The Successor

[Vitamin Dee 855]

Channel Seven weathergirl Sarah Cumming?

Who's the weathergirl on Seven in Melb these days?

Is it Judd? Can she be bumped? She's horrible.

Surely Channel 10 is looking for an upgrade?

If that is his girlfriend the man has done very well,he should stay in Sydney and do whatever the hell she tells him to do. WHATEVER.

Although, I am now more intrigued than ever, Dew is obviously a brilliant communicator and strategist.....get him to Melbourne now!

[Machsy 2,858]

Sarah Cumming is his wife, yes.

They have a kid together.

Edited October 11, 2013 by Machsy

[nutbean 8,838]

I think that people are missing two vital points.

With most succession plans :

1/ You dont only do you own job - you are involved in the learning the job for which you have been annointed as successor ( as in Dews case senior assistant then becoming head coach) - he would be involved in the decisions and tasks that Roos does so he can learn the skills. It is a different apprenticeship from just being an assistant and then getting the top gig. It is working with Roos as head coach for next 2-3 years so at the end of his apprenticeship he is more than just an assistant that has taken over cold. So to all those saying that of the rumoured names "what has he done" - the experience to be a head coach is going to come over the next 2-3 years whilst it may not be there right now - thats why it is a succession plan.

2/ All succession plans I have seen are not locked in stone and there is an out clause for both the company and the successor - The likes of a Dew may get 2 years into the apprenticeship and say it aint for me and likewise Roos may say that he hasnt come along as hoped and all bets are off - it is not usually a clause made public but it is there. The clause usually comes with golden handshakes for the successor if the succession plan doesnt go ahead.

[bing181 9,053]

Maybe Dew doesn't want to come to the MFC?

According to Mahoney, he made a presentation for the position, so hard to see how that could be the case.

[Viney Vidi Vici 145]

My question is who the backup if we can't get Dew.
looking at how Dew came out of nowhere (from the outside perspective) into considerations says to me that no one has one flying clue who else is under consideration.

[rpfc 28,068]

And yet he is only 34 - you would think he had been coach for a couple decades by reading that.

That's really the only thing that worries me - at 34 there must still be a few question marks over his ability to perform at the top (don' want to make a Neeld mistake again).

If we do get him I would like him to have as long as possible under Roos. Also I would like Melbourne to have two possible successors so we don't put all our eggs in one basket.

It would be great if Roosy stayed coach for 3 years and then 1 year as Dew's senior adviser. But I only see that happening if Roosy believes in the direction of the club after his 2-3 year contract ends.

I hope you weren't one of the fawn dogs salivating over Simpson before he took over at WCE...

Dew, or whoever takes the role, is allowed the luxury of a running head start under Roos. Whatever flavour of the month amongst assistants will come and go and we will groom this person for our own ends.

There is no perfect way to install a coach. We have decided to Poach and Groom.

[Craig Drinker 179]

According to Mahoney, he made a presentation for the position, so hard to see how that could be the case.

Yeah, what's with that? I thought Sydney weren't allowing Dew to be interviewed by the MFC?

[Machsy 2,858]

The plot thickens...

Of course Dew has made a presentation to the selection panel, or at least Roos, Mahoney and Jackson.

The process would never go this far without it.

He hasn't been granted official permission to interview, but that is moot.

It's only relevant because permission to accept the position would be implicit.

I imagine if Dew is not released from his contract (extremely unlikely IMO) we'll just wait for him.

Worst case scenario is that he changes his mind, we'll move on and and just grab the best candidate next year.

It's not the end of the world.

The important thing is the cultural shift, and the coach or successor alone won't do that.

[dazzledavey36 53,069]

Stewy dew has signed a three year deal with the Swans.

Now what??

[S.R.J 418]

I think the plan will be for roos to settle in for a year. Which would mean he coaches for 3... What about Voss? I know he shot himself with the fev trade.

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

Back to square one.

[Demon3 2,541]

While I am confident in the Roos plan, it is a bit if a worry, great assistants, like coaches, do not grow on trees.

Looks like a year without a senior assistant.. I'm not sure I like that!

[Roos can't lose 43]

Where is link to report on dew signing with swans

[Young Dee 1,303]

Bugger - goes against all our inside 'sources'........

I hear there is a so called Mark Neeld waiting in the wings?

Now I am actually beginning to worry if we can lure anyone to the club this year - Roo's or not.

Edited October 11, 2013 by Young Dee

[Young Dee 1,303]

Where is link to report on dew signing with swans

http://www.sydneyswans.com.au/news/2013-10-12/dew-resigns-with-the-swans

[Ouch! 2,210]

so ... there were 5-6 candidates according to Mahoney, Burns, Simpson and Dew were three of these candidates. We haven't spoken with Tudor or Bassett, who does that leave?

I wonder whether we look to contact Bassett,... who else? Voss & Harvey are unlikely IMO. What about Lappin who is at Geelong currently? Sumich?

Could Rawlings be a chance to be elevated from within the coaches we already have?

Interesting to see what our next comment is on this... and is it just me or does Paul Roos & PJ seem very quiet at the moment? it could just be that Mahoney is the person that is visible to the media due to the trade period I guess....

Edited October 11, 2013 by Oucher

[Young Dee 1,303]

so ... there were 5-6 candidates according to Mahoney, Burns, Simpson and Dew were three of these candidates. We haven't spoken with Tudor or Bassett, who does that leave?

I wonder whether we look to contact Bassett,... who else? Voss & Harvey are unlikely IMO. What about Lappin who is at Geelong currently? Sumich?

Could Rawlings be a chance to be elevated from within the coaches we already have?

Interesting to see what our next comment is on this... and is it just me or does Paul Roos & PJ seem very quiet at the moment? it could just be that Mahoney is the person that is visible to the media due to the trade period I guess....

PJ has never been one to approach the media - so far he has let his actions do the talking.

I think we need to land a decent player - show that we are a desirable club. It would be nice for one of our players to come out and say that anyone who gets picked up by Melbourne would be very lucky.

So far we seem to be that smelly fat kid at the front of class who nobody wants to sit next to. God I would like to be a fly on Paul Roos shoulder (I am so sick of being in the dark).

Edited October 12, 2013 by Young Dee

[Deestar3 167]

One thing I have noticed is that since pj has come to the club .....nothing has been leaked.....yes..rumours & innuendo but nothing of fact. I have complete faith in what roos & pj are doing.......if you think for one moment that roos took on this position without having his "team" in place then you sell him short. I have no interest in listening to the rumblings & speculation from journalists & posters alike who have nothing better to do than try & fill space in a long off season. I don't believe roos is the "messiah" but will trust the expertise, respect & knowledge that someone like him brings. I don't believe in the perception that the mfc is an unattractive place to go to......if you put the right deal in front of anyone they will take it. So far we are bemoaning missing out on players & assistant coaches when in reality there has been no concrete evidence of any firm offers being made. I think,it is exciting to see what is unfolding & I am happy to wait. After all,it is a long time till February. String it out i say !

[Real Demon 232]

Matthew Knights or Brett Ratten anyone?

[Machsy 2,858]

No.

But I notice Voss hasn't popped up anywhere yet...

[Young Dee 1,303]

Matthew Knights or Brett Ratten anyone?

Brett Ratten maybe as midfield coach or in some line position but I am not sure if his game style really matches Roo's.

PJ and Roo's said they where surprised how few professional/experienced staff we had at the club - we need to start fixing that.

[Young Dee 1,303]

No.

But I notice Voss hasn't popped up anywhere yet...

I see Voss as a good honest coach but not a Grand Final coach

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,867]

Well it looks like we have right royally messed this up. No Simpson, Burns, Dew, Tudor. I have a feeling we have put all our eggs in the Dew basket and this will certainly throw a spanner in the works.

[DeeSpencer 24,827]

I still think Sydney put him between a rock and a hard place. If they gave him their blessing early then he probably would've taken the gig. Instead he had to choose between 1 year stuck at Sydney then taking the Melbourne job or the 3 year deal at Sydney. But good luck to them.

I'm not sure why I liked Dew besides his novelty come back showing you can be portly and dominate AFL. He was large and in charge.

Anyway back to the drawing board. Simon Goodwin has signed on at Essendon. Geel, Haw, Syd, Coll a lot of the recent premiers have been stripped of the glamour assistants.

Mark Stone or Simon Lloyd from Sydney. Look that up - http://www.fremantlefc.com.au/footy-centre/coaching-staff

[tonatopia 278]

Kirk.

Spirit is the number1 ingredient in successful footy.