Patrick McCartin

[Whispering_Jack 30,130]

This bloke might be of interest to some even if he's not a midfielder ~ Top draft hopeful Patrick McCartin finds the right balance.

[Guest]

We should be drafting on ability, not needs. If he is, indeed, the second best player in the pool (as many seem to rate him), draft him and Brayshaw at 2 & 3.

[Matt Demon 1,430]

For some reason nothing about him appeals to me, seems one dimensional & under sized to be classed as a power forward.

[What 18,810]

For some reason nothing about him appeals to me, seems one dimensional & under sized to be classed as a power forward.

same

he seems very underwhelming

[daisycutter 29,616]

For some reason nothing about him appeals to me, seems one dimensional & under sized to be classed as a power forward.

why do you say undersized at 194cm and 95kg?

[DistrACTION Jackson 8,734]

People saying he's undersized is ridiculous. He is bigger than Jack Darling and he goes alright...

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

May as well post this for a third time, but in the proper thread now. Take it as you will:

MY MAIL:

Just spoke to my connection down at the Falcons. He said that if Petracca goes pick 1, we must take McCartin. Said the kid is an absolute brute, who plays aggressively and can mark, kick, tackle, out body and the rest.

Makes me think of what could be with a combination of Hogan and McCartin down there for the next 10 years. Also said he is a monster that would be ready to go round 1.

Said he played bottom age last year, and made the All-Australian side, and also actually broke Dom Sheeds collar bone in one of the matches.

Downside is that he has diabetes, and has sometimes had to run off the field to check his levels but is making good progress in learning how to manage this.

Anyways just what I got told. For me, if Petracca goes #1 like he is expected to, McCartin and Brayshaw would be my wishes.

[whatwhat say what 22,756]

He has been talked about as a top 3 pick along with Wright and Petracca for about 12 months.

Brayshaw has only come up into that upper bracket in the last 6 or so months, while the likes of Durdin and Goddard have slid big time.

If it's not Petracca and Brayshaw, it would make the most sense - in terms of where players are rated over a long period of time - for it to be one of Wright or McCartin.

Wright is my personal preference, but either way we should be getting a very highly rated big man.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,828]

I haven't seen one second of highlights, nor have not done an ounce of research but in my expert opinion we must take him at 3.

Lever seems more of a punt to me and we can't afford to be taking punts at this draft.

[MikeAlphaTango 150]

People saying he's undersized is ridiculous. He is bigger than Jack Darling and he goes alright...

Completely agree, Jesse Hogan was listed at 193 and 91kgs (now 195cm and 95kg as per MFC site) in his draft year.

2. Melbourne - Jesse Hogan (WA – KPF)

Height: 193cm, Weight: 91kg, DOB: 12/02/1995

Recruited from: Claremont

Style: Jonathan Brown

Player comparison:

Range: 1-5

Profile: Strong contested marking forward and is a real presence and target you can kick to. Also has excellent ability to take a 1v1 mark and this seems a real feature of his game. Reads it well in the air and off the players boot. Has the ability to crash packs and bring it to ground and seems to enjoy the physical side of the game. Physically developed for his age and already a very high level key forward. By foot is a good field kick and can find a leading target. Will need to work on set shot goal kicking routine – just doesn’t look as fluid as you’d ideally like to see and as a result his set shot goal kicking seems to suffer.

Why:

[rjay 24,928]

For some reason nothing about him appeals to me, seems one dimensional & under sized to be classed as a power forward.

same

he seems very underwhelming

You really needed to see him last year to get an idea of how good he could be. This year he struggled with injury all the way through.

His game against SA u18's was a beauty, looked like a young Plugger and I don't care about the game has changed etc Plugger would be a great player now.

Would be happy if our guys thought he was worth picking.

[ignition. 1,466]

Tony Lockett at 191 cm would have been considered undersized by your standards.

Secondly, I certainly don't find him underwhelming.

For me as I've stated before the club should be drafting (pick 2 & 3) entirely based on talent, not needs.

My top three consist of Petracca, McCartin, and Brayshaw. I hope to see two of those on our list by the end of the draft night.

If one of those two ends up being McCartin, I just hope he and Hogan can develop into a potent forward line duo that we'll see at our club for the next 10 years or so.

[ignition. 1,466]

Here's some footage:

[Sir Why You Little 37,036]

Is he ready to play Round one 2015?

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Is he ready to play Round one 2015?

See my post.

[The Great One 99 125]

I still think that the Saints are a chance to take him. I am not sure which one I would take between him and Petracca. Glad we won't have to pick between them, and we win either way

[Moneider96 1,045]

http://boundforglorynews.com/paige-cardonas-phantom-draft-5-0/

I don't think you can possibly compare him to Watts or Butcher after reading this...

[Moneider96 1,045]

Petracca will turn out to be a Colin Sylvia...He's too arrogant..

[jacey 333]

People saying he's undersized is ridiculous. He is bigger than Jack Darling and he goes alright...

A lot of people have bemoaned that if Jack Darling was a little bit taller, he would be a jet.

Meet McCartin

Not sure McCartin is as quick Darling but if he is clearly better then the next best mid for the love of god draft McCartin.

[Redleg 40,925]

I still think that the Saints are a chance to take him. I am not sure which one I would take between him and Petracca. Glad we won't have to pick between them, and we win either way

Well the whole footy world will be stunned if that happens.

[Spin-it-to-Goodwin-it 579]

Well the whole footy world will be stunned if that happens.

Get ready for it.

[Redleg 40,925]

May as well post this for a third time, but in the proper thread now. Take it as you will:

MY MAIL:

Just spoke to my connection down at the Falcons. He said that if Petracca goes pick 1, we must take McCartin. Said the kid is an absolute brute, who plays aggressively and can mark, kick, tackle, out body and the rest.

Makes me think of what could be with a combination of Hogan and McCartin down there for the next 10 years. Also said he is a monster that would be ready to go round 1.

Said he played bottom age last year, and made the All-Australian side, and also actually broke Dom Sheeds collar bone in one of the matches.

Downside is that he has diabetes, and has sometimes had to run off the field to check his levels but is making good progress in learning how to manage this.

Anyways just what I got told. For me, if Petracca goes #1 like he is expected to, McCartin and Brayshaw would be my wishes.

i am just salivating at the thought of Hogan and McCartin as our two key forwards for the next ten years. ATM we also have Dawes, Howe, Fitzy, Gawn, Pedersen, Watts etc. Now with Garlett added to crumb and JKH and Kent, we would have a pretty good forward line. Every other move could be for mids. Maybe a a late or Rookie pick for a ruckman.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

i am just salivating at the thought of Hogan and McCartin as our two key forwards for the next ten years. ATM we also have Dawes, Howe, Fitzy, Gawn, Pedersen, Watts etc. Now with Garlett added to crumb and JKH and Kent, we would have a pretty good forward line. Every other move could be for mids. Maybe a a late or Rookie pick for a ruckman.

We are in a total win, win.

Saints take MCartin, we get Brayshaw and Petracca. If they take Petracca, we take Brayshaw and (hopefully) Mcartin. I have a boner already.

[Redleg 40,925]

Get ready for it.

What makes you think that Saints will pass on Petracca?

[Spin-it-to-Goodwin-it 579]

What makes you think that Saints will pass on Petracca?

The media and Stkilda are full of [censored] for one.

Secondly, the Saints wanting to downgrade to pick 4 and being linked to McCartin as the reason for wanting that trade - we snookered them by threatening to trade one our picks to the Doggies who would have taken him.

Thirdly, trading out Stanley.

Fourthly, the media are full of [censored].