Who will be in the new Leadership group

[DeeSpencer 23,483]

Watts? Come on guys last year he was still shirking contests every now and then. He's still miles away.

Grimes and Trengove obviously

Jones and Clark based on form

Frawley

Jamar

Possibly one of Dawes, Garland or a surprise inclusion like Joel Macdonald who lacks some talent but is properly a respected older type these days or Jordie McKenzie

[dee-luded 2,958]

Trengove, Grimes, Mitch Clark, Nathan Jones, James Frawley, Mark Jamar, Colin Garland, & David Rodan.

We are a very young list & many aren't ready to be on the leadership group, let alone get a game as a 'regular'.

With that, I think we'll go with one of our most senior players now at the club, who will only be around, until some of our younger brigade step up they're credentials.

So for me Rodan may be the one to replace Barts.

Clint Bartram,

[P-man 13,277]

Watts? Come on guys last year he was still shirking contests every now and then. He's still miles away.

Grimes and Trengove obviously

Jones and Clark based on form

Frawley

Jamar

Possibly one of Dawes, Garland or a surprise inclusion like Joel Macdonald who lacks some talent but is properly a respected older type these days or Jordie McKenzie

Firstly, your list isn't complete. Choosing one of Dawes, Garland or Joel Mac only brings the number to 7.

Secondly, you rubbish the suggestion of Watts, but suggest Joel Macdonald? That wouldn't be a "surprise inclusion", that would be one for the funny farm. Joel Mac is a depth player, at best. Watts is one of the most talented players we have and represents the future of the club.

Edited December 13, 2012 by P_Man

[skills32 229]

Grimes/Trengove - Captains

Jones

Clark

Dawes

Jamar

Garland

Frawley

Sylvia

That's my pick, and yes you read correctly, Sylvia. I think it's time something clicked with him and even though it's a gamble somewhat, being part of the leadership group might just be the thing he needs to really switch on.

Yeah and they made me bus prefect at school for the same reason.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Is there still a chance our double captaincy won't be retained?

If Trengove can be captain then Watts deserves to be in the leadership group, in my opinion.

Don't be surprised if you see Chris Dawes put in it.

[DeeSpencer 23,483]

Firstly, your list isn't complete. Choosing one of Dawes, Garland or Joel Mac only brings the number to 7.

Secondly, you rubbish the suggestion of Watts, but suggest Joel Macdonald? That wouldn't be a "surprise inclusion", that would be one for the funny farm. Joel Mac is a depth player, at best. Watts is one of the most talented players we have and represents the future of the club.

So why is Nick Maxwell a premiership captain and Dayne Swan not in the leadership group. Will you see Alex Fasolo in the Collingwood leadership group anytime soon, he's one of Collingwoods brightest young talent,what about future star talent Dayle Garlett? Clear as day Watts was dropped last year and then after an injury played poorly both in form and spirit in the last rounds of the year. He's part of the future of the club but he isn't "the future". If he was pick 80 and played a few average years as a forward with some class then moved behind the ball and barely set the world on fire you wouldn't dare suggest him for the leadership group.

Why does the number have to be 7? Is that law?

We are still short on genuine leadership and the best leaders are respected players. I agree Macdonald is only depth but even if he is playing most of the year at Casey why can't he be in the leadership group? He plays hard footy, trains hard and is respected. Isn't that setting an example for the other players. Neeld went for a young leadership group but he picked guys who were ready. Watts is a long way from ready to lead other players.

[DeeSpencer 23,483]

Is there still a chance our double captaincy won't be retained?

If Trengove can be captain then Watts deserves to be in the leadership group, in my opinion.

Don't be surprised if you see Chris Dawes put in it.

Why?

When was Watts a top 5 trainer and runner at the club?

When did Watts really put his body on the line like Trenners?

When did Watts last get suspended for tackling too hard?

When did Watts be a vocal leader on and off the field?

Dawes for sure, but please tell me how on earth Watts deserves to be in the leadership group just cause Trengove is captain.

I'm not Watts bashing here, but people near to observe games, training sessions and coaches speaking and think about Watts. If your local footy club was Melbourne would you vote Watts into your footy club?

[Swampfox 190]

The media would have a field day if we changed the co captain structure so i would expect it to stay as is

With Barts gone i would expect Dawes to be included into the leadership group

I would not expect any news on leadership until at least NAB Cup time

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Why?

When was Watts a top 5 trainer and runner at the club?

When did Watts really put his body on the line like Trenners?

When did Watts last get suspended for tackling too hard?

When did Watts be a vocal leader on and off the field?

Dawes for sure, but please tell me how on earth Watts deserves to be in the leadership group just cause Trengove is captain.

I'm not Watts bashing here, but people near to observe games, training sessions and coaches speaking and think about Watts. If your local footy club was Melbourne would you vote Watts into your footy club?

Watts isn't a runner or a trainer, he's a player. He has some flaws he needs to fix, sure. I observe him all the time when we play, and his passion stands out and he never looks like he wants to concede defeat. He's clearly got talent and passion for the club.

Don't blow Trengove up too much, he had a pretty poor year and looked slow. He does do the inspiring thing every now and then but I liked him better in years 1 & 2. Doesn't strike me as a vocal leader to the effect Jones does, you can hear him scream like a madman every time he wants the ball in training or during games, even from the top level

[armstrong35 262]

Captains: Trengove & Grimes
Clark
Jones
Garland
Jamar
Sylvia (Give him some responsibility, might pick up his game and attitude)
Frawley
Davey
Dawes

[Roger Mellie 3,601]

I'd put Sylvia into the leadership group if he finally showed us why he's pick 3 consistently.

I'd do it in a second.

Mitch Clark didn't at any stage look like leadership material at Brisbane (IMO), but I think that's completely changed now.

But Sylvia isn't Mitch Clark.

For me:

In Dawes

Out Bartram

Smokies: Rodan, Howe, Jordie

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

This isn't about who are good blokes and good footballers.

It's about who are good leaders.

Good communicators is No.1 Understanding and implementing game plans would be high on the agenda.

Understanding the ins and outs of the club structure. Great work ethic. Ability to help team mates.

[Demon Jack 6,388]

Definitely would like to see Dawes in the group. Seems the type of player who can make an impact among the players. Leave the captains as they are and maybe try to squeeze in another experienced player (Rodan, Byrnes) or youngster (Howe, Mckenzie) depending on pre season results.

Edited December 14, 2012 by Demon Jack

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Does anyone know whether Sylvia's truly committed to the new regime? I'd love to know.

I reckon Rivers and Moloney leaving would've had a big impact on him, not necessarily in a wholly positive way.

I really hope this guy plays his entire career at this club.

[Daz's Dee's 113]

Does anyone know whether Sylvia's truly committed to the new regime? I'd love to know.

I reckon Rivers and Moloney leaving would've had a big impact on him, not necessarily in a wholly positive way.

I really hope this guy plays his entire career at this club.

Great question one I'd also love to know the answer too. I guess we will see throughout the year (barring injury) if

1) he can hold his spot

2) if other clubs show interest and $$$

3) if the club looks like being successful and are a legitimate chance to play finals.

He is a free agent next year very interesting year for him

[CBDees 3,162]

Does anyone know whether Sylvia's truly committed to the new regime? I'd love to know.

I reckon Rivers and Moloney leaving would've had a big impact on him, not necessarily in a wholly positive way.

I really hope this guy plays his entire career at this club.

Listen to Sylvia's interview on the MFC website. I am happy with Sylvia (and also regret losing Rivers and Moloney, who is really hitting his straps in the Lion's pre-season).

[Longsufferingnomore 1,489]

Listen to Sylvia's interview on the MFC website. I am happy with Sylvia (and also regret losing Rivers and Moloney, who is really hitting his straps in the Lion's pre-season).

I read that about Moloney as well but as they say proof will be in the pudding. He would train well with us and run around with arms flailing but come game time he constantly went missing. He was voted out of the leadership group - sulk - he wouldnt/couldnt buy into Neelds game requirements - sulk. As I have said previously for someone who was obviously looking for a new Club his last performance/attitude at Casey was abysmal and frankly I was embarrassed for him. We sent him off well at the B&F. He got a rousing reception. I watched the Bulldogs Round 4 game on Foxtel this weekend and there were glimpses of the old Moloney. It is sad when a player who was a lifelong supporter of the Club leaves under such a cloud but if the reports are true then it will be a win win situation. As far as Rivers he has given a massive part of his career to the Club and played well albeit in a different position. There was no sulking when he was played out of his normal position. I can only wish him well with his goal to play in a premiership team.

I havent heard Cols interview but to me actions will speak louder than words with him. For years we have all held such high hopes for him and I know in the last two years there have been preseason injuries and incidents but it is what he has done or not done on the field. He obviously has such high skill levels even match winning skills but he doesnt produce them consistently whether during the game or in a number of games. Neeld will be great for him. Maybe for years under Bailey etc he got by on what the Club thought he could produce. Under Neeld and Misson there are no preconceived ideas as to the level of his ability. It is time to put up or get out and hopefully Col is now ready to put up.

[Demon Jack 6,388]

After reading some posts it may seem that Col Sylvia has become the new whipping boy.

[Schneider 220]

Shame the co-captain decision was made last year. I agree with others, can't change that now it wouldn't look good and I do see Grimes / Trengove as future captains just probably too early.

Watching all the video from Darwin, seems Jones and Clark are clear standouts as leaders.

[stuie 7,374]

Shame the co-captain decision was made last year. I agree with others, can't change that now it wouldn't look good and I do see Grimes / Trengove as future captains just probably too early.

Watching all the video from Darwin, seems Jones and Clark are clear standouts as leaders.

Don't disagree that Jones and Clark are definitely spiritual leaders, but gotta say, every time I hear/read Grimes speak I never cease to be impressed. He is a captain's captain in the making.

[rjay 24,046]

After reading some posts it may seem that Col Sylvia has become the new whipping boy.

I don't think he is the whipping boy, but I do think most of us would like to see him reach his potential.

[rjay 24,046]

Listen to Sylvia's interview on the MFC website. I am happy with Sylvia (and also regret losing Rivers and Moloney, who is really hitting his straps in the Lion's pre-season).

I'm not disappointed to see Moloney move on, I don't think his style of game suits where we are going. I never have. I do think after his manager tipped him in it mid season he left the club with some dignity and didn't rise to the media bait that was offered on many interviews. Good on him for that.

[Demon trucker 1,779]

I dont believe in leadership groups too many cooks, the co captains was a bigmistake, grimes should have been solcaptain, u have one leader and a vs captain. Thats your leadership group.

[stingrays 24]

Reading player interviews and watching the club videos, and knowing he is one of the top trainers; James Magner seems to be up there. Can a rookie be in the leadership group?

[rpfc 27,637]

Sylvia in the LG?

Why do people think that being in the LG *gives* a player leadership?

The leaders will be in the group, not the ones who you wish were leaders. As a leader in a team, it would be foolish to belittle the experience by giving it to the 8th person in line simply because you are at your wits end as to how to get a bloke to pull his finger out.

Clark, Garland, Frawley, Jones, and Rodan.