are unobtainable, who else is ready to go and a true Full forward? 

[spirit of norm smith 16,559]

4 hours ago, MF-C said:
I'd like to see Tomlinson really take the game on. I hope the dropping was a wake up call because he clearly has all the attributes (although he doesn't have much pace) to be a great player. 

Agree MF-C. His lack of pace means the “wing” position is not really suited. He has great endurance which leads me to think of him more for CHF or possibly CHB. He’s a good mark and kick. I think his omission is concerning  even after only 4 games. He got a 4 year $$$ deal. 

[spirit of norm smith 16,559]

Just now, spirit of norm smith said:

Agree MF-C. His lack of pace means the “wing” position is not really suited. He has great endurance which leads me to think of him more for CHF or possibly CHB. He’s a good mark and kick. I think his omission is concerning  even after only 4 games. He got a 4 year $$$ deal. 

Tomlinson was my player referred to 

[adonski 12,406]

42 minutes ago, Greendale said:

Surely we don't have the salary cap space for a player the calibre of Williams? In the last few years we've picked up Lever, May, Tomlinson and Langdon. Add that on top of the likes of Gawn, Oliver, TMac and Trac, and I'd imagine that our cap would be fairly full.

Jones' departure will free up a bit of coin 

[Ethan Tremblay 30,958]

17 minutes ago, adonski said:

Jones' departure will free up a bit of coin 

He only signed on for one year at the end of last season, I could be wrong but I couldn’t imagine he’d be all on that much. 

[Grr-owl 1,244]

On 7/21/2020 at 4:10 PM, Lord Nev said:

Have posted it before, and understand some don't like the idea, but Gus for Saad and then Salem takes Gus' role?

 

With the talk about outside run and wings and all, what happens to Tomlinson?

[Ted Lasso 19,547]

Tom Papley? would be hard to find a good deal for Sydney but he'd be more than handy. 

[BW511 2,688]

1 hour ago, Damo said:

Im starting to come around to Ben Brown. He is the right age group and he is solely a FF. But at what cost?

If we swapped Weid for Collingwoods 1st rounder would we get anything more than that pick 15-20 to make the deal with North?

If just a straight swap, would we need to absorb some of his (as I understand it) large contract?

Would we have to add in another player, maybe a midfielder for North to be interested? Brayshaw, Salem? 

It sounds over the odds for Big Benny but if we are truly needing Brown for a flag and Ben King and Cameron are unobtainable, who else is ready to go and a true Full forward? 

I don't watch many games other than ours, but he doesn't strike me as someone who using his size enough. He is a run and jump forward, not one that will run through brick walls to create opportunity

[Deeko2 842]

6 hours ago, Dees2014 said:

Still think Hunt has some value if he can improve his kicking accuracy.....

I’m a fan of Hunt but if we go fishing again then we have to release some money from somewhere. He might have a little bit of trade value currency but I doubt it.

Really can’t see his kicking improving anymore noting hehas been around the club for nearly 7 years now. 

Jones, Jetta and Hunt have been favourites of mine at different stages but if moving them on brought in another best 22 player in say a Zac Williams (that we wouldn’t have to trade for) then I’d be all for it.

Would love Cameron or a King boy at our club but you need to move heaven and earth to grab a proven key forward. Ben Brown is fairly under rated here. I’d have him in our team over the current lads.

If Weid/TMac finish the year poorly then I’m happy to make a key forward priority one. But right now, I’m all about simpler improvements and whilst still bringing in high quality kids.

 

Edited July 24, 2020 by Deeko2

[WERRIDEE 5,502]

1 hour ago, Patches O’houlihan said:

Tom Papley? would be hard to find a good deal for Sydney but he'd be more than handy. 

When is he a free agent?

[Lord Nev 13,512]

1 hour ago, Grr-owl said:

With the talk about outside run and wings and all, what happens to Tomlinson?

Needs to find form, but we had both he and Gus in the team at the same time previously, so don't think their roles exclude each other.

Edited July 24, 2020 by Lord Nev

[Lord Travis 10,763]

1 hour ago, Patches O’houlihan said:

Tom Papley? would be hard to find a good deal for Sydney but he'd be more than handy. 

Will likely be at Carlton next season. Nominated them last trade period, Sydney requested first rounder, Carlton agreed but then deals fell over and they weren't able to get it done. They've already been in dialogue with him again and it's been in the news as recently as today. Either way, we'd need a first rounder for him and we don't have one this year. I wouldn't trade next years for another small forward either. No chance of being a Demon.

[spirit of norm smith 16,559]

10 hours ago, adonski said:

Another Pickett-esque small & a legit winger with speed and good kick would be ideal

Yes a highly skilled mid with pace as a running outside wing.