mitch

You are also completely off your face if you are putting Viney, Vince and Dunn in the same boat as Dayne Beams. Its amazing how much we love to overrate our list as soon as the season ends.

He should have included Jones for Melbourne, but besides that I absolutely agree with him., Beams is a young gun, and i would most definitely not accept pick 5 and a second rounder for him. I guess its easy for us to criticise Collingwood for playing hardball, but I would expect nothing less coming out of demonland if the shoe was on our foot.

If St Kilda end up preferring Mccartin over Petracca, we would be completely foolish to trade either pick 2 or 3. Acquiring Petracca and Brayshaw would set up our midfield for the next 10 years, with one who is compared to a fast Dustin Martin (without the personality deficiencies) and another who is compared to Ollie Wines. Unless we can get Dangerfield, there is no better result. These boys are also ready made players, no waiting in the wings for these beasts.

If we trade them pick 2, we are at no risk of losing Petracca (considering he doesn't go pick one) or Brayshaw, as Bulldogs are going to pick either Mccartin or Wright. This deal could be hugely beneficial for us, if we can get our hands on a Dalhaus, Stringer, Hrovat/Wallis type.

This kid is everything I want. Fast paced medium size rebounding defender, as aggressive as they can be (is being compared to Byron Pickett), and can play any position you ask. He is a 19 year old Hertier Lumumba, and is thought to be around the pick 15-30 mark. If we trade pick 22 for Lumumba and this kid is still around, I will be absolutely devastated.

They didn't get Tom Gillies after trying in 2010, look who landed with that star.

Had 64 possessions one game in the reserves, and that didn't even get him a call up. Starved of opportunities and may be looking to come home.

Dom Tyson ring a bell?

No key forwards for the next 3 weeks, losses to GWS, Carlton and Gold Coast are certain. 0-5, great way to start the year.

We didn't have a forward line, they didn't have a midfield and we lost the clearances. Letting them off the hook just cause Roos is our coach.

Trengove had 30 disposals and a whopping 13 marks!

Please calm down, it's the [censored] nab cup. Everyone is excited but people are rejoicing like we have won the premiership.

Just found out that he is a restricted free agent. Surely we will match his offer which means that we either keep him, or get a decent player in return.

I don't know why people expect a pick 57 to play in their first year anyway. No matter how physically ready they are. Give the kid some time to develop.

Yes. Can't beleive we didn't take him with 57.