Kane Tenace

[Melb2012 0]

thoughts?

[Keyser Söze 0]

thoughts?

Really?? is he?

No chance to make the squad though, I hope.

I thought we now placed a priority on recruiting players that could kick..?

[pringle 42]

Is the thread title a statement, question or suggestion? Has this been announced? Link? Seen at training? Source?

[Bates Mate 3,932]

thoughts?

measure him up for fluro green shorts and tshirt

he will be quicker than Anthony mcdonald at delivering messages

[Toot182 7]

He wasn't on the 'permission to train list' from memory, but then again, I'm not sure how often this is updated by the AFL or if you can simply add players given clearance on a daily basis.

Regardless, I don't think we need him.

[drdrake 3,047]

Can't kick can't get it enough.

[45HG 1,539]

Cough

[Jaded No More 58,685]

thoughts?

To duds, Melbourne says NO!

[maximum bob 462]

If I ever see another post with the word 'thoughts?' as the first, last or the only word in your case...

"I'll rip your bloody arms off!"

(With apologies to Auntie Jack).

[Dee Fan 3,247]

thoughts?

Well, is he?

[DemonDing 56]

your kidding arent you ? hes sh_t house. oh wait he's quick we better get him pfft

[Sir Why You Little 34,705]

Ha! When i first Joined Demonland Kane Tenace was the "Buzz" Player we had to have....Now he can't even be collected from the nature strip as hard rrubbish!!

Who would want the Recruiters Jobs-Bloody Nightmare isn't it.....I Pray that BP & Tim Harrington & co get it "mostly" right on the 26th....

[The Big Ticket 94]

I bloody hope not

[Sydney Pennski 270]

Can't kick can't get it enough.

Gets it enough sometimes but then again, anyone with the merest modicum of ability is going to get his hands on the footy going around with those Geelong blokes. Doesn't do enough with his kicks which lack precision and depth and I really think he would flounder and possibly end up a major league list clogger with us.

[rodney_g 63]

Is it too optimistic to hope that if Tenace is training with the Demons it is as a some kind of cautionary tale?

- High draft pick doesn't not equal guaranteed success.

- Failure to improve skills does equal delisting.

[LITTLE STINGA 1]

Well he does want to be at the club so that should please Rhino and Bezlebub.

[Adzman 2,085]

I have seen much worse than Tenace play at AFL level. He is alright, but I really cannot see him addressing a need for the MFC. He has less of an upside than Simon Buckley who was let go, signing Tenace would make no sense.

[hoopla 418]

Well, is he?

I don't think anyone's answered this yet- Is he training with us or isn't he?

[Nasher 33,133]

I have seen much worse than Tenace play at AFL level. He is alright, but I really cannot see him addressing a need for the MFC. He has less of an upside than Simon Buckley who was let go, signing Tenace would make no sense.

How does he have less upside than Simon Buckley?

In my mind they might as well be the same player; though I admit I've seen a lot less of Tenace than Buckley.

[H_T 2,941]

If I ever see another post with the word 'thoughts?' as the first, last or the only word in your case...

"I'll rip your bloody arms off!"

(With apologies to Auntie Jack).

Maxi Bob. Thankyou for your contribution to the thread and your 'thoughts'...

.....on Kane Tenace.

Tenace is quick. Scully is quicker. That's my contribution.

Edited November 13, 2009 by High Tower

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

How does he have less upside than Simon Buckley?

In my mind they might as well be the same player.

Very similar.

Quick, flaky disposal and decision making skills with questionable defensive capability.

The other issue with Buckley is any linger groin problems (The fact that he has been pictured in a NM training guernsey) does not mitigate that issue.

[Darren Cuthbertson 0]

I don't think anyone's answered this yet- Is he training with us or isn't he?

Hey Hoopla -who told you to pick him up?

[old55 21,445]

thoughts?

That your mail has proven to be very reliable - perhaps Demonland deegirl?

A fringe player in a champion team is not necessarily a dud and it's facile to assert that. He's potentially a pretty good player, but it's very hard to break into that midfield. He's excctly the right age and he has pace, which when I look at our 2010 best 22 even with Brock gone and Ball not arriving, is a problem.

Look at Farren Ray, he made a significant contribution at St.Kilda. I think Tenace could add value.

In the long run the problem is that we're aiming to be the next Geelong so that would see him at the fringes and Ray failed in the GF. But there's the possibility that he becomes a more effective player in his late 20s.

I'm definitely interested.

[beelzebub 22,269]

I'm definitely interested.

pick 50 ?

[titan_uranus 22,659]

I can't believe people are actually interested in Kane Tenace.

Kane Tenace...

Come on, now. Tenace was on their list before they became a powerhouse, and he failed to do anything of note then either.