Why Bernie, why?

[dee-tox 4,835]

Do you give away the most ridiculous of free kicks. Why as the most experienced player in the team are you the most undisciplined? Why do you confound us with your stupidity?

[Biffen 12,834]

Because he is having a go mate.

He slipped over. So what.

[dee-tox 4,835]

No Biff. Don't care about the slipping over. I care about the five stupid free kicks, the seven clangers, the bad options, the faux tough guy act, etc

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

He did make a couple bad errors today. But some were as Biff said because he was trying to make things happen. 

The eagles flood smothered our scoring options.

But dont worry it was the McDonald brothers fault we lost... not Berniea or anyone else 

[qwerty7 322]

Just frustrated probably. When you feel a game - that you should rightfully win - slipping through your hands, it gets pretty [censored] frustrating. 

[John Demonic 5,515]

5 minutes ago, dee-tox said:

No Biff. Don't care about the slipping over. I care about the five stupid free kicks, the seven clangers, the bad options, the faux tough guy act, etc

As much as I love the way he plays when he's having a good hard crack, i can acknowledge he's a bit of an arrogant tosspot, comes with the Footy show regular territory. Every team has one though I suppose.

Edited July 23, 2016 by johndemons

[Adam The God 29,381]

Had a pretty ordinary year for a leader IMO. We need him to be a leader and he simply isn't.

[spirit of norm smith 15,229]

Poor leadership and discipline today from Bernie.

[The heart beats true 17,808]

If we had 20 blokes that get as much out of themselves as Bernie does we'd win the flag. He makes mistakes but he has a crack. He's playing a vital role for us until the next generation evolve. 

[Ricky P 757]

Festering turd of a thread. The bloke's been terrific for the club - doesn't need his own thread because he made a couple of blues today.

[dee-tox 4,835]

10 minutes ago, Ricky P said:

Festering turd of a thread. The bloke's been terrific for the club - doesn't need his own thread because he made a couple of blues today.

Comprehension is obviously not a strong point of yours Ricky P. Vince's discipline has been horrendous all year. The reports, the stupid free kicks, the lack of leadership etc. No-one is saying he has been bad for the club. But as one the most experienced players he has to lead the way.

[Ricky P 757]

1 minute ago, dee-tox said:

Comprehension is obviously not a strong point of yours Ricky P. Vince's discipline has been horrendous all year. The reports, the stupid free kicks, the lack of leadership etc. No-one is saying he has been bad for the club. But as one the most experienced players he has to lead the way.

Comprehension is top notch mate. I fully understand what you're saying. You're just wrong and this thread is a disgrace.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Thought he had much more hunger than last week. Did give away 5 frees, but 3 of them were nonsense

[DeeSpencer 24,762]

Could pull his head in just a little Bern. We need in your face aggressive play but not silly frees and reports.

I'm willing to forgive him for the slip. Just pumping it in wasn't working, we needed to do something different to score.

[Adzman 2,153]

Bern = gun

 

 

 

[Deemented Are Go! 3,676]

[censored] thread. 

[Moonshadow 17,551]

3 hours ago, dee-tox said:

Do you give away the most ridiculous of free kicks. Why as the most experienced player in the team are you the most undisciplined? Why do you confound us with your stupidity?

Yeah, he's been terrible for our club. Let's delist him in October. Bern him.

[dave 183]

3 hours ago, AdamFphlebeb said:

Had a pretty ordinary year for a leader IMO. We need him to be a leader and he simply isn't.

Absolute bollocks

[Je Roos Salem 661]

3 hours ago, AdamFphlebeb said:

Had a pretty ordinary year for a leader IMO. We need him to be a leader and he simply isn't.

I think it's hard for any player to come to a club so deep into their career and expect to be a leader. Like Goddard at Essendon. We've tried basing our leadership group around new guys and it's never worked. I think his year's been good enough, but I think he's much more important for the team playing on the ball and being physical, like today or that role he did on Dangerfield, even if he gives away a few silly frees, rather than picking up cheap stats in defence (like last week and a fair bit of the year). 

Edited July 23, 2016 by Je Roos Salem

[Adam The God 29,381]

20 minutes ago, Je Roos Salem said:

I think it's hard for any player to come to a club so deep into their career and expect to be a leader. Like Goddard at Essendon. We've tried basing our leadership group around new guys and it's never worked. I think his year's been good enough, but I think he's much more important for the team playing on the ball and being physical, like today or that role he did on Dangerfield, even if he gives away a few silly frees, rather than picking up cheap stats in defence (like last week and a fair bit of the year). 

If he was playing the same role as he did on Dangerfield last year I wouldn't have a problem with it, but he's playing off half back and playing this faux tough guy rubbish and it kills the team.

[Adam The God 29,381]

20 minutes ago, Je Roos Salem said:

I think it's hard for any player to come to a club so deep into their career and expect to be a leader. Like Goddard at Essendon. We've tried basing our leadership group around new guys and it's never worked. I think his year's been good enough, but I think he's much more important for the team playing on the ball and being physical, like today or that role he did on Dangerfield, even if he gives away a few silly frees, rather than picking up cheap stats in defence (like last week and a fair bit of the year). 

If he was playing the same role as he did on Dangerfield last year I wouldn't have a problem with it, but he's playing off half back and playing this faux tough guy rubbish and it kills the team.

[Wrecker45 3,378]

6 hours ago, dee-tox said:

Comprehension is obviously not a strong point of yours Ricky P. Vince's discipline has been horrendous all year. The reports, the stupid free kicks, the lack of leadership etc. No-one is saying he has been bad for the club. But as one the most experienced players he has to lead the way.

The most successful team of the era and possibly ever specialise in "unsociable football". Before that Brisbane were perhaps the greatest team ever and guess what they played unsociable football but just didn't call it that.

Bernie Vince is leading the way. Before he came to the club we could barely win a game and it was hard to even watch a game. Only a Melbourne supporter could be happy with losses but the Adelaide and West Coast games show we are in it to win it.

Thank you Bernie Vince for playing a leading role in resurrecting a sinking ship.

 

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I haven't seen all the game but from what I did see he made two stupid decisions after taking a mark. The first was he chose to kick in his left foot when there was no need at all and the ball was turned over, the other was playing on when he slipped over. He can't help the slipping but there was no need to play on, a kick over the mark was all we needed.

The way we can turn a "free kick" into a kick under pressure is mind boggling.

[Redleg 40,207]

A more balanced post might be:

Is Bernie one of our best players?  Yes.

Does he give his all?  Yes.

Was yesterday one of his best games for us?  No.

Did he make quite a few mistakes?  Yes. 

[Gator 17,260]

I like Bernie, but I've rarely seen an experienced senior player make the mistakes he does.  And he does it every single week.