Carlton Kaos

[angrydee 842]

Couldn't happen to a nicer organization..

Enormous respect for the VISY Paper Bags.

Excellent to puke into

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,534]

Anyway, back on Carlton...

I recall in recent years many people lauding Judd for his leadership and I could never get my head around it.

Yes, head leads by example. He sets an amazing example.

But there's so much more to leadership than that, and I think Judd falls down in a lot of those areas.

Heroic and spectacular acts on the field are just that.

Others may get a lift from these acts, but I don't see that as providing great leadership.

That's just playing footy.

Malthouse now discussing Carlton on FC as being the quietest footy club he's even been at, would seem to be testament to that.

That and maybe also their recruiters being shy of selecting another loudmouth troublemaker like Fevola.

Judd's a great payer and he's also smart. He knows he's not a natural leader - not every great or champion player is (eg, Gary Ablett Sr and probably Marc Murphy). If you remember, when Judd first came to Carlton he didn't want to be captain. But the powers that be gave him the job against his wishes, probably because they thought they knew better and also because there was no other obvious candidate. I suspect having Judd as captain added another layer of wallpaper to the cracks being covered over in other ways.

[Machsy 2,858]

Not trying to put blame on Judd, but I agree, and I've always felt he's a bit aloof.

My point was that I could never understand those in the media incessantly lauding his leadership - leadership I always felt was lacking.

[Binmans PA 26,867]

I actually was quite impressed by MM's press conference after the loss, he made allot of sense, we did do some things right and won the game, but their hard ball gets were up there and if we had at any stage not stuck fat to the plan they would have come over the top of us. They couldn't buy a goal but we played well and they were under pressure going for goal. Not that I like MM but he was pretty sensible about it all.

What is very obvious is that MM is now firmly in the sights of the Media, and is the coach they want to 'get' this year. MM is going to be offered up as the necessary sacrifice by the media, regardless of whether it is deserved or not.

I of course love that the plebeian rabble has chosen Carlton to dwell on and not us, my hate for them remains undiminished.

They were never going to win that game. Who was going to kick their goals? It was just a matter of whether we knew how to win. A bit like the St Kilda game, but this time we had Dawes, so we were afforded confidence going forward.

[dee-luded 2,958]

I saw this and couldn't resist sharing it.

absolutely sensational.

..... they been doing Swan dives, & sampling others waters, for a few years now. but who could riley say when finals will be on their Radar

fuhrious Micks 5th Panzer, all guns will be blazing for they're counteroffensive Battle of Yarra-court, 2015... fuhrious Mick wants to take Lunar-ville back. thinks its written in his horror-scope.

.

Edited April 15, 2014 by dee-luded

[premiers in my lifetime? 30]

Just saw Kernahan interview on news

Said those fatal words "the coach and staff have the full support of the board"

Mick meltdown Gone !!!!!!!

knock knock.

Who's there?

Naught.

Naught who?

Naught and four.

[picket fence 15,856]

Never forgotten Big Head Kernahan's comment a few years ago

"We are Carlton @*%# the Rest

Loving it even better than a buy one Big mac get another for free!

Also loving the interference of Bruce Mathieson , magnificent soap opera of the highest order!

Hope the whole place totally implodes!

[monoccular 16,747]

Nothing feels as good as a bit of schadenfreude when a team like Carltank are at the receiving end.

[Sir Why You Little 35,393]

That meme above of Eddie & Mick could well be the highlight of 2015!!

[McQueen 17,864]

That meme above of Eddie & Mick could well be the highlight of 2015!!

It could have quite well been Neeld instead of MM in that photo and the meme relating to the MFC this time last year.

[Sir Why You Little 35,393]

It could have quite well been Neeld instead of MM in that photo and the meme relating to the MFC this time last year.

It is what it is...!

[Wormburner 674]

It is what it is...!

Didn't see that comin!

[radar 1,859]

Judd?

Leadership?

Eye gouger

Choke hold.

Bent that North guys shoulder 270 degrees for no reason. Real leadership.

Ok running free with Kerr and Benny.

JmAc always got him.

[Ted Lasso 17,350]

Judd?

Leadership?

Eye gouger

Choke hold.

Bent that North guys shoulder 270 degrees for no reason. Real leadership.

Ok running free with Kerr and Benny.

JmAc always got him.

also 250 pllus games, 2 brownlows premiership captain a heap of All Australians and all those minor details.

[chookrat 3,875]

I actually was quite impressed by MM's press conference after the loss, he made allot of sense, we did do some things right and won the game, but their hard ball gets were up there and if we had at any stage not stuck fat to the plan they would have come over the top of us. They couldn't buy a goal but we played well and they were under pressure going for goal. Not that I like MM but he was pretty sensible about it all.

What is very obvious is that MM is now firmly in the sights of the Media, and is the coach they want to 'get' this year. MM is going to be offered up as the necessary sacrifice by the media, regardless of whether it is deserved or not.

I of course love that the plebeian rabble has chosen Carlton to dwell on and not us, my hate for them remains undiminished.

He acquitted himself quite well and some of the stupid questions from the media would have anyone wanting to launch into the crowd of journos with a dragon punch.

[Ted Lasso 17,350]

He acquitted himself quite well and some of the stupid questions from the media would have anyone wanting to launch into the crowd of journos with a dragon punch.

I was so annoyed when Mark Stevens asked him, "are you embarrassed to lose to a team like Melbourne?" and Mick responds with, "I think you're underestimating Melbourne, beaten us and Richmond, should have beaten St. Kilda and GWS".

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I think the stench of tanking still hangs over their heads and they will not go forward until they purge it like we did.

They days of buying or cheating your way to a flag are gone; they, like us, thought that a few number one and a few high picks would guarantee success, we know it doesn't. Carlton has an ordinary list and if Mick thought it was simply a matter of buying Daisy to top it up he was mistaken; they need KPP not more mids.

They have destroyed the culture of the club and as long as the people that planned and condoned it are there, it will haunt them.

[Ted Lasso 17,350]

I think the stench of tanking still hangs over their heads and they will not go forward until they purge it like we did.

They days of buying or cheating your way to a flag are gone; they, like us, thought that a few number one and a few high picks would guarantee success, we know it doesn't. Carlton has an ordinary list and if Mick thought it was simply a matter of buying Daisy to top it up he was mistaken; they need KPP not more mids.

They have destroyed the culture of the club and as long as the people that planned and condoned it are there, it will haunt them.

Thomas Boyd was on the table, how they didn't chase him is beyond me, i wouldn't consider any player on their list untradable for a 10 year power forward.

[Machsy 2,858]

also 250 pllus games, 2 brownlows premiership captain a heap of All Australians and all those minor details.

What does any of the above have to do with leadership?

[Machsy 2,858]

Thomas Boyd was on the table, how they didn't chase him is beyond me, i wouldn't consider any player on their list untradable for a 10 year power forward.

How do you know they didn't chase him?

More importantly, who on Carlton's list would you happily trade Boyd for?

Come on! Think!

[Ted Lasso 17,350]

What does any of the above have to do with leadership?

the quote i was replying too said he was okay in a wce eagles midfielder, i'd say he is abit better than okay, and he's a premiership captain, i don't think that happens if you simply can't lead, certainly there would be better leaders but i don't think he's terrible

in answer to your other question, i'd trade Gibbs and Yarren for Boyd in a heart beat

Gibbs, Yarren, Kruizer, Robinson, Menzel, any of their picks from last year,

i'd suggest a player like Gibbs and their first rounder might have tempted GWS

[monoccular 16,747]

Judd?

Leadership?

Eye gouger

Choke hold.

Bent that North guys shoulder 270 degrees for no reason. Real leadership.

Ok running free with Kerr and Benny.

JmAc always got him.

also 250 pllus games, 2 brownlows premiership captain a heap of All Australians and all those minor details.

.......and absolutely none of those achievements (and other dubious distinctions) has anything at all to do with leadership. The drover's dog could have lead that WCE team to a flag.

Junior didn't have a premiership, a Brownlow, or (correct me if I am wrong) a heap of AAs, yet he was an outstanding leader, far better than Judd has been or will ever be. Sadly, and aided by the benefit of hindsight, he was put down a year or two too soon, something that our club has suffered from ever since.

Edited April 16, 2014 by monoccular

[Dee Fan 3,247]

.......and absolutely none of those achievements (and other dubious distinctions) has anything at all to do with leadership.

Junior didn't have a premiership, a Brownlow, or (correct me if I am wrong) a heap of AAs, yet he was an outstanding leader, far better than Judd has been or will ever be. Sadly, and aided by the benefit of hindsight, he was put down a year or two too soon, something that our club has suffered from ever since.

When was he put down, I didn't hear that.

[Ted Lasso 17,350]

.......and absolutely none of those achievements (and other dubious distinctions) has anything at all to do with leadership. The drover's dog could have lead that WCE team to a flag.

Junior didn't have a premiership, a Brownlow, or (correct me if I am wrong) a heap of AAs, yet he was an outstanding leader, far better than Judd has been or will ever be. Sadly, and aided by the benefit of hindsight, he was put down a year or two too soon, something that our club has suffered from ever since.

i'd argue you can't be a premiership captain without being a leader to some extent, i'll give you an example, my boss is a massive Carlton supporter, last year on the bye week the blues were given an optional training the first day, one player turned up, guess who it was, my boss went to training to watch one bloke get out there.

being a duel brownlow medalist means you have some good habbits and standards, this is another example of leadership, he is a role model for the younger players at training and so on, this is how a brownlow medalist carries himself,

captain of two different clubs to me says someone thinks he's a decent leader.

[Undeeterred 2,908]

also 250 pllus games, 2 brownlows premiership captain a heap of All Australians and all those minor details.

That's being a good player, not a good leader. Plenty of douchebags have successful careers, doesn't mean they're not pricks.