Jack Trengove

[thaipantsman 180]

People wish to know why he has no pace, it's not a matter of lacking support.

Hi Why you little!

What you say is clearly not the case. Please read this post as confirmation. There is many more like it. Nothing! Clearly Jack Trengove is extremely promising and IMO is better than Scully. (not that Scully is bad)

Range Rover, on 26 August 2012 - 06:35 PM, said:

I see nothing special in this guy at all. Nothing.

[Undeeterred 2,908]

People wish to know why he has no pace, it's not a matter of lacking support.

Are you actually a goldfish who has somehow learned how to type, but, being a goldfish, forgets what he has said 10 minutes ago?

[P-man 13,309]

Slower than McLean.

This.

It's like he's injected with tranquilisers before every match.

[Undeeterred 2,908]

Rob Mac......, on 26 August 2012 - 01:57 AM, said:

Agreed!

I've no idea whether it's psychological, or a little undisclosed injury, but he was better last year & I suspect the reason he wasn't dropped for a bit this year was because of the captaincy. Poor decision not to give him a run in the two's, it worked well for others this year. (I also wouldn't have made him captain so young.)

Undeterred, Your quoting of me is (possibly unintentionally) unfair.

In my post you quoted, I clearly agreed solely with Range Rover saying that "He's been one of our worst players over the course of the season." You yourself said, "The fact that he can't kick 35m and can hardly run at the moment (is not because he is cr@p)." ..but Undeeterred, while you "can't kick 35m and can hardly run" you ARE at least somewhat cr@p (in spite of many other admirable efforts) which is how Trengrove's been this season, right?

Previously he was fine & hopefully next year too, plus he seems a great fellow who's development has been put under much strain this year. I like him & wasn't suggesting his delisting

Sorry to include you in the Peanut Gallery with RR and WYL.

I can see what you're saying.

I just don't think that he has been that bad. He's right up there in most of our key midfielder stats, and in my view has dealt with the captaincy really well. It is obvious if you watch him closely that he is working his guts out and doing lots of things that people don't notice. I do agree that he has obviously been labouring, which means he is (1) not running as quickly or (2) not kicking with as much penetration as he usually would.

But you have to view these things as a whole, and I don't think those particular (temporay) limitations overshadow the fact that he has actually had a pretty good season. It is easy to pinpoint 1 kick that doesn't make the distance, or 1 chase where he can't go, while ignoring the 20 other times he touches the ball in a game.

[Johnny Karate 559]

Some of you clowns amaze me.

Newsflash: bar the expansion sides we are the worst side in the competition. Jones aside (& Clark for half a season), nobody has lifted their game at all this year. Nobody. By that measure nothing on the list is that 'special'.

The stat about his lack of disposals made me giggle, barely any of our players average 20 or more disposals.

I see Trengove as a potential Jimmy Bartel, plenty of dickwits were writing him off as too slow in his 3rd season too. He was even dropped to the VFL & mooted as potential trade bait. The kid had nothing special. 3 premierships, a Brownlow & Norm Smith, 7 years later for 'nothing special'... JT is arguably ahead of Bartel at the same stage of his career (albeit playing in a far worse team) I have high hopes he can achieve nearly half of what Bartel has by the end of it.

[deejammin' 2,096]

Jimmi, I couldn't agree with you more. All of Trenners strengths would be very useful to a side with a versatile midfield. Sewell and Mitchell are made to look very quick by their midfield at times, but most of the football media and many coaches talked about how slow they were coming into the system. The reality is our team don't block well for eachother, our ball use is clunky at best and our midfield is either one-paced, under-developed physically or has extremely poor disposal depending on which combination you pick. The reality is JT is in our top 6 mids even whilst underperforming, this is how terrible our midfield is and until we draft and trade to rectify this problem he will have no problem keeping his spot. And who knows, maybe with a half decent midfield group around him he will flourish. Hell, Adelaide make a plodder like Van Berlo look good.

[McQueen 17,864]

I don't believe that having a © next to your name on a team sheet has any effect on your ability to run quickly.

That said, if he produces another plodder of a season like this one in 2013 I've got no issue with Neeld stripping him of that title.

At the moment Trengove is just another battler. No great going for a no.2 draft pick.

I just think you're way premature on this one Rangey. There are many Captains in the league that are not superstars.

To say that you see nothing special in him at all is quite damning.

[thaipantsman 180]

I just think you're way premature on this one Rangey. There are many Captains in the league that are not superstars.

To say that you see nothing special in him at all is quite damning.

"just another battler"

RR needs to take off his "7 day glasses".

[thaipantsman 180]

Are you actually a goldfish who has somehow learned how to type, but, being a goldfish, forgets what he has said 10 minutes ago?

That's a little harsh on the poor old goldfish!

[Sir Why You Little 35,318]

Undeeterred..an apt name.

What have i said that is so "out there"?

In 2012 Jack Trengove has no pace and struggles to kick longer than 30-35 metres.

How many times has he kicked into the man on the mark??

I saw it. You saw it. It is what it is.

I am asking why. I am not burning him.

No need to be rude btw.

[Binmans PA 26,662]

It's interesting, Trenners moved a lot better for mine today. He could also kick with a little more penetration against the Crows. I agree he's struggled to get past 35m for most of the year but today and last week he looked better.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,000]

The guy is second in tackles, second in handballs and third in overall disposals this year. He can't be doing too badly. Watch how he goes about it on the field. He's always looking to do the team things, sometimes I think a little too much. JT is going along nicely.

[rjay 24,178]

Judge him on next year, he showed plenty in his first couple of seasons to say he will be a player. I don't think it's the captaincy that's responsible for him struggling to kick a ball 30 or so metres or to keep up with the play. He was a good kick, a very good kick and had good run, not blistering but good run in his legs. You don't loose this without a reason, injury? training loads?

He is one that I'm not worried about, there are many others on the list that I am.

[angrydee 842]

He still reminds me of a young Bartel. Especially his marking. Watch his speed pick up next year with his endurance training mixed with speed training in the preseason.

[Undeeterred 2,908]

Undeeterred..an apt name.

What have i said that is so "out there"?

In 2012 Jack Trengove has no pace and struggles to kick longer than 30-35 metres.

How many times has he kicked into the man on the mark??

I saw it. You saw it. It is what it is.

I am asking why. I am not burning him.

No need to be rude btw.

Go back and read your posts on this thread. You start off by getting stuck in to Trengove on a very general basis, probably because Range Rover was. Then, when the discussion changes tack towards Trengove being slow, you say that its not about him having a lack of support, it is about him having a lack of pace.

Utterly inconsistent.

And I wasn't being rude, I was merely pointing this out.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,785]

Trengove is slow and has played every single game this season. Those are the only facts at hand. No evidence of an injury at all.

So you're just disregarding his 2010 & 2011 seasons where he showed no signs of being slow? The fact there was such a marked drop-off this year is a sign that something is not right physically, you don't just stop being able to run fast at 21 years old.

[Chook 14,647]

Why is my comment any more outlandish than the the throng of people on here who opine that he has OP when they have no proof to that effect and no word from the club about it?

Why? Because human beings consistently become faster and stronger until the age of around 26. Unless you know of some fundamental change in human biology that the rest of us don't, you're simply being a pessimist when you say that heavy training loads or an injury aren't the cause of Trengove's lack of speed.

[Range Rover 1,935]

It seems it's sacrilege around here to suggest J. Trengove is slow. So I'll stop doing it.

Meanwhile ya'll go on deluding yourselves about it, creating a fictitious injury that he doesn't have.

[rpfc 27,673]

I was a late withdrawal in two PS games, that means injury and interrupted PS.

He will be fine.

[Undeeterred 2,908]

It seems it's sacrilege around here to suggest J. Trengove is slow. So I'll stop doing it.

Meanwhile ya'll go on deluding yourselves about it, creating a fictitious injury that he doesn't have.

I don't think you'll find, of the vast weight of posters who disagree with you, not one has suggested he isn't slow.

[Chook 14,647]

It seems it's sacrilege around here to suggest J. Trengove is slow. So I'll stop doing it.

Meanwhile ya'll go on deluding yourselves about it, creating a fictitious injury that he doesn't have.

So tell me, Professor, why has he become so slow so quickly?

[jnrmac 19,481]

Some of you clowns amaze me.

Newsflash: bar the expansion sides we are the worst side in the competition. Jones aside (& Clark for half a season), nobody has lifted their game at all this year. Nobody. By that measure nothing on the list is that 'special'.

The stat about his lack of disposals made me giggle, barely any of our players average 20 or more disposals.

I see Trengove as a potential Jimmy Bartel, plenty of dickwits were writing him off as too slow in his 3rd season too. He was even dropped to the VFL & mooted as potential trade bait. The kid had nothing special. 3 premierships, a Brownlow & Norm Smith, 7 years later for 'nothing special'... JT is arguably ahead of Bartel at the same stage of his career (albeit playing in a far worse team) I have high hopes he can achieve nearly half of what Bartel has by the end of it.

Howe

[Range Rover 1,935]

So tell me, Professor, why has he become so slow so quickly?

Don't know, just like you don't.

What I do know is players like Martin, Gaff, Hill, Heppell, Redden, Hannebery, Shuey, Sidebottom and Atley - the next generation of gun young mids - have skipped right past him.

Trengove is stagnating big time. He's a no.2 draft pick for chrissakes.

[waikikkamukau 62]

JT will be a great for the MFC, I have no problem with where he is at. He is a 58 game player. He has another 2 pre seasons to get through before he gets to the same stage as someone like Dangerfield.

I prepared to give him a 4 year apprenticeship and reserve my judgement until then.

Morton on the other hand.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,785]

It seems it's sacrilege around here to suggest J. Trengove is slow. So I'll stop doing it.

Meanwhile ya'll go on deluding yourselves about it, creating a fictitious injury that he doesn't have.

No-one's disagreeing about his lack of pace at the moment. It's just some of us look at all the facts including his history and make a reasonable assessment that it is temporary due to factor/s we don't know of while others are running around like Henny Penny shreiking the sky is falling.

How do you account for the fact that his pace/explosiveness declined over one pre-season if not for injury and/or training loads?