Who would be currently leading the B&F

[Pates 9,660]

So I was thinking the other day who would be in our top 5 at the moment for the Best & Fairest. We've had quite a few even performances but I would say that Viney would have to be a lock at the top currently. His form has been outstanding and I believe he's had two perfect scores in the coaches award. That certainly would indicate he'd be leading as that award is judged by those who see more than just disposal stats but genuine influence. 

Beyond that though I would struggle to work it. 

Max Gawn, Jack Watts, Nate Jones, Bernie Vince, and Ben Ken would probably be my first names that would come to mind as top 5 contenders.

[Jaded No More 68,965]

Viney from Gawn 

My top 5 prediction at years end:

1- Viney 

2- Gawn

3- Hogan 

4- Jetta

5- Jones 

[Nasher 33,616]

Viney.

Gawn, Vince, Jones, Watts up there.

I like Kennedy, but he doesn't belong in the same group as the others you mentioned. 

[Ethan Tremblay 30,872]

Viney. FWIW he's also top four on Fox Footy's player of the year ladder.

[What 18,810]

Current top 5

First - Viney

Second - Gawn

Third -  Jetta

Fourth - Watts

Fifth -  Bugg

 

Prediction end of season

First -   Viney

Second - Hogan

Third -   Gawn

Fourth -  Jetta

Fifth -    Vince

Edited May 22, 2016 by Petraccattack

[Pates 9,660]

16 minutes ago, Nasher said:

Viney.

Gawn, Vince, Jones, Watts up there.

I like Kennedy, but he doesn't belong in the same group as the others you mentioned. 

I feel that Kennedy could be the "what the hell" top 5 placer. He probably won't have the stamina to maintain it for the entire year but I think he's one that does stuff that coaches love. 

I'm surprised many are placing Hogan in the top 5 at this stage, he may well get there by the end of the year but I think he's had a couple of outstanding games pocketed with solid-good games and a couple of mules. Really took until round 3 before we started seeing the real Jesse.

[Edit] Just realised the top 5s that included Hogan for years end.

Edited May 22, 2016 by Pates

[Deestroy All 14,266]

Give it to Viney now so he can enjoy it for longer. Oliver will win the next 10. 

[KingDingAling 3,758]

1 minute ago, Deestroy All said:

Give it to Viney now so he can enjoy it for longer. Oliver will win the next 10. 

Why stop at 10?

[Deestroy All 14,266]

5 minutes ago, KingDingAling said:

Why stop at 10?

Just a nice round number and he doesn't strike me as selfish. 

[Demon Jack 6,918]

Unsurprisingly I think Viney would be leading pretty comfortably at the moment. Gawn would probably be runner up at this stage.

There's a large group of players who are in contention for the remainder of the top five. I'm backing Jetta as a smokey for a top five finish this year.

[Wrecker45 3,378]

1 - viney (clear leader)

2 - max gawn (nèeds support to stay up)

3  - Jetta (best small backman in the game)

4 - Jack Watts

5 - garlett

[jumbo returns 6,741]

The skipper's up there....again.

Has been really flying the flag this year - Doggies sucked him in, though.....

[DeeSpencer 25,718]

I know the Melbourne B+F voting system rewards elite games as much as anything - so Viney and Gawn would be top 2. Hogan would be up there as well.

But it's also a reward for consistency of playing your role. So Bugg would be right up there. His work rate and defensive efforts from a wing would have him well placed.

Harmes would be another getting a fair bit of love for his good games as well as Kennedy. 

[DubDee 25,901]

Viney by a street

[Skuit 10,031]

26 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

I know the Melbourne B+F voting system rewards elite games as much as anything - so Viney and Gawn would be top 2. Hogan would be up there as well.

But it's also a reward for consistency of playing your role. So Bugg would be right up there. His work rate and defensive efforts from a wing would have him well placed.

Harmes would be another getting a fair bit of love for his good games as well as Kennedy. 

Can you explain this system again DeeSpencer? Everyone gets votes out of ten for each game or some such?

[DeeSpencer 25,718]

Just now, Skuit said:

Can you explain this system again DeeSpencer? Everyone gets votes out of ten for each game or some such?

I can't remember exactly but I thought it was each player gets a score out of 10 from 4 coaches, doing your role might only get 2 or 3, with a good game getting a pretty low score ie. 4 or 5 and a special game getting a 7,8 or 9. So a really excellent game can score 30+ (or 40) points, where just a standard good game might only get 15 or so. Clearly it's important to put together consistent games scoring 10-15 votes but a few big games can out weigh that.