Changes: Rd 05 v St. Kilda

[leave it to deever 17,541]

4 hours ago, picket fence said:

If he kicks 3 or more goals HE WILL PLAY!

Billy Stretch again underwhelming!

When he fires he is awesome. 

I wonder if he has lost pace. He certainly has shown how its done in the past and is an alternative to a couple of others.  If he doesnt     fire than it may be end days. I would  take a punt at a large ground like the Mcg.

[bing181 9,333]

Stretch wasn't that bad, I'd give him at least another match or two to find his feet (again?) at this level. It's a big step up from VFL.

Re other changes, two factors that will probably come into play are:

- we have a very short turnaround (as noted)

- Casey have a bye next week

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

1 hour ago, Graeme Yeats' Mullet said:

No way can Spargo cover Stretch (or ANB), his "engine" is 2-stroke wippa-snippa stuff

Share's the role with Chunk on the wing.... might make a 4 stroke!

[Superunknown 4,225]

3 hours ago, Graeme Yeats' Mullet said:

No way can Spargo cover Stretch (or ANB), his "engine" is 2-stroke wippa-snippa stuff

What, go all day without missing a beat in sweet fa fuel?

[WERRIDEE 5,536]

IN: GARLETT, LEWIS, JETTA

OUT: SPARGO, STRETCH, J.WAGNER

The outs very unlucky J.Wagner to come in if Jetta isn't fit.

[rjay 25,197]

Garlett for Spargo...

Spargo had some nice little cameos but can't lay a solid tackle and opposition players know & expose him....

If he can't tackle then he needs to get a lot more possession & hit the scoreboard regularly, neither of which he does.

Oscar probably rested with concussion.

[WERRIDEE 5,536]

1 minute ago, rjay said:

Garlett for Spargo...

Spargo had some nice little cameos but can't lay a solid tackle and opposition players know & expose him....

If he can't tackle then he needs to get a lot more possession & hit the scoreboard regularly, neither of which he does.

Oscar probably rested with concussion.

Petty in if Oscar out? 9 days is enough to recover

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

7 hours ago, Deemania since 56 said:

Nah, ANB already kicks better than Greg Parke, just nowhere near as good at marking.

Pretty sure you wouldn't be able to Vape on the G just before the first bounce either 56.  Stamping them out would become an expensive habit also eh.

[What 18,810]

10 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

IN: GARLETT, LEWIS, JETTA

OUT: SPARGO, STRETCH, J.WAGNER

 

Those changes look beautiful on paper.

I wouldn't play Lewis with the 4 day break into the Tigers game,  hes no spring chicken anymore and coming off a hammy..

[FlashInThePan 1,893]

I think Spargo may eventually be a bit Caleb Daniels like,  he is generally a good user of the ball, but 7 possessions and 1 tackle really doesn't cut it.

Garlett to get one more chance based on his BOG performance at Casey. Any other changes  will depend on injury and fitness. Stretch needs to do better though of he wants to keep his spot .

[dl4e 5,851]

Out: Oscar and spargo

In:   Anyone ( lewis? ) and garlett. 

Hibberd on membrey and Frost on Bruce.

[Nasher 33,617]

I’d hold fire on Garlett. It’s great that he had a big game for Casey. Spargo is already likely to make way for Lewis or Jetta; I’m happy enough with how the other players went not to feel the need to change it. If he keeps playing like that in the VFL his time will come, it’s just not yet.

[chook fowler 19,650]

I thought J Wagner was pretty good - playedhis role and disposed the ballwell. Would be surprised if he was dropped. Jetta must still be in doubt.

[DeeSpencer 26,091]

I think we should roll the dice of 1 tall defender against the Saints forward line. I'm a big Petty fan but last year against the Saints he was exploited for a lack of suitable match up and poor team defence and that has to be the focus again.

Lewis and Jetta in to the backline means 2 defenders have to make way or be reassigned. I think it might be time to try Salem up the ground, can always swap him with Fritsch or Lewis if it isn't working. 

T. Smith for Preuss if we want to maintain a bigger forward line, or we could go small. Unsure who gets the last couple of forward spots. I like Spargo because despite the slipped tackles and limited ball winning you can see he's a smart footballer who gets to the right spots, which then makes it easier for everyone else.

FB: Jetta  Hibberd  Hore
HB: Lewis  Frost   Fritsch
C: Salem   Oliver  Stretch
HF: Melksham T Mc  Petracca
FF: Hunt  Weid   T. Smith/small
Foll: Gawn  Harmes Brayshaw
Int: Viney, Jones, J. Wagner, C. Wagner/Spargo/Garlett/Lockhart

[picket fence 17,716]

15 minutes ago, Nasher said:

I’d hold fire on Garlett. It’s great that he had a big game for Casey. Spargo is already likely to make way for Lewis or Jetta; I’m happy enough with how the other players went not to feel the need to change it. If he keeps playing like that in the VFL his time will come, it’s just not yet.

Nasher, I reckon when Jeffy plays a game like yesterday , his confidence soars! I wouldn't risk an extended break given Casey has a Bye next week. I think we pull the trigger and give him a chance, sooner rather than later. Next week ideal and if it works I reckon we go a long way towards a win. In a team lacking seriously good finishers with goal sense and pace, against the AINTS he must play! How many games has Stretch, Spargo, et al taken and become match winners. ZERO. Jeffy can and has done this for us and so he plays.

[picket fence 17,716]

19 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Nasher, I reckon when Jeffy plays a game like yesterday , his confidence soars! I wouldn't risk an extended break given Casey has a Bye next week. I think we pull the trigger and give him a chance, sooner rather than later. Next week ideal and if it works I reckon we go a long way towards a win. In a team lacking seriously good finishers with goal sense and pace, against the AINTS he must play! How many games has Stretch, Spargo, et al taken on and become match winners. ZERO. Jeffy can and has done this for us and so he plays.

As Norm Smith once said “Never Flirt with Form”

[Dee Zephyr 19,269]

In: Garlett 

Out: Spargo/C Wagner 

I think it’s Jeffy time. In the JLT and the scratch match against Pies he looked more likely than Spargo to be playing Round 1 until his injury. He was on a club-mandated restriction on his game time in VFL 1 but did show a bit of class when he touched the ball. By all reports he was great yesterday. Look at the way Richmond won yesterday, their small lightning forwards destroyed Port on the rebound and with their forward pressure. If Jeffy can reproduce his defensive efforts that had him the number one pressure forward in 17 or early 18 it could help us get on a roll. He can make something happen from nothing too. 

Spargo did set up a couple of goals with his low disposal count and isn’t too bad in traffic with his little sidesteps, maybe that will save him ahead of C Wagner although his lack of tackling is a concern. 

Not sure about the readiness of Jetta and Lewis. Might be best to save them for Richmond. 

Petty in for OMac if still concussed.

[58er 6,655]

36 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

I thought J Wagner was pretty good - playedhis role and disposed the ballwell. Would be surprised if he was dropped. Jetta must still be in doubt.

Good point CF

i thought it was the most rounded and composed game from Josh W. ( must admit I am not one of his fans)  but he hardly made an error and his ball handling  on a dewy night was very good. Not to drop for Saints at least.

Tigers will need defence of speed speed and more speed! Though.

[What 18,810]

In -      Garlett,  Petty

Out -   Spargo, O Mac

[chook fowler 19,650]

4 minutes ago, 58er said:

Good point CF

i thought it was the most rounded and composed game from Josh W. ( must admit I am not one of his fans)  but he hardly made an error and his ball handling  on a dewy night was very good. Not to drop for Saints at least.

Tigers will need defence of speed speed and more speed! Though.

I think he will always be a backup option but if he plays like that he’ll get opportunities.

[Mr Steve 3,820]

Good to see Garlett play well yesterday but don't put him it yet. 

[58er 6,655]

6 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

I think he will always be a backup option but if he plays like that he’ll get opportunities.

Agree CF but nice to get better quality depth!

[Willmoy1947 4,164]

Breakout game for a now confident  Hore against Sydney, Oscar to go, May to come in, move around, and get his act together. Forward line is now open and functioning.

[Redleg 41,705]

Saints have pace and Billy needs to stay in. No good dropping him after one game every time, it is destroying any confidence he needs. I would give him 2-3 games at least and give him the opportunity.

Edited April 14, 2019 by Redleg

[Sydee 4,544]

7 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Saints have pace and Billy needs to stay in. No good dropping him after one game every time, it is destroying any confidence he needs. I would give him 2-3 games at least and give him the opportunity.

I agree they made us look hopelessly slow last year we must go with our fastest possible team and play full four quarters to win 

Sydney are not really traveling well at all so we can’t get too carried away with that win albeit a positive step

I like Petty for OMac but still have nightmares about his debut game last year where he really was found wanting big time largely due to zero pressure up the ground