Just think its worth an enquiry to Dylan's manager. 

He is contracted til end of 2019, but that Giant Beanstalk seems to be withering.

Will he wither on the Vine?

Also Lachie Whitfield, but he is contracted til end of 2020.  But this could be better for us re available trades for use ?

nahhh.. too much of a front-runner for me ?

we don't have the assets to trade for him

free agency all the way - gaff, dahlhaus this year; shiel, coniglio next year

I feel like this questioned gets asked every year.

I don't think we'll be in the market for him, especially while under contract.

  On 19/05/2018 at 10:52, whatwhatsaywhat said:

we don't have the assets to trade for him

free agency all the way - gaff, dahlhaus this year; shiel, coniglio next year

 

  On 19/05/2018 at 11:05, Wiseblood said:

I feel like this questioned gets asked every year.

I don't think we'll be in the market for him, especially while under contract.

Shiel would be the perfect understudy to Jones, who has maybe a couple more in him?

With all the talk of Gaff etc, I just wonder if anyone has made any contact to suss his position, Prior to us going spending this year.

 

We have to continue to AIM High... not settle for just deserts.

Edited May 19, 20186 yr by DV8

As always, depends on cost.

Not sure we'd want to pay that much or even if he's worth it.

Shiel is a star. I’d offer a 6-year contract worth $800,000 per year.  

But we would be unlikely to have such room under the salary cap plus we have NOTHING to trade. 

 

Shiel is one of my favourite players but it would cost 2 first round picks.

We dont have the currency, hence the club will be going all guns blazing to bring in a free agent this year.

He is a gun. Wins his own ball on the inside,  has great acceleration from stoppages.  Often does the give & get, gains plenty of metres and good kick.  Doubt we have the draft fire power to get this done. 

Seems to have solved his shoulders popping out a lot. Must be better tape.

I reckon Josh Kelly only re-signed so he could chase the on field success everyone thought was coming. Quick two year contract taking him through to the end of ‘19 and then back home. 

Success or not i think you’ll see a number of GWS players heading home before their best playing days are over. Hopefully we will be able to benefit from this.

I'd take him in a shot. Fills a lot of needs for us. I was banking on us getting Prestia who was the same, and apparently we very nearly did. Gaff probably the priority, but failing that, I'd take Dylan. Not that we have much to trade.

I would say we need to look after a few people currently at MFC and aim on keeping them considering the development work that has gone into them .( i.e. T@OMac, Hoges etc who are key players. From all accounts we have sold the Southern Stand for one of our "newies"

Is Gaff better than Oliver, Viney, Brayshaw, Petracca ?  Plays a different role than Jones . ANB , Hannan could develop into a 2020's Jones.( Remember that Harmes is probably just as good a player as Jonesy back at the same age.

Our immediate problem is replacing Vince & Lewis in a  couple of years.

You don't turn down good players but wing/half back class and a gun small forward are probably still the priorities I'd think. 

Expect Carlton to put their first round pick on the table for Shiel or Kelly (or both), they are Sos' favourite players and they need to land a mature mid to kick start their rebuild before it massively flops. North will try the same as well.

Anyway, unless ware linked to a player we don't need to be bringing up names. We have a team with a few weaknesses but also a few strengths as is right now.

Gun player and you'd certainly make room for him the side, but hard to see how we'd fit him into the cap? Need to keep enough room for Brayshaw, O and Tmac and Hoges of course...

  On 20/05/2018 at 01:43, spirit of norm smith said:

Shiel is a star. I’d offer a 6-year contract worth $800,000 per year.  

But we would be unlikely to have such room under the salary cap plus we have NOTHING to trade. 

 

We'll be paying very close to this for Gaff, if he comes our way.

 

  On 20/05/2018 at 01:52, BAMF said:

Shiel is one of my favourite players but it would cost 2 first round picks.

We dont have the currency, hence the club will be going all guns blazing to bring in a free agent this year.

Maybe we would be better going after RSloane this year;  and aiming at DShiel in the 2019 free agency?

Too good a player to ignore if available unless his price tag is ridiculous.

Certainly would offer us something that we don't have a great deal of - breakaway speed from the stoppages. Would love playing under Max, that's for sure.

Tyson is a better disposer of the ball by foot than Shiel is. Wouldn't break the bank for him.

What we need in the short term is a speedy midfielder which shiel is. He would cap off our midfield nicely.

  On 20/09/2018 at 11:06, Whispering_Jack said:

Too good a player to ignore if available unless his price tag is ridiculous.

I actually think he has slipped a bit and is not as good as he was.

  On 21/09/2018 at 05:07, Redleg said:

I actually think he has slipped a bit and is not as good as he was.

Kicking is terrible and a turnover merchant when the going gets tough 

certainly better than gaff would be for us. Because Shiel has speed. 

  On 21/09/2018 at 05:16, ucanchoose said:

Kicking is terrible and a turnover merchant when the going gets tough 

This. Wouldn’t touch him as he can’t kick.