Jurrah to Port?

[Sir Why You Little 37,045]

My sentiments to Mr Bean. I have no bad feelings toward LJ, but i was actually hurt when he just walked. The MFC is a better place for the LJ experience, it is just sad he HAD to go back home that weekend. If he had stayed south the no. 24 may still be on the list.

If he goes to the big house he will rue that moment.

[Biffen 12,943]

Good Luck at Port Jurrahcane!

Milk 'em dry son .

[Nasher 33,616]

That would be this - Port Adelaide's not ready for Liam Jurrah, says club great Warren Tredrea.

I completely agree with Tredrea, I think the fact that they took him is a paradoxical indication that they're not ready for him. I simply can't fathom why a professional football club would want to take him on at this point in his life. It's like they listened to all their forum footy experts who said he was worth a punt and took it from there. I think it's irresponsible recruiting myself, but whatever floats their boat.

[PaulRB 6,363]

Port need every win and piece of good news they can get. They just posted a 2-4 million dollar loss, are leaking players and face a couple of years re-building with a new coach. Gaining an experienced and talented forward / excitement machine who'd be a walk up started in their 22 for Zero in the rookie draft is a no brainer. If things go bad for Liam in his court case in March they say "see ya" and calm they did their best by Liam etc...

Liam is not a toxic influence on the group, he worked hard and kept his head down until last year when things went off the rail.

Port's current rookies = Danny Butcher

If he'd come "home" to Melbourne, there would be numerous clubs cueing to speak to him.

[beelzebub 23,377]

I completely agree with Tredrea, I think the fact that they took him is a paradoxical indication that they're not ready for him. I simply can't fathom why a professional football club would want to take him on at this point in his life. It's like they listened to all their forum footy experts who said he was worth a punt and took it from there. I think it's irresponsible recruiting myself, but whatever floats their boat.

Theyre desperate for some "X" factor.....

As a club they havent been making a lot of good decisions lately, this is testament to its continuation id suggest

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

I do not profess to have knowledge of the cultural divide that separates us but the thing that irked me was the complete lack of acknowledgment of the support the club had given him - I would have been happy enough for his manager or the club to make a statement on Liam's behalf "Liam has asked me to thank.....etc".

I would be surprised if Liam's culture does not find the giving of appreciation necessary. I restate that I have no knowledge of the culture but I believe that it is a basic human trait that spans all cultures that when levels of support and help are given, appreciation/acknowledgment is shown/given in return

Who knows man. It might be cultural, he might be too distracted by the situation to say anything, or he might just be a dick.

Like you said, we just don't know enough to make the call.

[Guest José Mourinho]

Well if you dont have respect for contracts that's fine Jose, but some people choose to be more professional than that.

Haha twist and turn...

[stuie 7,374]

Haha twist and turn...

Ha! You're calling me a black kettle...

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

Hahahahahahahaha do you have ANY understanding of football? If you're scenario applied then any player could just walk club to club. Geez you ever heard of the "trade period" mate. Far out.

Do you have any understanding of contracts?? Have you ever heard of Free Agency or the National/Pre season draft?? How many AFL player contracts have you seen/reviewed?? Have you ever heard of the concept of restriction of trade??

How about producing some facts to your statements before slagging people off.... I would love to hear you expain how an AFL contract is different to an employment contract. And yes i do understand the restrictions the AFL places on player movement.

A little more facts from you and a lot less slagging would be a nice change from you Stuie

And before you go on about how i know nothing maybe we'll use a real life scenerio and you can explain to me the ramificatoins of St Kilda terminating Winmar's contract 1 year early

Edited November 30, 2012 by Unleash Hell

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

PS: I couldn't give a stuff if Jurrah plays for Port

Yeh it's a shame he left, yep he had issues and [censored] didn't work out - footy lists change and a bloke (hopefully) who wants to play winning footy at the Dees gets a chance.....

Thanks for the service LJ all the best (except against the Dees)

[stuie 7,374]

Do you have any understanding of contracts?? Have you ever heard of Free Agency or the National/Pre season draft?? How many AFL player contracts have you seen/reviewed?? Have you ever heard of the concept of restriction of trade??

How about producing some facts to your statements before slagging people off.... I would love to hear you expain how an AFL contract is different to an employment contract. And yes i do understand the restrictions the AFL places on player movement.

A little more facts from you and a lot less slagging would be a nice change from you Stuie

And before you go on about how i know nothing maybe we'll use a real life scenerio and you can explain to me the ramificatoins of St Kilda terminating Winmar's contract 1 year early

Here's a fact: Football is not a "normal" job. How many times have you heard of someone in a "normal" job being traded? ie: 2 Companies agree to swap workers...

Here's another fact: Free agency, draft periods etc etc are all part of a players contract.

And here's one more: In ANY industry, someone who does not honor contracts does not last long, so apply that to your thinking when you say players are free to walk club to club willy nilly.

ps- Sincere apologies for the tone of my first reply, too harsh in my response.

Edited November 30, 2012 by stuie

[Brayshaws' Helmet 143]

i can't believe some of the posters on here, the guys family life is falling apart, and you're wanting compensation because he's leaving for nothing. Poor little MFC supporters.

Have some perspective people. Life>football

[Guest bluey]

Not much of a bloke all round, doing very little for his people hiding under his bed in Adelaide, if he had any balls he would be heading back home to help his people and mediate the issues, deserted the MFC as well, seems to be pretty good at running away and hiding when challenged.

[Pennant St Dee 13,184]

Not much of a bloke all round, doing very little for his people hiding under his bed in Adelaide, if he had any balls he would be heading back home to help his people and mediate the issues, deserted the MFC as well, seems to be pretty good at running away and hiding when challenged.

Bluey the more you post the more it becomes clear what a fookin ejit you are. I'd say returning home may see him locked up for breach of bail.

In regards to Jurrah costing us nothing that is true Iin a sense he was a Rookie pick and always was a risk, did he effect our culture well yes in part he did or should I say those who invested in him did, he was another in a long list of project players. Lets not forget we originally were looking at taking a hard working mid who could also play forward at the time. But we didn't and Rockliff went to Brisbane where his hard work paid off. He could have been a handy pick up and provided quality leadership but we will never know

[Mono 455]

......

In regards to Jurrah costing us nothing that is true Iin a sense he was a Rookie pick and always was a risk, ..............

Nope, he was selected pick 1 in the 2009 PSD. MFC had to get special permission for him to enter the PSD, as he had not nominated for the ND.

We did a lot of hand-holding with Jurrah; you have to wonder why the filth didn't go to the same trouble (he played some VFL games for them)?.

[stuie 7,374]

i can't believe some of the posters on here, the guys family life is falling apart, and you're wanting compensation because he's leaving for nothing. Poor little MFC supporters.

Have some perspective people. Life>football

Yet he's still managing to play for Port... hmmmmmm...

[jnrmac 20,089]

Jurrah's 2 - 4 wrist looks fine and dandy.

Didn't stop him swinging a machete.

[Pennant St Dee 13,184]

Nope, he was selected pick 1 in the 2009 PSD. MFC had to get special permission for him to enter the PSD, as he had not nominated for the ND.

We did a lot of hand-holding with Jurrah; you have to wonder why the filth didn't go to the same trouble (he played some VFL games for them)?.

Whichever draft it was Pre season or Rookie it was 2008 and Rockliff went in the same draft and had been training with us, our ethos around the period 2008-11 seemed to be Project over Workrate

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Yet he's still managing to play for Port... hmmmmmm...

Hasnt yet.......Hmmmmmm.

In fact a long way short that atm.

Needs to prove his mettle.

[stuie 7,374]

Hasnt yet.......Hmmmmmm.

In fact a long way short that atm.

Needs to prove his mettle.

Yeah no certainty that's for sure, was just responding to the guy saying he has family problems and footy is not as important... I don't disagree with the sentiment, but the fact Jurrah is trying to keep his career going at Port when all these things are far from resolved suggest to me that's not much of an excuse for him.

[Biffen 12,943]

Who knows man. It might be cultural, he might be too distracted by the situation to say anything, or he might just be a dick.

Like you said, we just don't know enough to make the call.

I chose option C.

[PJ_12345 1,098]

I think you are all missing the point.

I understand why LJ had to cut and run from the MFC but i thi. there are a range of issues here that none of us will understand.

His career is on a knifes edge and he is a football player - has to make an income and be near home.

It will take a while till this issue geta towards the point end of thibgs but let us remember rhat

LJ wasnt a hack, he was a sharp tool in the shed and was a cut above the rest.

It was knife to know him and i wish him the best of luck in his endevours.

[PJ_12345 1,098]

^^ sorry for all the spellimg mistakes my phone likea to lay the game lets see how hard we can make it for me to type and randomly starts sentances in diferrent words and not let me ammend them

[Deefiant 441]

Nope, he was selected pick 1 in the 2009 PSD. MFC had to get special permission for him to enter the PSD, as he had not nominated for the ND.

We did a lot of hand-holding with Jurrah; you have to wonder why the filth didn't go to the same trouble (he played some VFL games for them)?.

MFC didn't get the special permission, pretty sure Collingwood did that

[SidVicious 130]

Who mentioned compensation?

I'm happy that we neither asked for, nor received any compo in these circumstances because, in a football sense, he was not a player for who compensation is warranted.

Jurrah had talent to burn but did we ever really see him do the things necessary to enhance his talent to the point where he could have become one of the stars of the competition? Long before the alleged machete attack in Alice Springs, the training reports about him generally suggested otherwise. He didn't have much of a tank to start off with but what did he do to improve that?

Now he presents himself to train at Port Adelaide for a PSD or rookie spot and the visual evidence suggests he hasn't done much work in between his departure to Adelaide and the present time - Jurrah back on the track. His excuse might be that he has other things to worry about like the sad state of his community and his family and his forthcoming trial. That's true but if you want to be a professional footballer you have some responsibility to your club and your team.

Tredrea is 100% correct. Jurrah, the footballer, needs to prove himself at State League level before getting another chance.