Players who will thrive under Neeld?

[Sir Why You Little 34,939]

There WILL be some suprises to, that will throw all of us...

[old dee 22,983]

Agreed on Jetta

I also see Bate in the same catogory as he always seems to be trying to give his all and do the team things.

Olddee's mate, #7, shoud also show a bit more if he is given one role to focus on (forward or backline, not both).

imposters like Dunn will either flourish under a new coach or be further found out and kicked to casey!

I am not taking the bait

No more comment on you know who till May1st

That probably means I already have!

[digby wolf 1]

Sam Blease

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Any player who has a head down, bum up attitude. Grimes comes immediately to mind.

[old dee 22,983]

40 of them I hope!

[Redleg 38,045]

40 of them I hope!

What about the rookies?

[Sir Why You Little 34,939]

After reading yesterdays press i really do hope it is Cale Morton. The kid does have talent, but lacks all confidence. The perfect project for a new hard edged coach.

[Roger Mellie 3,601]

At Collingwood, they managed to turn the worst kick in the league into a reliable (although awkward) kick - Ben Johnson.

Therefore I would hope to see the ordinary kicks improve out of sight and even the players where kicking isn't their strength make noticeable improvement.

Bartram, Grimes, Bail, Nicho, McKenzie, Petterd, Joel Mac, Martin, Fitzpatrick, Spencil etc

Edited November 13, 2011 by Roger Mellie

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

About half the list will. I think some of the older heads won't though. Guys like Moloney, Jamar, Green. Blokes with work ethics already, or guys like Sylvia who are too far gone just won't learn at the same rate as a young kid. I think someone like Watts will benefit from a Paganesque hardass. Someone has to [censored]-slap him into line.

Jordie will win about 3 Blueys under him though. He'll be our Hayes... and he looks like Neeld's lovechild, to boot.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Hmm. One more. Gys. Smart, but slow footballers. Assuming Neeld comes in and coaches to his midfield's strength (which is NOT pace) then he should break even there at least. With a dynamic forward line and fantastic defence, that'll put us in the top 9 or 10.

[maximum bob 462]

I look forward to the day that Bate becomes a consistent AFL footballer. Good luck Neeld.

Along with Davey, a little underwhelming and get a right foot.

The old days of one position, one side are long gone.

[Biffen 12,433]

We all will .

[Guest Deefence]

Big hard bodies who do the team thing. So Frawley, Joel Mac, Bartram, Jamar...

I've also heard that Blease and Tom Mac are training up forward, and Jetta down back.

[mrtwister 650]

IMO Trengove will become an animal in 2012. The new coaching staff will improve his presence on the field immensely. I hope he drags plenty up with him as well.

[deanbarber 37]

Jones, Moloney, Rivers, Mckenzie, Sylvia

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Maybe not necessarily because of the fitness, but Tom McDonald might start to usurp Rivers...

This may happen to a few players throughout the year, as we are assuming Neeld will pick people purely on a form basis

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I think Neeld would really want to have a strong impact on the top 6 to 10 players on our list. Get them moving toward being "stars" or well above average footballers. Its only then will MFC improve. And as these players improve they will make others around them better than what they are.

Too many what Neeld to have phoenix like impacts on fringe players. And he may well but some of those mentioned even if they play at their best will still find them as mid range NQRs.

At Collingwood, they managed to turn the worst kick in the league into a reliable (although awkward) kick - Ben Johnson.

Must have been in another life. Johnson could always kick 60 mertres on the run hardly a candidate for worst kick in the AFL.

[rpfc 27,646]

Must have been in another life. Johnson could always kick 60 mertres on the run hardly a candidate for worst kick in the AFL.

Being able to kick it far doesn't mean someone is a good kick.

Johnson used to spray them.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

But he wasnt the worst kick in the AFL.........

[rpfc 27,646]

But he wasnt the worst kick in the AFL.........

He only said he was a candidate for worst kick...

[BAMF 3,809]

But he wasnt the worst kick in the AFL.........

He was certainly the worst kick in the collingwood side for a long time.

I don't think I could actually name the worst kick in the league now, let alone 4 or so years ago.

Actually, its probably Spencer!

[Roger Mellie 3,601]

But he wasnt the worst kick in the AFL.........

IMO he was - some will agree, some wont.

If it makes you happier I'll rephrase it - he was a shocking kick.

The point of the post was, he is now a reliable kick and furthermore there are no obvious bad kicks at Collingwood, or Geelong for that matter.

You couldn't say the same for the MFC and I hope Neeld turns said players into serviceable if not reliable kicks.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Looking forward to seeing how Watts, Jones, Sylvia and Morton take to Neeld.

Jones, by all accounts, is in the top 3 fittest people at the club at the moment. He is a competitor, and if Neeld can fine tune his deficiencies he will become a very good footballer.

We saw Watts take his game to a new level in 2011, but he is still far from elite. Interesting seeing that Neeld gave him a kick up the backside the other day, and I'm curious as to what influence this will have on Killa. He is a player who still isn't in his prime, but will Neeld and his assistants be able to make him into a star?

Cale Morton is far and away the most bagged Demon. This is mostly because he has been labelled as 'soft'. I believe that Neeld's no-nonsense approach will either make or break Cale, but with Misson on board he should be able to significantly bulk up, and I think it is likely he will become a very good player for the MFC. He has the tools, he just needs the guidance.

The player I'm going to be watching the most closely this year, though, is Col Sylvia. For too long he has been able to get away with not playing to his ability, not taking professional footy seriously, and being a 'passenger' in most games against top 8 sides. Neeld has shown that he isn't going to take any **** from Col by already suspending him for one game. I think this will be a major wake up call to him, and he will work harder and become a potential Bluey winner in 2012 as a result of Neeld's hard nosed attitude.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,534]

Cale Morton is far and away the most bagged Demon.

Only for the last two weeks. Prior to that it was Michael Newton.

[Sir Why You Little 34,939]

Only for the last two weeks. Prior to that it was Michael Newton.

I bet Simon Eishold is very glad the Internet did not exist in 1987!!