joeboy 3,193 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Jones - slowing but effective Viney - little spacial awareness Gawn - an outstanding game Oliver - few clean disposals Harmes - great first half Hunt - some impressive cameos Garlett - goals but wasteful Petracca - hugely wasteful performance Salem - rarely disposed effectively Stretch - momentum killer again Brayshaw - lost on flank T.McDonald - ten minute game Frost - confident but costly Hore - endeavour and composure O.McDonald - a serviceable game Wagner - jittery with ball Smith - little to enthuse Lockhart - was rarely sighted Neal-Bullen - average before injury Petty - was not disgraced Fritsch - devoid of awareness Baker - overawed but promising 3 Quote
illbarto 436 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 1 minute ago, joeboy said: Jones - slowing but effective Viney - little spacial awareness Gawn - an outstanding game Oliver - few clean disposals Harmes - great first half Hunt - some impressive cameos Garlett - goals but wasteful Petracca - hugely wasteful performance Salem - rarely disposed effectively Stretch - momentum killer again Brayshaw - lost on flank T.McDonald - ten minute game Frost - confident but costly Hore - endeavour and composure O.McDonald - a serviceable game Wagner - jittery with ball Smith - little to enthuse Lockhart - was rarely sighted Neal-Bullen - average before injury Petty - was not disgraced Fritsch - devoid of awareness Baker - overawed but promising Please do this for the Eagles list too. Did anyone play to your standards I wonder? Such a pesimistic post 3 1 Quote
demon3165 2,865 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 2 minutes ago, joeboy said: Jones - slowing but effective Please Please retire Viney - little spacial awareness No football brain Gawn - an outstanding game Oliver - few clean disposals Harmes - great first half Hunt - some impressive cameos Garlett - goals but wasteful Petracca - hugely wasteful performance Salem - rarely disposed effectively Stretch - momentum killer again Brayshaw - lost on flank T.McDonald - ten minute game Frost - confident but costly Hore - endeavour and composure O.McDonald - a serviceable game Wagner - jittery with ball Smith - little to enthuse Lockhart - was rarely sighted Neal-Bullen - average before injury Petty - was not disgraced Fritsch - devoid of awareness Baker - overawed but promising Quote
Damo 3,466 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Petracca - put him in cotton wool and ask for a round 1 pick. Stretch - twitchy yet slowthinking Quote
RalphiusMaximus 6,112 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 I think you've missed the mark on a few of these this week Joeboy. Jones - Fumbling, bad decisions Garlett - Cheap goals, [censored]-weak Frost - Dominant bar one Petty - Showed real promise Baker - Some impressive glimpses. 7 Quote
nichoneitz 14 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Jones - Leadership skills gone Viney - Wastes the ball Gawn - Best on Ground Oliver - Needs to kick Harmes - Good early on Hunt - Only good forward Garlett - Soft and Wasteful Petracca - Its getting worse Salem - Was well held Stretch - Not AFL standard Brayshaw - Loss his ability T.McDonald - Didn't reward himself Frost - Good until late Hore - Another good game O.McDonald -Wasn't our worse Wagner - Not AFL standard Smith - was well beaten Lockhart - Was rarely sighted Neal-Bullen - battles until concussed Petty - showed some promise Fritsch - Lost all confidence Baker - Had his chances Quote
rjay 25,424 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Margetts - FMD Seriously, tonight was a good argument for not allowing umpires from home states to umpire when the opposition are from outside that state. Like in test cricket the umpires must be neutral. Yes we cost ourselves with poor kicking but that Smith decision was a disgrace and probably cost us the game. Forget Rampe climbing up a post that had absolutely no effect on the result and his remark to the umpire had even less. A 12 point turnaround and a player incapacitated. The WC player will be sighted on the tackle & probably get a week but the umpires dept and Shocking will still try to tell us the umpire got it right... 7 1 Quote
goodwindees 2,586 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Pruess - should have played Smith - should not have Jones - slow to react Fritsch - coughs it up Stretch - makes poor decisions Hore - very good game Frost - positives outweigh negative Gawn - brilliant & brave Viney - use ball better Oliver - use ball better 1 Quote
TGR 1,367 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Jones - Was good tonight Melb - Had a crack Gawn - Wiped Vardy’s Rsss Lockhart - Something special emerging Frost - Petruccelle met kryptonite Harmes - Great 1st half Tim Smith - Luck over due Stretch - never ever finishes Hore - Great 1st half Trac - Good and bad Garlett - Good and bad TMac - Great and OK 2 Quote
Straight Sets Simon 23,113 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Team as a whole - Season’s best performance 7 1 Quote
Tarax Club 4,189 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 (edited) Joeboy - closer to mark MFC - brave but flawed Jones - slowing but effective Viney - in and under Gawn - an outstanding game Oliver - exciting centre chain Harmes - great first half Hunt - some impressive cameos Garlett - goals improved performance Petracca - get kicking coach Salem - less influence tonight Stretch - tries very hard Brayshaw - lost in space T.McDonald - getting better ? Frost - confident but costly Hore - endeavour and composure O.McDonald - a serviceable game Wagner - jittery with ball Smith - dangerous tackle surely? Lockhart - some classy touches Neal-Bullen - average before injury Petty - was not disgraced Fritsch - yin and yang Baker - overawed but promising Umpires - some ordinary decisions Postgame - group think gripe Edited May 17, 2019 by Tarax Club revisionism 2 Quote
Elegt 872 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Stretch - please get out Petracca- do you train? Brayshaw- stop slipping over Oscar- surprisingly good tonight Viney- stop taking on Mcdonald- so damn slow Wagner- learn to kick Petty- get in gym Goodwin- please play preuss Garlett- go for marks Umpires- you are [censored] Oliver- please stop handballing 1 1 Quote
Micksdemons 131 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Smith - better than most ! Umpires - favour West Coast Team - Lack Composure totally Luck - We had none Season - Gone and worsening ! Quote
Adzman 2,154 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Frost - becoming more valuable Hore - bye bye Lewis We are missing Lever, May, Lewis, Hibbo and Jets from the back half, I have to give credit to Hore and Frost who have been really solid the past few weeks. If our full backline was available I'm wondering if Hore has gone past others for a spot in the best 22. He is getting better by the week. 6 Quote
Farmer 903 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 41 minutes ago, goodwindees said: Pruess - should have played Smith - should not have Jones - slow to react Fritsch - coughs it up Stretch - makes poor decisions Hore - very good game Frost - positives outweigh negative Gawn - brilliant & brave Viney - use ball better Oliver - use ball better Thought Smith was ok in a tough position until he was killed in the last quarter 3 Quote
At the break of Gawn 4,515 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 I’ve given up on Stretch. Really hoped he could make it, but sadly it’s not going to happen for him. Kolodjashnij has his spot if he can ever get on the park. I felt Oliver tapered off a little when he had a bit of a head clash (not sure if it was second or third qtr) but he was electric before that. Quote
picket fence 18,188 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 1 hour ago, Damo said: Petracca - put him in cotton wool and ask for a round 1 pick. Stretch - twitchy yet slowthinking Agree with both, Petracca I'm calling it.. Time to Trade. Momentum killer of the highest order. Billy Stretch , Similar to Cale the Whale! Prefer others when fit! Quote
binman 44,837 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 1 hour ago, Elegt said: Stretch - please get out Petracca- do you train? Brayshaw- stop slipping over Oscar- surprisingly good tonight Viney- stop taking on Mcdonald- so damn slow Wagner- learn to kick Petty- get in gym Goodwin- please play preuss Garlett- go for marks Umpires- you are [censored] Oliver- please stop handballing Elegt- please stop posting 4 Quote
leucopogon 1,519 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 MFC - please stand up Lost count of the number of times our players slipped over tonight, embarrassing, same thing happened in last year's two games at Optus. And I notice it happening every week, particularly Viney, slips over nearly every time he goes near the ball. 1 1 Quote
YesitwasaWin4theAges 6,830 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 (edited) T. Smith- Not AFL standard. B.Pruess- Where was he? Set shots- Killed us Again. Petracca- So [censored] frustrating. Gawn- One man band. Long kicks to Mcgovern and co- just so predictable. Skill level- Not AFL standard. Football IQ- just doesnt exist. Football boots- screw-ins not required Hore- Stroke of Genius. Hunt- Has reinvented himself. Goodwin- Good for 3qtrs Rest of Season- Couldn't give two... Edited May 17, 2019 by Win4theAges Quote
Billy 2,576 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 7 hours ago, Elegt said: Stretch - please get out Petracca- do you train? Brayshaw- stop slipping over Oscar- surprisingly good tonight Viney- stop taking on Mcdonald- so damn slow Wagner- learn to kick Petty- get in gym Goodwin- please play preuss Garlett- go for marks Umpires- you are [censored] Oliver- please stop handballing Elegt harsh & unfair 1 Quote
Forest Demon 4,681 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 Petracca should be waking up to a 4 or 5 goal performance in a huge interstate win, but not to be, again. I actually think he is having an ok year, but he is so close to having a very good year. 6 Quote
spirit of norm smith 16,679 Posted May 17, 2019 Posted May 17, 2019 9 hours ago, nichoneitz said: Jones - Leadership skills gone Viney - Wastes the ball Gawn - Best on Ground Oliver - Needs to kick Harmes - Good early on Hunt - Only good forward Garlett - Soft and Wasteful Petracca - Its getting worse Salem - Was well held Stretch - Not AFL standard Brayshaw - Loss his ability T.McDonald - Didn't reward himself Frost - Good until late Hore - Another good game O.McDonald -Wasn't our worse Wagner - Not AFL standard Smith - was well beaten Lockhart - Was rarely sighted Neal-Bullen - battles until concussed Petty - showed some promise Fritsch - Lost all confidence Baker - Had his chances Agreed. Harsh on Jonesy who showed he still gets into the close midfield contests. He also kicks the footy. His opening goal was very good. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.