Injury List - Round 16

[alpha33 320]

Liam Jurrah no longer 2 - 4!!!

Mark Jamar (calf) test

James Sellar (thigh) test

Jai Sheahan (ankle) test

Tom McDonald (internal injuries) 1 week

Liam Jurrah (ankle) 1-2 weeks

Michael Evans (back) 1-2 weeks

Kelvin Lawrence (calf) 2 weeks

Rory Taggert (back) indefinite

Clint Bartram (knee) season

Max Gawn (knee) season

Mitch Clark (foot) season

Edited July 10, 2012 by Whispering_Jack
Addition of Kelvin Lawrence

[old dee 23,792]

Liam Jurrah no longer 2 - 4!!!

Mark Jamar (calf) test

James Sellar (thigh) test

Jai Sheahan (ankle) test

Tom McDonald (internal injuries) 1 week

Liam Jurrah (ankle) 1-2 weeks

Michael Evans (back) 1-2 weeks

Rory Taggert (back) indefinite

Clint Bartram (knee) season

Max Gawn (knee) season

Mitch Clark (foot) season

Their just playing with our minds, not that there is a lot to play with.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

It would be good to see both Jurrah and Evans finish the season well at Casey.

Good platform for a decent head start into preseason 2013.

[The Lobster Effect 892]

Liam Jurrah no longer 2 - 4!!!

hey alpha... awesome that jurrah is finally recovering from the ankle, that is. Taken so long, it has.

thanks http://www.yodaspeak.co.uk

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Their just playing with our minds, not that there is a lot to play with.

He'll probably be 1-2 weeks for the next month.

[IRW 1,387]

1 to 2 weeks eh? I'm pretty sure they're bluffing

[binman 42,986]

He'll probably be 1-2 weeks for the next month.

No i don't think so. He'll be 1-2 for the next 2-4.

[Roger Mellie 4,032]

Just watched Misson on DEETV and to update:

- Michael Pickle Evans will play for Casey this week (2nds most likely) - great news!

- Sheahan wont play

- Lawrence is 2 weeks away with a calf injury

- TMac, Jamar and Seller to all push for selection (TMac needs OK from the doc)

- Mitch Clark is bored

[DemonWA 3,934]

Jurrah's 'injuries' are p1ssing me off.

Anyone got any info on how clark is going? No complications from the procedure i hope?

[old dee 23,792]

No i don't think so. He'll be 1-2 for the next 2-4.

Very Good binman love it!

[old dee 23,792]

Jurrah's 'injuries' are p1ssing me off.

Anyone got any info on how clark is going? No complications from the procedure i hope?

You are not Robinson Crusoe mate.

I have to say (because I cannot help myself) that LJ is either the unluckiest player going round or he is the slowest healer going around.

Every injury he gets seems to take forever to get over.

This will bring the wrath down on me but I am beginning to tire of LJ and his problems.

He is beginning to get too hard.

[DemonWA 3,934]

You are not Robinson Crusoe mate.

I have to say (because I cannot help myself) that LJ is either the unluckiest player going round or he is the slowest healer going around.

Every injury he gets seems to take forever to get over.

This will bring the wrath down on me but I am beginning to tire of LJ and his problems.

He is beginning to get too hard.

Fair call Old Dee.

However, it's annoying me because it seems like they're calling him injured when its more like he's not deemed fit enough to play in a game!

Every training report says he's running laps at a good pace. Surely his ankle can't be 2 weeks away if that's the case?

[Whispering_Jack 30,173]

Every training report says he's running laps at a good pace. Surely his ankle can't be 2 weeks away if that's the case?

I'm not really into conspiracy theories or the like but I wonder if the idea all along, once Liam incurred what was at least a medium term ankle injury, was for him not to play until after his next hearing in NT was over. This would have kept him out of the limelight and away from publicity which, in the circumstances, was probably a good thing.

I say this because, effectively the downgrading from 2 - 4 weeks to 1 to 3 weeks is virtually meaningless. It's hardly likely that Liam would be selected for Melbourne first up if declared fit to play the weekend after next - especially since the game that weekend is against Port Adelaide in Darwin. He won't be playing in the VFL that round either because both Casey teams have the bye. Which means that realistically we won't be seeing Liam Jurrah playing until Casey's game against Frankston in 2½ week's time and after his date with the court in the NT.

Either way, I wouldn't be getting too excited about the new 1 - 3 week classification for Liam Jurrah's return because it's virtually meaningless. He has bigger fish to fry both in the legal sphere and in terms of achieving some sort of reconciliation in his wider family and within his community in Yuendumu and in that regard we should be hoping for an early and a positive outcome for all concerned.

[beelzebub 23,377]

Their just playing with our minds, not that there is a lot to play with.

I reckon they are too. Now itll remain 1-2 for about 5 weeks most likely

[beelzebub 23,377]

I'm not really into conspiracy theories or the like but I wonder if the idea all along, once Liam incurred what was at least a medium term ankle injury, was for him not to play until after his next hearing in NT was over. This would have kept him out of the limelight and away from publicity which, in the circumstances, was probably a good thing.

I say this because, effectively the downgrading from 2 - 4 weeks to 1 to 3 weeks is virtually meaningless. It's hardly likely that Liam would be selected for Melbourne first up if declared fit to play the weekend after next - especially since the game that weekend is against Port Adelaide in Darwin. He won't be playing in the VFL that round either because both Casey teams have the bye. Which means that realistically we won't be seeing Liam Jurrah playing until Casey's game against Frankston in 2½ week's time and after his date with the court in the NT.

Either way, I wouldn't be getting too excited about the new 1 - 3 week classification for Liam Jurrah's return because it's virtually meaningless. He has bigger fish to fry both in the legal sphere and in terms of achieving some sort of reconciliation in his wider family and within his community in Yuendumu and in that regard we should be hoping for an early and a positive outcome for all concerned.

shhh !!!! supposed to be a secret

[beelzebub 23,377]

Im not actually expecting to see him play this year at all..Ive actually considered the idea we wont see him play again as a Dee. I just dont get any positive vibes about this who debacle at all. I do wish him well but the splitting of his heart might be a bridge too far. The call might be too great.

[old dee 23,792]

I'm not really into conspiracy theories or the like but I wonder if the idea all along, once Liam incurred what was at least a medium term ankle injury, was for him not to play until after his next hearing in NT was over. This would have kept him out of the limelight and away from publicity which, in the circumstances, was probably a good thing.

I say this because, effectively the downgrading from 2 - 4 weeks to 1 to 3 weeks is virtually meaningless. It's hardly likely that Liam would be selected for Melbourne first up if declared fit to play the weekend after next - especially since the game that weekend is against Port Adelaide in Darwin. He won't be playing in the VFL that round either because both Casey teams have the bye. Which means that realistically we won't be seeing Liam Jurrah playing until Casey's game against Frankston in 2½ week's time and after his date with the court in the NT.

Either way, I wouldn't be getting too excited about the new 1 - 3 week classification for Liam Jurrah's return because it's virtually meaningless. He has bigger fish to fry both in the legal sphere and in terms of achieving some sort of reconciliation in his wider family and within his community in Yuendumu and in that regard we should be hoping for an early and a positive outcome for all concerned.

I agree with you WJ.

When the extent of his injury was known after the Swans game my imediate reaction was we will not see him again this year.

Due to his proven slow heal rate in the past and events in the NT

I am fairly confident I wrote that on one of the treads at the time.

I remember saying we may never see him again I still think that is a real chance.

I have written him off for 2012 and perhaps forever I wonder if he has the body to make it in the AFL!

Edited July 10, 2012 by old dee

[Redleg 40,926]

I'm not really into conspiracy theories or the like but I wonder if the idea all along, once Liam incurred what was at least a medium term ankle injury, was for him not to play until after his next hearing in NT was over. This would have kept him out of the limelight and away from publicity which, in the circumstances, was probably a good thing.

I say this because, effectively the downgrading from 2 - 4 weeks to 1 to 3 weeks is virtually meaningless. It's hardly likely that Liam would be selected for Melbourne first up if declared fit to play the weekend after next - especially since the game that weekend is against Port Adelaide in Darwin. He won't be playing in the VFL that round either because both Casey teams have the bye. Which means that realistically we won't be seeing Liam Jurrah playing until Casey's game against Frankston in 2½ week's time and after his date with the court in the NT.

Either way, I wouldn't be getting too excited about the new 1 - 3 week classification for Liam Jurrah's return because it's virtually meaningless. He has bigger fish to fry both in the legal sphere and in terms of achieving some sort of reconciliation in his wider family and within his community in Yuendumu and in that regard we should be hoping for an early and a positive outcome for all concerned.

Agree with you WJ, but I think the next hearing is a Committtal and if he is committed for a trial, then it will go on to next year most likely. His best bet is a finding at the committal of insufficient evidence to go forward.

[old dee 23,792]

Agree with you WJ, but I think the next hearing is a Committtal and if he is committed for a trial, then it will go on to next year most likely. His best bet is a finding at the committal of insufficient evidence to go forward.

I would not like to be hanging my hat on that one Redleg.