7 minutes ago, Alex Flood said:

has the club considered giving up pick 3 for Hill ?

And 900k a season for 6 years? I bloody hope not. 

1 hour ago, Demonland said:

Fremantle up to their old tricks. 

 

Freo are predictable and deserve to be dealt with accordingly.

 

pick 12 and 18 are now with the aints - there's yr two first rounders for brad hill

StKilda are in a tight spot as they've offered him a massive contract (cash and years) and he's contracted to Fremantle.

With that said, I would have thought pick 6 (with perhaps a swap of later picks was fair enough).

 

 

Seems like Freemantle is getting a taste of their own medicine after spliiting their picks we were after for Jesse last year. The vindictive side of me is pretty happy about this, although the dockers can just keep hill if they aren't happy with those picks from the saints.

I wonder if this means we'll deal with giants for 6 and something?

5 minutes ago, Nascent said:

I wonder if this means we'll deal with giants for 6 and something?

i reckon we'd be better off just taking it to the draft.

If No Ben King. Draft!!!

I think the obvious move is to go for freo's 2 first rounders for our pick 3. Say 3 for 7 and 18 - suits our needs best, but they would want something in return. Or go 3 for 7 and langdon (probably we win that one) or 3 for 12, langdon and a later 3rd round pick).

St Kilda shafting Freo is my favourite move of the trade period. We could land Bontempelli from here and it couldn't get better than that ? 

How's this sound?

Melb give Brayshaw 3,22

Melb get Hill, Langdon 7,26

2 minutes ago, Parmalove said:

How's this sound?

Melb give Brayshaw 3,22

Melb get Hill, Langdon 7,26

Is that you Peter?

24 minutes ago, Parmalove said:

How's this sound?

Melb give Brayshaw 3,22

Melb get Hill, Langdon 7,26

Would love Brad Hill. Should we start a gofundme page for donations?

If we have the money, should we go all out for Hill with pick 3? He’s exactly the type of player we need.

Freo wanted  pick 6, a future first rounder and a third rounder for him. Can't see him being traded for pick 3, and not sure we have the 900k to lure him to us anyway.

 

Too expensive on the books for mine. Langdon will do us well at a lesser expense

They were suggesting on trade radio that 3 should get it done. We also have the Elliot money left over. Also, Bell seems the type to hold a grudge, so might want to deal with someone other than the saints to make a statement.

He's not worth $900k a season. Maybe $700k.

1 minute ago, AaronDaveyChipsAndGravey said:

Too expensive on the books for mine. Langdon will do us well at a lesser expense

On trade radio, they were suggesting 3 & 22, for Hill & Langdon. Would be great having one on each wing.

If we could split the 3 into a 6 and say a 10, we could give Freo the 6 for Hill and use the other in the draft. We would be under no obligation to offer the ridiculous coin that the Saints have. Although, do we need both Hill and Langdon?

I feel that we still need a gun pick up from the draft, tho’.

IMO the less we have to deal with Freo, the better. I’d like to get the Langdon deal done and not have to put up with any of their [censored]. 

Their St Kilda demands are pathetic. They did a similar thing to us last year as what Saints are doing to them with their early pick. Total hypocrisy 

Please merge with Brad Hill thread...

2 minutes ago, 3183 Dee said:

If we could split the 3 into a 6 and say a 10, we could give Freo the 6 for Hill and use the other in the draft. We would be under no obligation to offer the ridiculous coin that the Saints have. Although, do we need both Hill and Langdon?

I don’t think Freo would accept say just a 6 for Hill, but would accept 3. Also, I think if we could get 2 top 10 picks from GWS we would take them to the draft. I also think we do need both Hill & Langdon, one on each wing.

7 minutes ago, Dees247 said:

On trade radio, they were suggesting 3 & 22, for Hill & Langdon. Would be great having one on each wing.

My only problem is why did we recruit Tomlinson then? He’d have to move either forward or back and probably completely changes why he was recruited in the first place. Also Freo were demanding 2 1st rounders for Hill. How is that going to get both Hill and Langdon done? We’d be selling the farm to get both done and paying out the a for Hill. We need to be saving this money for a decent forward