Do we honestly care as much as we used to? From tribunal inconsistency to umpire favouritism I think the medal is viewed differently of late. 

The significance of the Brownlow medal has substantially diminished during the 21st Century.

If Diacos is to win it, please at least let it be a tie with someone else. Wouldn't even begrudge Cripps tying for him to win a legitimate one!

Edited September 22, 20241 yr by Left Foot Snap

As long as everyone has a good time.

12 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Do we honestly care as much as we used to? From tribunal inconsistency to umpire favouritism I think the medal is viewed differently of late. 

Too many rubbish winners, Neale a two-time winner while Bont hasn’t got one? Give me a spell. 

Yuck

Plenty of great players have won it, and even more great players haven't won it. At least last century if you played in the ruck, or key position you had a chance of winning it.  That's all gone now. 

Bontempelli is 10x the player Daicos is. No doubt Daicos is a talent, but so many of his stats come after a teammate takes a mark, before he then sprints into space and receives an easy mark from that teammate’s short to medium pass. 

Like almost everyone else I'd love to see Bontempelli win it but it seems the winner will come from Daicos, Cripps or Neale.

If that's the case (and I realise I'm inviting a lengthy suspension from Demonland for saying this) I hope Daicos wins it outright. Say what you like about him being an outside player, his ball use is off the charts.

Cripps already has one that he shouldn't. Winning in 2022 was a victory for the Carlton lawyers.

Neale is a very, very good footballer but triple Brownlow Medallist? No thanks.

11 hours ago, Swooper1987 said:

Plenty of great players have won it, and even more great players haven't won it.

Without even thinking and naming some of the greatest like:

Matthews. Carey. Ablett Senior. Barassi. Whitten. Flower. Bartlett. Tuck. Francis Bourke. Selwood.  Dunstall. Bont so far. etc

My next door neighbour gave me $150 to put on Cripps for her, so if Cripps wins I will be able to do a runner.

11 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Bontempelli is 10x the player Daicos is. No doubt Daicos is a talent, but so many of his stats come after a teammate takes a mark, before he then sprints into space and receives an easy mark from that teammate’s short to medium pass. 

Has never taken a contested mark IN HIS CAREER....Says a hell of a lot!

I would love to see Bont take it out. He's everything the medalist should be.

As usual I will not watch it but will possibly tune in right near the end to see the result after all the filibuster material. 

Hope Bont wins it, definitely deserves it!

Again not that interesting if no Dees likely.  No Clarry. No Trac.  Gawn to poll about 16 votes by my calculations.  Agree that it’s going to take about 30 or more to win it.  Neale.  Bont.  Daicos.  Cripps. Any of those four are most likely.  

I really hope the bont can somehow win it.

Nothing would make me laugh more if cripps pipped daicos  by a vote. The pies fans would riot. As would the blues fans if it was the other way around 

Anyway it will come down to the final round I reckon. Daicos will definitely get the 3 against us

Honestly I lost interest in the brownlow a while ago. It very rarely gives an accurate representation of who the best player was in a given season.

I doubt that anyone thought that Neale was the best player last year. Same goes for Wines in 2021.

Before the last game I said on this site that Goodwin needed to place a HARD tag on Daicos if we were to have any chance of winning.. so mastercoach didn't and the rest is history. IF he wins he should buy Goody a tattslotto ticket for gifting him 3 votes.

Should just change it to the midfielders medal

Just a note to the players & coaches, don't have any conversations you don't want repeated. Tom morris is in attendance & will be lurking.

Watching or even listening to the count is mind numbingly awful and I gave up bothering as soon as it became a tv event. Watching players get drunk is boring and the only upside is goggling at the wags. Too much inane commentary and pretend analysis. Nobody has a clue.

I am old enough to remember Bob Skilton and Ian Stewart win three brownlows each. Skilton won his playing in a poorly performing side where he was a standout for his skill, courage and determination. Stewart was silky smooth in teams that were at their respective peaks so he outdid some top competition. He won his second medal playing just 12 games out of 18. That's class.

Sadly modern football does not allow for such players to excel. It's all about numbers of possessions but not about the qualities of Skilton and Stewart. The player most like them is Neale who wins his own ball and disposes with skill and flair. The other favoured players do not.

Should he win, will he be considered the equivalent of Skilton and Stewart? Not quite but still deserving.

For those who have an interest in the Brownlow, you can track my predictions live during the count this year.

https://www.wheeloratings.com/afl_brownlow_live.html