The Line Coaches

[Hellofatime 84]

I know we are only playing with 14 players on the ground each week and it's a credit to those 14 to get the ball in so often, but, who are our forwards coaches because we don't seem to have any plan, system or confidence when it's in the 50 arc!

 

 

 

[fired up 77]

Blind Freddie

[Gorgoroth 13,124]

Why worry about the forwards? The biggest problem is the midfield who over handball, stuff around with it then bomb it in long to anywhere in the f50, anywhere would do.

[dazzledavey36 55,453]

Max Rooke

[deebug 1,754]

3 minutes ago, Gorgoroth said:

Why worry about the forwards? The biggest problem is the midfield who over handball, stuff around with it then bomb it in long to anywhere in the f50, anywhere would do.

100% agree.

If we don't fix this in the off season it will be time for the rebuild drums again.

[Damo 3,405]

You would think Nick Reiwoldt or Wayne Carey would be available(payable) to come down and talk forward craft to forwards and mids.

[Queanbeyan Demon 6,892]

here they are

[Damo 3,405]

Just now, Queanbeyan Demon said:

here they are

Isnt that Preuss 2nd from the right on the top row?

[Queanbeyan Demon 6,892]

3 minutes ago, Damo said:

Isnt that Preuss 2nd from the right on the top row?

recon you're right Damo. recon i spotted nat jones in there as well. 

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

H.R. Pufnstuf, Kling, Klang, Fleagle, Bingo, Drooper and Snork.

[Mondê 525]

Troy Chaplin?

[DeeSpencer 26,091]

There's clearly no connection between the forwards and mids. 50/50 blame. 

The only thing I can say to defend the coaches is that the forwards are trained to focus so much on defensive work - partially because the midfield and backline have been so poor defensively to start the year - that they have lost a lot of attacking focus. The backline and midfield are defending far better and the forwards are going ok in that regard. The focus can shift back on to attacking play.

Also look at the personnel: 

Hannan's 3rd game this year - rusty as heck. 
Garlett - cooked
Spargo - limited
Tommy Mc - awful

Hunt, Petracca, Weid ok.

Judging a coach largely requires talent, which means a healthy and confident Tommy Mc or a different tall target plus some better smalls.

[Salems Lot 2,662]

Anyone who knows my posts would know that I hate potting players but I seriously thing  TMac needs a spell in the 2s.  A man without a plan.

[Diamond_Jim 12,639]

2 hours ago, Gorgoroth said:

Why worry about the forwards? The biggest problem is the midfield who over handball, stuff around with it then bomb it in long to anywhere in the f50, anywhere would do.

yep... the vaunted midfield is not playing well.

Perhaps ban Oliver from hand balling for an occasional quarter or two

[picket fence 17,730]

More to the point 7 goals 15

AN ABSOLUTE INDICTMENT ON THE CLUB, COACHES AND PLAYERS who just cannot kick a friggen goal.

Sheeeeit it aint that hard from set shots!! It really isn't!

This after last weeks debacle. we are very SLOW Learners.!

[picket fence 17,730]

2 hours ago, Damo said:

You would think Nick Reiwoldt or Wayne Carey would be available(payable) to come down and talk forward craft to forwards and mids.

Oh Yeah, give me Nick "Freddie Mercury" Reiwoldt anyday 

Kicked CRUNCH goals and was a real "Dead eye [censored]"

[Pipefitter 2,180]

Poorly coached and bereft of talent. Down there with Gold Coast as the worst forward line in the league. At least they have Sexton.

[bing181 9,343]

22 shots on goal should be enough to get the job done, but almost none of them are renowned for their kicking prowess. 

[DV8 2,271]

2 hours ago, picket fence said:

Oh Yeah, give me Nick "Freddie Mercury" Reiwoldt anyday 

Kicked CRUNCH goals and was a real "Dead eye [censored]"

Not in his early years he didn't,  'PF'.    He was as bad as 'Richo'.

Riewoldt fixed his kicking around the time he played predominantly wing.   Half way thru his career,  he got much better.

[John Demonic 5,870]

9 hours ago, fired up said:

Blind Freddie

[Matsuo Basho 1,053]

Max Rooke

Troy Chaplin

Ben Matthews

Greg Stafford

Justin Plapp

Tell me I'm wrong but that list of former players does not scream "skill, vision and finesse" to me. ALL OF THEM were either backmen or good honest battlers.

Maybe some assistant coaches who were renowned for their skills and vision might impart some teachings about skills and vision to our players? Just a thought.

*Mods - The forward line coach thread should be subsumed into this broader one.

 

[Macca 17,080]

In other sports around the world (notably the NFL & NBA) clubs often do a cleanout of the assistants whilst at the same time keeping the head coach.

Some responsibilities might be taken from the head coach as a matter of course too.

And you don't want to necessarily wait until the proverbial hits the fan before making those changes.  Rebuilding of the list to varying degrees are often needed too.

We have to do something and only a thorough review will reveal what we need to do.  Those doing the review need to be detached or semi-detached from those who they are reviewing.

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

[scarlett 247]

16 hours ago, Hellofatime said:

I know we are only playing with 14 players on the ground each week and it's a credit to those 14 to get the ball in so often, but, who are our forwards coaches because we don't seem to have any plan, system or confidence when it's in the 50 arc!

 

 

 

Interesting watching casey with more afl players available this week had much more space in the fwd50 and a clear change in plan and execution. Hopefully its the start of change.

[ManDee 7,236]

If we insist on bombing it in we need a man mountain. Rest Tommy Mac FFS give Preuss a few games in a row.  This years average stats.

 

Braydon Preuss	Name	Tom McDonald
Melbourne Demons	Team	Melbourne Demons
Ruck	Position	Forward
10	Career Games	158
Surfers Paradise	Origin	North Ballarat
June 16, 1995	Date of Birth	September 18, 1992
23yr 11mth	Age	26yr 8mth
206cm	Height	194cm
109kg	Weight	100kg
2014 Rookie Draft	Last Drafted In	2010 National Draft
Round 1, Pick #15	Last Draft Position	Round 3, Pick #53
North Melbourne Kangaroos	Last Drafted By	Melbourne Demons
2019	Stats for Season	2019
2	Games	12
10.0	Kicks	7.4
3.0	Handballs	4.5
13.0	Disposals	11.9
2.0	Marks	3.6
2.0	Goals	0.7
0	Behinds	0.8
1.0	Tackles	1.6
14.5	Hitouts	1.3
3.0	Inside 50s	2.2
0	Goal Assists	0.4
1.0	Frees For	0.8
0.5	Frees Against	0.8
9.0	Contested Possessions	5.8

Edited June 11, 2019 by ManDee