TassieDevil

Can't vote - went to bed at half time in disgust.

I'm glad I had the foresight to turn of TV at half time and get some early shut eye.

Answorth needs to be cited for his sledge on Petty imitating he was crying - conduct unbecoming/ bringing the game into disrepute

Answorth needs to be cited for his sledge on Petty imitating he was crying - conduct unbecoming/ bringing the game into disrepute

Truck Max McVee May Spaz Fritzl

That Soligo goes ok - racked up possessions last night, even after the hit.

Windsor reminds me of Brisbane mid legend Simon Black. Light frame but willing in a contest. Uses the ball exceptionally well for a 4th gamer.

The Tassie Jackjumper's win in the NBL shows Tassie can attract and retain talent.

6. ANB 5. Max 4. Chandler 3. Rivers 2. Brown 1. TMac

Living interstate I have had limited chances to watch MFC live. Every time I have I am left in awe of Jack's contribution - a real see ball get ball player but with a better footy IQ. Deserves another flag.

There was a clear "kicking in danger" vs Hawks that was not paid. He looked to be impacted by that

No stadium = no team. AFL unequivocal about that - which opponents don't get. Tasmania vs AFL is no contest. We need them more than they need us.

The playing surfaces at both grounds are fine - and that's about it. Bellerive is bang in the middle of suburbia and has limited potential for growth and dreadful transport options. York Park - aka Pork Barrel stadium - would mean that many Hobart fans won't attend. It's a horrible spectator experience. The stadium is more about the spectator experience - as long as they get the surface right - if they get that right they will be looking at good crowds, and interstate fans wanting to come down for the experience.

If you've ever sat at either Bellerive or Pork Barrel Stadium watching footy in the depths of winter you'd understand why a roof is needed. I'm not sure if a roof would add to heat capture but a crowd of 23K would generate some heat that a roof would likely capture. I'm unqualified in any relevant fields - but I have spent winters watching footy in Tassie and it gets bone chilling

6. Petracca 5. Fritsch 4. ANB 3. Gawn 2. Pickett 1.Oliver