wheaters31

It is often said that there is a point in which the game has gone passed players. The same phrase can be applied to expert comment personnel too IMO. And I think Gerard now falls into that category.

Lindsay and Windsor have been so disappointing.

Brad Scott has a 86.67% win percentage against Melbourne 15 games, 13 wins. I can see us losing this. Similar feel to when they beat us with a team of replacements in Round 2, 2016.

Did they explain why they hated us?

Max is tremendous, but he needs to park the ego sometimes and accept he needs greater assistance from a second/support ruck. He was clearly sore today and going up against two rucks was always going to be an issue for us. Turner getting injured didn't help, as that meant Petty couldn't ruck, but Heath has to be considered next week. I think it is unfair that Culley is being played as a third tall forward when he dominated preseason in the midfield. I think we could use his more mature body as an inside mid to help the likes of Windsor. Bring Melksham in as the third forward if he is fit, or bring in Heath and play him as a forward when he isn't rucking. Release Culley in the midfield. CJ's mistakes by foot are a real worry. I'd love to see Moniz-Wakefield brought in for him. After his criticism last week, I thought Sparrow was a positive today.

Latrelle Pickett in number 33 please #jeffreyjeffreyjeffrey Taylor for number 20

Put simply, he's a left-footed Trent Rivers

I hope we attempted to trade our first pick and gold coast's F1, for one of Richmond's picks and a future second/third. That way we could guarantee getting one of Robey, X Taylor and Cumming. Then use our second pick for Nairn since we are so keen on him. Gold Coast's F1 will be a late teens pick next year anyway.

No. This actually makes me angry at the thought. We are better off backing our current players. Rivers, Windsor, Langford, Sparrow, Lindsay etc. Another Jack Billings type trade. Bugger off Lamb.

This reminds me of the Héritier Lumumba move. Fills a need. Jiath and AMW as our small forward stoppers.

Two left-footed, unrelated Lindsay's in the same team. Brian Taylor wouldn't be able to get his head around it on commentary.

Did Humphrey train with us before he was drafted? Similar to how Langford trained with us before he was drafted

It was reported today that Humphrey's management has told rival clubs of his availability recently. I wouldn't be surprised if this forced our hand with Clayton. We need more draft capital and space in the cap for Humphrey. The only way we get Humphrey to nominate us is if we offer him big dollars and a significant midfield role.

Playing through a dislocated toe injury

I think they'll be upgrades to Langford and Lindsay Langford to #9 Lindsay to #1