186 - Hall of Shame

[jnrmac 19,513]

9 Players now gone from the 22 that 'represented the club' in Rd 19, 2011. They are Gys, Bate, Moloney (did not get a stat!), Rivers, Petterd, Martin, Maric, Jurrah, Green.

Interestingly three of those players (Gys 11, Rivers 10 and Martin 10) were the only players to have 10 kicks or more

Finally someone is ruthless.

Go Dees. Go Neeld.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Why do people keep reminding me of this horrible event?!

[binman 39,631]

Hall fo shame - is that a list of the worst Vietnamese soup restaurants?

[Sir Why You Little 35,342]

An excellent point that the Media never bring up...186 that is, not vietnamese soup kitchens which i love, unlike 186!!!

[satyricon 267]

Read a story along similar lines, except most of the Nazi war criminals died of old age......

[45HG 1,539]

What was this "186" game everyone talks of? Darts only goes to 180... It's not a particularly high cricket score, even for a Twenty20... Doesn't seem to fit for basketball, soccer, rugby, ice hockey or netball... 4 great rounds of golf perhaps? 1 bad game of golf?

[Nasher 33,246]

Half a game of golf if I'm involved.

[Biffen 12,567]

My bowling figures if I'm made captain for the day.

Nunfer.

[Little Goffy 13,042]

Perfect snooker break?

[Sir Why You Little 35,342]

The Holden 186 Red.

[Tatu 416]

Not sure if Jurrah was actually playing during 186....

[45HG 1,539]

Price of bananas in 12 years? Though I'm not sure what part Jurrah will play in that, either.

[Jack7 463]

Care to name the rest of the hacks that wore our jumper that day that are still on our list?

Or are you only interested in Knifing the players in the back that have left the club?

Gutsy!!!

[The Big Ticket 94]

Why do people keep reminding me of this horrible event?!

I nearly did a 'Grimey' that day.

[monoccular 16,695]

In the year 186 Peasants in Gaul staged an anti-tax uprising under Maternus.

I guess they may have been hungrier than many MFC players !!

Edited October 29, 2012 by monoccular

[45HG 1,539]

Does picture 2 show the Hall of Shame?

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,087]

Isnt 186 a knock shop in south melbourne? LOL

Look there is no one we have gotten rid of that added some of the qualities we need in this side other than perhaps Brent.

[Biffen 12,567]

Does picture 2 show the Hall of Shame?

Is that where Alan Jones "privately"addresses the Young Libs?

[Maldonboy38 6,157]

There are more factors involved, but it is no concidence that so many of the mediocre players from the 186 game have been delisted, Rivers aside. One of Neeld's main mentors is Blight - look what he did at Adelaide.

What is interesting is that Neeld hasn't gone only to the draft, but has traded for players to replace many of them, and these players are fringe players from other clubs. Big bodies appears to be his main recruiting philosophy for this stage of the development of the list.

[Carrot Top 947]

Not sure if Jurrah was actually playing during 186....

Not sure if any of them were.

[stuie 7,374]

"186" is the most over emphasized, over dramatized event I can recall EVER.

FFS get over it. It was bad, but it was ONE GAME. It does NOT define us.

[stuie 7,374]

There are more factors involved, but it is no concidence that so many of the mediocre players from the 186 game have been delisted, Rivers aside. One of Neeld's main mentors is Blight - look what he did at Adelaide.

What is interesting is that Neeld hasn't gone only to the draft, but has traded for players to replace many of them, and these players are fringe players from other clubs. Big bodies appears to be his main recruiting philosophy for this stage of the development of the list.

Lol.. Yes I'm sure Mark Neeld based his list decisions on one game 18 months ago in Geelong when he had nothing to do with us...

[Bitter but optimistic 21,586]

"186" is the most over emphasized, over dramatized event I can recall EVER.

FFS get over it. It was bad, but it was ONE GAME. It does NOT define us.

Yes Stuie we need to get over it. However, we should not turn it into a joke as some above have. We must never forget it and do whatever it takes to ensure that such humiliation is not repeated.

[stuie 7,374]

Yes Stuie we need to get over it. However, we should not turn it into a joke as some above have. We must never forget it and do whatever it takes to ensure that such humiliation is not repeated.

GTFO it's not ANZAC day mate.

Of course we should get over it and forget it. It was ONE GAME. DO we still celebrate the wins? No. That's how GOOD football teams do it, they move on to the next challenge rather than dwell on the past. Ever heard the saying "one week at a time"?!!

[Bitter but optimistic 21,586]

Well actually I think it has defined us since that time. Hence the Neeld slash and burn burn policy to bury it. I think you and I are on much the same wavelength but the "one week at a time" cliche does worry me.