Malthouse seems to think he should retire, while "he still has something left in the tank".

Would we want him at MFC? Would he be interested? Could it happen? Didn't he promise his Nanna he would play for the dees?

Yeah, nah.

No. Turned us down when we were any real chance to get any value out of having him at the club. He is now a shadow of his former self and would lucky to be best 22 at most clubs with the way his body is deteriorating.

Definite no.

Lol So much no

Even if he could go around again, I just couldn't bring myself to support that arrogant sh!tbag.

And the winner is......demondame!

You have got to be taking the pi$$.

Does this really require a new thread?

There's plenty of other threads already dedicated to talk of recruiting and players to target.

*Judd isn't one of them.

SURELY you're taking the absolute [censored]? I'd have for him to come to us, especially in the condition his body is in and how he snubbed us off a few years ago. He can go get f'k'd.

Purely as a player, I miss watching him at his best and think it's sad to watch him run around now.

As a bloke...

Purely as a player, I miss watching him at his best and think it's sad to watch him run around now.

As a bloke...

ill say it, its true, as a bloke… man he has done some very odd things and strikes me as a [censored].

as for his playing ability, he's done. he should retire.

Maybe we could get Locket, Jackovich and Williams as well while we're at it!!

The last thing we need is to help Judd with his pension plan. Despite his skill and ability, he would only clog the list for a year and keep a younger, developing player out of the team.

No thanks.

I like a bit of comedy in the morning.

Was a great footballer but very ordinary leader. Something cold and remote about him. Doubt he is a coach in waiting.

Maybe we could get Locket, Jackovich and Williams as well while we're at it!!

As long as you throw in Cazaley and some of the Fitzroy mosquito fleet from the 19030s.

No, no, no!

We have a far better senior leader at the club right now in Daniel Cross.

Struggling to see the upside of recruiting Judd.

His leadership has always been lacking in my opinion.

Aloof, some would say sh%t bloke.

I don't know what we'd want him for, especially at the expense of a youngster.

Judd has never been the one to play an unpalatable role and sacrifice for the team, a la Daniel Cross.

Only if he promised to do more chicken wings and pressure point assaults. Perhaps a bit of eye gouging, scratching and squirrelling as well. You know, step it up a bit. Nice.

Who would have thought we would be saying no to a multiple all Australian former captain of two sides, premiership captain, norm Smith medalist, dual brownlow medalist and multiple best and fairest winner

In short we need the player desperately even at his age, but his personality makes it a no for me

No he doesn't like our facilities.

I'm with the nays, but not because of some of the petulant people above who only seem to not want him because they're still bitter about how he handled us half a lifetime ago.

I just simply don't see the point. There's a very big chance you'll get nothing from him. If he had anything left to give, Carlton would keep him.

Yes yes and yes ... Judd on one leg and at reduced speed is better than most in our team

Struggling to see the upside of recruiting Judd.

His leadership has always been lacking in my opinion.

Aloof, some would say sh%t bloke.

I don't know what we'd want him for, especially at the expense of a youngster.

Judd has never been the one to play an unpalatable role and sacrifice for the team, a la Daniel Cross.

You are wrong there Machsy he was severely hampered in 2007 and knew he was leaving Meth Coast at the end of the season. He played the second half of that season under extreme duress as his team had another tilt at a flag. Had he been selfish he could have booked in early for surgery and hit the ground running pre-season with his new club. Furthermore he made sure Meth Coast got a good deal when he could have walked via the PSD. Whatever coin the Tigers wanted to throw at him Carlton would have matched and taken him with pick 2 in the PSD.

Having said all that it's a no from me