Selection of Paul Roos successor

[All the Jacks 99]

Starting to warm up,

3AWisfootball: Ling to begin seriously considering coaching career http://t.co/4WHOowVBoC

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-05-24/the-new-crop-of-senior-coaches

Paul Roos says Mark Thompson is on the list of next possible coaches http://afl.to/1jQBkF0

theagesport: AFL: Paul Roos flags Mark Thompson http://t.co/hTYKIfoVoM

27/5

Paul Roos spoke to the media this morning and addressed the mounting speculation regarding his successor - http://mfcde.es/1jU7G1x

Edited May 27, 2014 by All the Jacks

[Guest]

I would like Lingy at the club but I wonder if his timeline matches up with ours. He clearly is a very level headed and smart bloke. He wouldn't get into the caper only to set himself up to fail (i.e. Voss though I think he is salvageable as a senior coach, Tim Watson). If he thinks he needs 3-4 years as an assistant, he would do it. By the sounds of it that might be too long a wait for us.
Roos says he will extend into a third year and then hand over. I am a little worried about that. I think he should say 5 years at an absolute maximum. I understand some potential assistant coaches might get cold feet if Roos just doggedly hangs on but I still think it should be a case of him leaving when the job is done (i.e. when the club can actually withstand him leaving and not fall over as soon as he does).

[All the Jacks 99]

2 years under Paul Roos would be Ideal for Ling or Voss and hopefully Paul Roos influence will still be around the club in a new job 2017

[Young Dee 1,303]

A rather good article on potential coaches

Biding their time: The next wave of senior coaches

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-05-24/the-new-crop-of-senior-coaches

Hopefully we can hold on to Rawlings

Edited May 24, 2014 by Young Dee

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Luke Beveridge is interesting been at hawthorn, throw in 2 years under roos

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Whoever it is it must be a coach who will continue the Roos gameplan. Roos stated that on the MFC mid year review video. I still believe it will be Rawlings. He will have had 3 years under Roos and from all reports he works well with the players and other coaches. Rawlings will have more knowledge of the game plan and the players then any other potential coach out there.

[McQueen 17,867]

Logic would suggest Rawlings considering his time already with Roosy. He seems to have the respect of the players and the times I've listened to him speak he comes across as a person that engages.

Surely he wants another shot at a senior gig?

[chook fowler 19,533]

Nathan Bassett has a good record of success and seems to be able to gel a playing group.

[McQueen 17,867]

Apart from being a MFC player, there's something I find appealing about Beveridge. He took the reigns in a Hawks NAB challenge game earlier this year IIRC.

I wouldn't sneeze at getting an experienced assistant out the Hawthorn system.

[Pipefitter 2,168]

If someone like Ling would come in 2 years would be fine. Players like that are already coaching on the field. Roos as director (master of puppets) coaching. I like it.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

I'd love to get Junior back to the club as a coach. Surely with everyone involved in his sacking now gone he'd consider us again?

[Maldonboy38 6,406]

I am a huge fan of what Basset has done at Norwood.

I still like Ratten.

Beveridge is a smoky. I had not considered him at all but Hawk supporters love his work with the younger players.

But to be honest, I have no idea who is on the Dees radar. Our board no longer leaks and their planning is all done away from the media, quietly and effectively. Looking at the style of PJ and Bartlett, I reckon they already know who they want and have a program of how/when to recruit get him, but are just waiting for the right time to sign off and announce.

[chook fowler 19,533]

I have said it before but next to Roos I think George Stone is the most important to tie up tightly. Much of our midfield turnaround is due to him. As long as he stays in place and we pick a coach that has the players respect we'll be OK.

[BAMF 4,385]

After the Port Vs Hawks game, Cam Ling is saying that in the next few months he will make enquiries about getting into coaching.

He is not saying he is, but he is starting to think about his options.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

If nothing else, we are finally being taken seriously as a club and are genuinely seen to be a credible destination.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/geelong-interested-if-cameron-ling-wants-to-join-coaching-ranks-20140524-zrn6b.html

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Worsfold?

[rjay 25,088]

I think if Ling is the choice then Roos will be official coach for 2 years then unofficial for a couple more, it would be a bit more of a reverse Longmire handover where Roos had really relinquished the role a year or 2 before telling anyone. I couldn't see him coming in from no coaching experience to head coach in 2 years.

[Deez 298]

I still think we should be asking james mcdonald to finish at gws and come back as a coach, potentially successor. he's been coaching/playing at gws since he left melb.

[rolly 149]

jnr mcdonald to make his triumphant return

[JV7 2,354]

I have heard from a reasonable source from someone back in Perth who has a lot to do with football that John Worsfold has moved to melbourne and is keen on coaching again. Supposedly his presence is the richmomd job if it becomes available, if not he wants the melbourne job

[Guest]

I loved Junior as a player.

I was happy PJ showed him the respect he deserved and was not shown in 2010 by naming the best team man award after him.

These were positive developments in the club's history.
Another is that people in the club are no longer getting gigs because they are past players or 'bleed red and blue'.

It doesn't mean that if you played for the club you aren't entitled to apply for a job. It's just that this shouldn't be the main selection criteria.
If Junior makes a decent fist of his time at GWS or elsewhere, then fair enough. However, him being a past club great should be irrelevant.

[Biffen 12,947]

Ling or Bomber.

[Maple Demon 449]

Reading this thread, there have been some very intriguing suggestions. Whomever the Demons choose, I just hope they take their time, do all the proper research and make the best decision for the club rather than go for the latest flavour of the month. That said, with the recent changes made at all levels of the club, I am confident that the right choice.

Worsfold, Ling, and Bassett seem like interesting possibilities to me.

[dazzledavey36 55,320]

Been turned off Bomber recently. I think Brett Kirk would be ideal.

Basically already learning the Paul Roos game plan from Ross Lyon and would be just the perfect smooth transition after Roosy. The game plan wouldnt chance much which I like.

[rjay 25,088]

Been turned off Bomber recently. I think Brett Kirk would be ideal.

Basically already learning the Paul Roos game plan from Ross Lyon and would be just the perfect smooth transition after Roosy. The game plan wouldnt chance much which I like.

I think he might have learned the Paul Roos game plan playing under Paul Roos but I get your drift.

I still think we should be asking james mcdonald to finish at gws and come back as a coach, potentially successor. he's been coaching/playing at gws since he left melb.

jnr mcdonald to make his triumphant return

An inexperienced coach coming out of a bad system, I don't think so.