GAMEDAY: Rd 19 vs St Kilda

[forever demons 2,316]

on the more positive side ,go dees we can do it

[dees189227 12,453]

I have no idea what to expect. Last time they gave us a hammering. Bruce and Membrey worry me and with no May down there who knows what will happen. 

I can't make it tonight but will be following the scores. 

Lets hope we can kick straight. I liked lewis in the forward line last week if only he could have kicked straight.

Hopefully Max can dominate around the ground and the midfielders respond with first use. 

[Neil Crompton 5,747]

5 minutes ago, forever demons said:

you think you are doing it tough,Iwas born 1952 and was mfc supporter from then on,mfc member ,redlegs member,chucked so much money into this club and here I sit wondering WHY ,just to watch us fail time and time again

Thank god footy is just a game - or we’d all be taking this losing caper so seriously. 

 

F’ing MFC.

[Lord Nev 13,512]

2 hours ago, In Harmes Way said:

2020 starts now

Not sure I agree, but I get where you're coming from.

I just don't buy the 'line in the sand' stuff with this club anymore. We've had more than enough of those and generally failed at them. I hope I'm wrong, but I feel like this year has exposed that our culture wasn't totally fixed and when tested (aka 'line in the sand') it doesn't stand up. I'm not blaming the results on that solely as there's clearly many other factors at work, but just the way we've gone about it as a club this year has been so cardboard and listless that it feels like we're back to the 'just show up and get a paycheck' type of culture.

I know to some it might sound silly, and we don't talk about it much anymore, but I still can't shake the feeling that things turned somewhat with the cancelled camp.

[McQueen 17,867]

49 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Backing us in for a win tonight. 

We play Marvel well and we haven't been playing bad footy recently. I think we are due a win. 

Just watched Captain Marvel on the trip over..... this could be an omen?

One thing I know for sure is that Brie Larson is seriously easy to look at.  

[Sir Why You Little 37,302]

13 minutes ago, Lord Nev said:

 

I know to some it might sound silly, and we don't talk about it much anymore, but I still can't shake the feeling that things turned somewhat with the cancelled camp.

Power Shifts are never good when the Top Man is usurped. Regardless of whether it was “worked out”....

We will find out how strong Goodwin is this Summer...

[Lord Nev 13,512]

9 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Power Shifts are never good when the Top Man is usurped. Regardless of whether it was “worked out”....

We will find out how strong Goodwin is this Summer...

Yeah i think a lot will hinge on how Goody manages to balance his (seeming) want for total control (or stubbornness possibly), his need for better support, building relationships with a group that has had no consistency in lineup this year and re-intstilling the work ethic we've missed this year. Really intriguing offseason where we have to balance stability and change.

[Sir Why You Little 37,302]

5 minutes ago, Lord Nev said:

Yeah i think a lot will hinge on how Goody manages to balance his (seeming) want for total control (or stubbornness possibly), his need for better support, building relationships with a group that has had no consistency in lineup this year and re-intstilling the work ethic we've missed this year. Really intriguing offseason where we have to balance stability and change.

Yes it will be a defining preseason on many levels. 

I am glad we have the senior fitness position sorted. That is where the discipline must start from

[Hot as Hell 466]

4 hours ago, ProperDee said:

Seriously though, I’m over “line in the sand” games. I am truly at the stage where I am embarrassed to be a Demons fan. I started barracking for this club in 1966 after coming back to Australia with my family as an 11 year old from Canada (left at age 4). 

I’ve followed this team through thick and thin. Enjoyed the rare good times and graciously accepted the bad but this year has been something else. I believe last year was a fluke and 2019 has clearly revealed our lack of skills, depth and quality coaching. Yeah, injuries didn’t help but hand balling to targets and kicking for goal are the most basic of fundamentals and these guys are professionals? Gimme a break please....

 Behind closed doors, the handful of talented players we do have must be having second thoughts about staying with the club. We are a train wreck and frankly I’ve had enough. I will still follow the team but sadly the passion I once had has gone. I won’t be renewing my membership any time soon. Thanks to all at the Melbourne Football Club. I hope you are happy with yourselves.

Believe me, l hear you ProperDee.

It has been a very long and excruciating ride for many of us.

I was intending to go tonight,  as l have done through all those dark decades and not so long ago dark days. Last year genuinely lifted my spirits for a great 2019. Now that it is here, and looks as it does, l find it much much harder to raise the spirit, than l did in our darkest hours.

I have decided not to go to the game, irrespective of the outcome.

We have played like a hapless rabble this year. It very hard to watch.  Good players have been reduced to hand ball robots with little leadership or direction of or off the field.

Maxy, Salo and 1 or 2 others have played their part.  The rest have fallen off a cliff.

I can't wait until the season is over. I expect over summer, l will be revitalised by the fit list training the house down. 

It's been many years since l have felt so flat about Melbourne Football Club, after supporting them since early 60s.?

Edited July 27, 2019 by Hot as Hell
Typos

[In Harmes Way 7,840]

It’s so bad this year @Hot as Hell that I went and bought some skis to join the cliche.

[defuture15 900]

5 hours ago, ProperDee said:

Reads fine when you insert your own commas.

Comma, Comma, Comma, Comma, Comma,Karmeleon!

Edited July 27, 2019 by defuture15
One more Comma!

[Demonstone 23,336]

But certain posters tell me we're a Club with no Culture.

[Deeoldfart 8,104]

1 hour ago, forever demons said:

you think you are doing it tough,Iwas born 1952 and was mfc supporter from then on,mfc member ,redlegs member,chucked so much money into this club and here I sit wondering WHY ,just to watch us fail time and time again

Its been a very long time fd, but at least you've had 6 Flags in your lifetime (and I'm one up on you !)  The ones I really feel sorry for are my kids (3 all in their 40s).  As part of our  household they had no choice about what team to support, and they've stuck fat all the way.  I'm not sure if it's out of 'blind loyalty' to the MFC or their old man. (lol).

Edited July 27, 2019 by Deeoldfart
Typo

[FireInTheBennelly 4,101]

No idea what to expect, confidence is shattered. If we were playing a top 4 side I'd say we're a chance, but against pretenders it's a lottery.

I think if we lose this I might just start agreeing with Lyon's sentiment that last year was the anomaly. Please show us something MFC.

[Docs Demons 1,792]

2 hours ago, forever demons said:

on the more positive side ,go dees we can do it

That's the spirit. Need more like yourself. We certainly can do it if we bring the desire and improved skills with our better players playing to their potential.

Go Dees. Finish off year with some good performances and give us long suffering supporters something to hang onto for 2020

[faultydet 7,623]

4 hours ago, ding said:

Im predicting a win today.

Not a one sided, running-away-in-the-last kind of win... I predict a win that has us falling over the line by less than a goal, followed by the team singing the club song like they just won a Finals game. Goody will then post a video with a smug grin, talking about us having "the will and the want" today. Many fans will also feel flat because of the lack of quality in said win.

Dees by 3 points.

Because 2019

Nah, he'll raise his chin skywards, while dribbling on about "making connections"

I Expect a win, but think we will lose.

[Deesprate 1,324]

7 hours ago, Mel Bourne said:

Some pretty fascinating typos happening here  

 

Didn’t realise it was an English exam!

[Soidee 1,496]

2 hours ago, Hot as Hell said:

Believe me, l hear you ProperDee.

It has been a very long and excruciating ride for many of us.

I was intending to go tonight,  as l have done through all those dark decades and not so long ago dark days. Last year genuinely lifted my spirits for a great 2019. Now that it is here, and looks as it does, l find it much much harder to raise the spirit, than l did in our darkest hours.

I have decided not to go to the game, irrespective of the outcome.

We have played like a hapless rabble this year. It very hard to watch.  Good players have been reduced to hand ball robots with little leadership or direction of or off the field.

Maxy, Salo and 1 or 2 others have played their part.  The rest have fallen off a cliff.

I can't wait until the season is over. I expect over summer, l will be revitalised by the fit list training the house down. 

It's been many years since l have felt so flat about Melbourne Football Club, after supporting them since early 60s.?

You sum up my feelings perfectly.  Care factor is not there. Goodwin needs to grab this group by the throat and show he means business.  The pre season Camp no show now looms much larger for me.  The softness of this club is the most relevant point in most discussions.

[Ethan Tremblay 31,243]

8 minutes ago, Soidee said:

You sum up my feelings perfectly.  Care factor is not there. Goodwin needs to grab this group by the throat and show he means business.  The pre season Camp no show now looms much larger for me.  The softness of this club is the most relevant point in most discussions.

To be fair, they didn’t want to get mud on their shoes. 

[Demonsone 2,050]

Don’t be surprised if Carlton win more games than us  & currently  on track to beat the crows. We are the laughing stock of the afl from prelim to last!

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,956]

I'm [censored] (really annoyed) that May is not playing as one good thing that could come for us in this last half a dozen or so games is for our backline to get some continuity and really gel together.  But by the same token, I'm also glad that they are taking a conservative approach to May's hammy as I really don't want us taking so many injured players into preseason and a repeat of this year's injury debacle next season, so I'll cop loosing May on the chin.  It's not disastrous for O Mac to be getting another hit out down back at AFL level either.  Granted O Mac has been underwhelming this season to be polite, but on his day he can also provide a sufficient solid option, so I think that also bodes well for both our chances tonight and the seasons ahead that we can bring him in as a backup.

If you look at it objectively,  I think our performance post the bye has been reasonably solid and all the doom and gloom during the week is somewhat overblown and due to us slipping back a place on the ladder due to fixture issues more than anything.  I think we will win tonight, without being particularly confident about it.  Watching us in some of the games post bye, it's apparent to me that we are playing with more confidence and much cleaner ball movement than we did earlier in the year when we were fairly rabble like.  We have been compeditive against several top eight sides in Adelaide and West Coast, without quite being able to crack it.  The worm just has to turn for us soon.

Edited July 27, 2019 by Rodney (Balls) Grinter
Really annoyed = [censored]

[Demonsone 2,050]

6 minutes ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

I'm [censored] (really annoyed) that May is not playing as one good thing that could come for us in this last half a dozen or so games is for our backline to get some continuity and really gel together.  But by the same token, I'm also glad that they are taking a conservative approach to May's hammy as I really don't want us taking so many injured players into preseason and a repeat of this year's injury debacle next season, so I'll cop loosing May on the chin.  It's not disastrous for O Mac to be getting another hit out down back at AFL level either.  Granted O Mac has been underwhelming this season to be polite, but on his day he can also provide a sufficient solid option, so I think that also bodes well for both our chances tonight and the seasons ahead that we can bring him in as a backup.

If you look at it objectively,  I think our performance post the bye has been reasonably solid and all the doom and gloom during the week is somewhat overblown and due to us slipping back a place on the ladder due to fixture issues more than anything.  I think we will win tonight, without being particularly confident about it.  Watching us in some of the games post bye, it's apparent to me that we are playing with more confidence and much cleaner ball movement than we did earlier in the year when we were fairly rabble like.  We have been compeditive against several top eight sides in Adelaide and West Coast, without quite being able to crack it.  The worm just has to turn for us soon.

Fed up with competitive... we are a disgrace of how this season has gone & just another one of many in the last 55yrs of which suffering supporters have to put up with! Understand injuries have impacted & could accept just missing finals but our issues run much deeper with culture & leadership & question the coaching of the team. Three other sides sacked their coaches & are winning more games than us ..  how the hell does this happen & why? Not advocating to sack Goodwin but ffs we members need f...ing answers!

[MarkMacca 133]

4 hours ago, forever demons said:

you think you are doing it tough,Iwas born 1952 and was mfc supporter from then on,mfc member ,redlegs member,chucked so much money into this club and here I sit wondering WHY ,just to watch us fail time and time again

Is it a competition as to who has suffered the most? Surely not.

[forever demons 2,316]

3 hours ago, Deeoldfart said:

Its been a very long time fd, but at least you've had 6 Flags in your lifetime (and I'm one up on you !)  The ones I really feel sorry for are my kids (3 all in their 40s).  As part of our  household they had no choice about what team to support, and they've stuck fat all the way.  I'm not sure if it's out of 'blind loyalty' to the MFC or their old man. (lol).

if you are one up on me what year was that ,was it 54,if so are you about a very young 70

[John Crow Batty 8,880]

Never mind the quality of the opposition. We save our worst for prime time. Could get ugly and embarrassing.