Who plays Ruck next week?

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,874]

Will White be right?

OR

Could big Meeson get an unlikely run??

He is slowly getting better, will get a go next year, no doubt, no chance to be delisted, hasd such athletisicsm, that he does need to really be given every chance!

I hope they don't ask Stef to help out, id rather just give Meeson a run!

Jeff, well breing a great club man, appreciate all he's done, but again, id rather see Meeson thrown in!

[Beamer 1]

Jeff White but there will be no positive reason behind his selection.

[Blistering 545]

John Meesen named in the best for Sandy today. Should be enough for the call up to help us against Port Adelaide. After 3 years in South Australia with the Crows, surely he would at least be familiar with his surroundings.

[Beamer 1]

I'd be stoked if John was included.

We would get a close look at him and would do something amazing for his confidence.

[Chook 15,023]

Well, big Meesen was in the best for Sandy this week, so I'd give him a run if Whitey isn't right. If he plays, it's fitting that we're going over to Adelaide this week.

[Axis of Bob 11,898]

If White is fit then he will ruck. Meesen has only put together one good game in a row and I will wait until I get the report from someone who actually saw it before I give him that praise.

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,874]

well, by the few ppl ive spoken to today, he was excellent!

I know its only one game, but there is far more to gain by playing John than Jeff!

Throw him in, let him run.. why not?

[ucanchoose 1,816]

Just use Silva as third man up all day. Can't go any worse.

[MrMoose 316]

Put Meeson & White both in - can't hurt!

[Robbo_24 0]

i think johnson and jamar are the ones who will take over the ruck in the future after white leaves... BTW he is out of contract too!

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

If White is fit then he will ruck. Meesen has only put together one good game in a row and I will wait until I get the report from someone who actually saw it before I give him that praise.

Agreed. I dont kow how anyone can lobby for his inclusion on an unsubstantiated performance after a season of poor showings. Anyway, the Tigers dont have any big men of note so if there was ever a game that Meesen could show somethin it is here. But Bob is right on this.

[H_T 3,049]

well, by the few ppl ive spoken to today, he was excellent!

I know its only one game, but there is far more to gain by playing John than Jeff!

Throw him in, let him run.. why not?

White, only if fit. Otherwise Meesen.

Just use Silva as third man up all day. Can't go any worse.

No.

[rednblue2009 0]

Meeson should be tried - Whitey and Benny and Yze given a farewell game against Tiges the following week.

[Nasher 33,617]

I thoroughly believe in requiring players to earn it. That rules Meesen out.

White by default, if he's fit. If he's not... well, I hate to think.

[beelzebub 23,390]

Even I can see that if everything was purely on form then Adem would have had a gig by now. Dean can say what he likes about it all being on 'form' but he has his agendas..and rightly so..thats what a coach is about surely !!. So simply saying that White is a monty may not necessarily carry weight.

I'll wait for the various spins given by the club leading up to the next round

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Even I can see that if everything was purely on form then Adem would have had a gig by now. Dean can say what he likes about it all being on 'form' but he has his agendas..and rightly so..thats what a coach is about surely !!. So simply saying that White is a monty may not necessarily carry weight.

I'll wait for the various spins given by the club leading up to the next round

Yze who has show an habitual dislike for doing the basic head over the football requirements may not have the form required. I dont think an appearance in the best for Sandy in the newspaper is an automatic basis for inclusion. A player like Yze has more ability than most in the VFL and can turn it on without performing the requisite criteria that a Coach would value for selection in the AFL. The guy is an anathema to the game plan and culture MFC are trying to cultivate and this week will be probably be told he is not wanted next year and his MFC career is finished after R22. He will probably get a send off game in R22 nevertheless.

[beelzebub 23,390]

Rhino.in case it may hav escaped your attention over the years..I am also one of Oozes greatest critics. However he HAS listed wel lfor most of the year as a mamber of teh Zebs..and as thats his only means of impressing..then by comparison to tohers on the lists then he ought wel lhave ben considered for games..indeed was named emergency onmore than one occasion.

The point I made..which you seemed to have missed.. is that Dean DOES have his agendas..and its NOT about form solely..So who knows who might front next week.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Rhino.in case it may hav escaped your attention over the years..I am also one of Oozes greatest critics. However he HAS listed wel lfor most of the year as a mamber of teh Zebs..and as thats his only means of impressing..then by comparison to tohers on the lists then he ought wel lhave ben considered for games..indeed was named emergency onmore than one occasion.

The point I made..which you seemed to have missed.. is that Dean DOES have his agendas..and its NOT about form solely..So who knows who might front next week.

Measuring it by appearing in the best at Sandy may represent the "form" you require and given that Yze makes a number of appearances in the best and does not get selected may mean your criteria for "form" is different to the Coach's criteria without necesarily having agendas. On the basis of the way Dean's wants them to play and the way Yze has played I can see that Yze's "form" would not excite Bailey in the least.

If we did not have a long list of injuries, I doubt Yze would be in our top 25 to 30 at any time.

[Chook 15,023]

Yze who has show an habitual dislike for doing the basic head over the football requirements may not have the form required. I dont think an appearance in the best for Sandy in the newspaper is an automatic basis for inclusion. A player like Yze has more ability than most in the VFL and can turn it on without performing the requisite criteria that a Coach would value for selection in the AFL. The guy is an anathema to the game plan and culture MFC are trying to cultivate and this week will be probably be told he is not wanted next year and his MFC career is finished after R22. He will probably get a send off game in R22 nevertheless.

Totally agree. Except I think the word you're looking for isn't anathema, it's antithesis. But that's not to detract from what is otherwise a fantastic post.

[Jaded No More 68,975]

Why can't we let Jamar ruck the whole game on his own?

White did it for 10 seasons, and we're hardly playing for finals here.

As far as I'm concerned, no other available ruckman on our list deserves a game. Bring in Petterd to replace PJ and we'd be miles better off than having a disinterested White or a seriously poor Meesen. If worse comes to worse and Jamar goes down, Martin can have a short stint in the ruck.

[titan_uranus 25,174]

My vote's for Holland. At least we know what we'll get with big Dutchy

[Rogue 585]

John Meesen named in the best for Sandy today. Should be enough for the call up to help us against Port Adelaide.

Great timing

If fit, White.