Maynard must get at least four weeks

[layzie 28,744]

47 minutes ago, Monbon said:

You haven't even considered the most obvious deduction yet: That it was Brayshaw's fault because he ran into poor, stationary and innocent Maynard who only had eyes for the ball. Angus should get 6 weeks for damaging Maynard's reputation as a thug: Maynard is INNOCENT - HE WAS PROTECTING HIMSELF FROM A VISCOUS BRAYSHAW ATTACK.

Yeah true. If he stood still he could have been bowled over.

[The heart beats true 16,147]

54 minutes ago, binman said:

It's one thing saying we need the broadcaster's dollars to grow the game, pay the players etc etc. It's quite another to sell the soul of the sport to the highest bidder. The symbiotic, parasitic relationship between 7, Fox and SEN is at the heart of the rot in the sport. 

I suspect this finals season has been the tipping point for a lot of people and their relationship with AFL broadcasting. I love going to the footy, but I can’t stand it on the TV.

For me Thursday nights TV was the pinnacle. Angus Brayshaw lay motionless in the middle of the MCG for an off the ball incident that will control the AFL media landscape for the next 2 weeks - but the broadcaster was showing us De Goey limping because he rolled his ankle.

Their pandering isn’t helping anyone, and least of all the game. If Kayo had the option to just watch the game with crowd noise I’m guessing 80% of the audience would watch it.

[leave it to deever 15,368]

4 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

People saying they want justice.

There's no justice in all of this. If rumours are true that Gus could give the game away from this incident then there's no justice at all.

Someone's career is potentially taken away from him but yet the offender only misses 3-4 weeks? 

No good outcomes out of this.

According to DubDee,  Gus wears the Helmut to pacify his mother's concern. Given the injuries to other family members mentioned by Jaded No More, it is not inconceivable for Gus to call it a day. Maybe it's the best thing for him, but would be a gut wrenching call for the young man. I'm not going to say I hope he doesn't because it's none of my business. 

I will say that now I hope Maynard gets more than four.

Any ideas as to when will we find out?

[Jaded No More 57,897]

8 minutes ago, The heart beats true said:

I suspect this finals season has been the tipping point for a lot of people and their relationship with AFL broadcasting. I love going to the footy, but I can’t stand it on the TV.

For me Thursday nights TV was the pinnacle. Angus Brayshaw lay motionless in the middle of the MCG for an off the ball incident that will control the AFL media landscape for the next 2 weeks - but the broadcaster was showing us De Goey limping because he rolled his ankle.

Their pandering isn’t helping anyone, and least of all the game. If Kayo had the option to just watch the game with crowd noise I’m guessing 80% of the audience would watch it.

Let’s not even mention that half the channel 7 team frothing at their mouth were very close to Danny Frawley, who won’t get to walk Danielle down the aisle and see her marry Gus because he ended his life due to the impact of ECT. 
The utter lack of respect was astounding. 

I can’t imagine the decision Gus has to make. Nor how his entire family must be feeling. 

Edited September 9, 2023 by Jaded No More

[Colm 1,477]

6 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

People saying they want justice.

There's no justice in all of this. If rumours are true that Gus could give the game away from this incident then there's no justice at all.

Someone's career is potentially taken away from him but yet the offender only misses 3-4 weeks? 

No good outcomes out of this.

Your right. Nothing is going to give justice if it’s the end of his career.

That bump probably had a major influence on the outcome of the game too. Him coping a suspension won’t change that. 
It would however really turn me off the game if he doesn’t get suspended and helps Pies to a flag. 

[GM11 689]

11 minutes ago, D4Life said:

Well congratulations to Laura Kane if she did! Showing courage to do the right thing.

Multiple reasons:

- Maynard chose to take Brayshaw out, total rubbish he had no other choice

- Footballers, ex footballers seem to stupid, or thick to realise, it’s to their benefit to protect the head, perfect example is Barry Mitchell father of Tom, life massively impacted by head collision trauma 

- Tom Mitchell’s action highlights his level of stupidity, obviously forgot his fathers problems

- Richo, BT & co. Must have had incredibly thick skulls not to have been more severely impacted by the hits taken, but why they protect weak dog acts is beyond me

- Could write pages on this topic but enough said!

Most important point - hopefully Brayshaw is okay, for now and rest of his life!

Worst part is so many hang off their every moronic word. 

Add Dunstall, JB and "Clickbait" Cornes. 

[bandicoot 1,395]

16 hours ago, Earl Hood said:

The side vision is telling and brutal with Maynard travelling at full speed toward Brayshaw. If Brayshaw had fumbled and not got the kick away, I am sure Maynard would have just continued on, colliding with Angus. We know what the intention was. The days of white line fever play are over. It was careless conduct so must wear the consequences. For some reason it has taken all day for the MRO to handball it to the tribunal where I am sure the lawyers will get him off. 

So you mean to tell me it’s acceptable to jump at full pace at a defenceless kicker, knock them out and say it’s just a ‘football act’? 
laughable 

[ElDiablo14 3,062]

8 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Let’s not even mention that half the channel 7 team frothing at their mouth were very close to Danny Frawley, who won’t get to walk Danielle down the aisle and see her marry Gus because he ended his life due to the impact of ECT. 
The utter lack of respect was astounding. 

I can’t imagine the decision Gus has to make. Nor how his entire family must be feeling. 

Even worse to think his uncle was there sitting with those jerks (7 commentators) and he didn't defend his nephew.

 

[Jaded No More 57,897]

10 minutes ago, ElDiablo14 said:

Even worse to think his uncle was there sitting with those jerks (7 commentators) and he didn't defend his nephew.

 

This. He would know his poor nephew’s history with head knocks and that his other nephew also had his jaw broken in an AFL game. He would probably know Anita and Danielle fairly well both thru Spud and Gus. He would know how his brother and sister in law would be feeling watching Gus get stretched off and probably in tears in the room afterward. It’s embarrassing how the media conducted itself, but what else is new?! 

These low IQ bubbling idiots masquerading as commentators, combined with poor cameras and inconsistent umpiring, makes games unbearable. 

[DubDee 20,622]

If Maynard gets off i’m going to protest outside AFL house

im still [censored] furious about the hit!

[layzie 28,744]

I'm almost done with AFL broadcasts anyway. I didn't even watch last nights game. 

I dont know what JB said but it's probably not our place to say how he should feel or act in these situations.

 

[DeeZee 6,732]

Maynard knew exactly what he was doing and that was to take a player out.

No other outcome was possible when he chose to leave the ground and make front on contact , whether the ball was in the vicinity or not.

Edited September 9, 2023 by DeeZee

[Kent 2,581]

On the tram after the game full of black and White dogs for some reason

over heard a number of conversations near to me

Most agreed that Maynard tried to hurt Angus and should be rubbed our for 4 to 6

but the kicker was THAT THE AFL WONT DO THAT BECAUSE THEY LOOK AFTER BIG CLUBS

the sheer arrogance is disturbing on many levels only made me angrier. Fortunately I  got off that tram before I engaged verbally

 

 

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,191]

While every commentator and his dog has gone out of their way to show their support for poor old Maynard, Leigh Mathews flat out said he should be suspended. Pure and simple.

And I like the argument people have put forward about whether Maynard would do the same thing at training/match simulation. I think we all know the answer.

Edited September 9, 2023 by Bring-Back-Powell

[ElDiablo14 3,062]

9 minutes ago, layzie said:

I'm almost done with AFL broadcasts anyway. I didn't even watch last nights game. 

I dont know what JB said but it's probably not our place to say how he should feel or act in these situations.

 

I know I would expect better from my uncle.

[leave it to deever 15,368]

13 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

While every commentator and his dog has gone out of their way to show their support for poor old Maynard, Leigh Mathews flat out said he should be suspended. Pure and simple.

And I like the argument people have put forward about whether Maynard would do the same thing at training/match simulation. I think we all know the answer.

If Mathews says that than it's pretty much tge way it should be. He's probably hospitalised more than most.

[jane02 3,324]

12 hours ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

Michael Christian has more than overstayed his welcome as MRO. The system is terrible with one person effectively making the decisions and only reviewing things that are brought to his attention anyway. He is a boofhead whose sole credentials are that he played for Collingwood and was a commentator post-career.

Agree with all of that. I’ve met him several times over the years ( nothing to with footy but horses) and I would not  trust him as far as I could throw him to be neutral, non biased and fair.

[PaulRB 5,923]

A related aspect to Maynards cowardly assault on Gus is the impact it had on us winning that final, and the impact it may have on us in this finals series. Both detrimental.

So if the AFL is serious about stamping this out, they should be considering a "sin-bin" rule where if a player is concussed in a manner that is reportable then the reported player is removed from the playing field (subbed out) for as long as the injured player is...

After that hit, Maynard should not have been able to continue to play in that game.

The fact he did, while Gus didn't, was impactful on the team (Melbourne) that didn't break the rules (and spirit) of the game.

Still fuming.

Go Dees

Edited September 9, 2023 by PaulRB

[Jaded No More 57,897]

27 minutes ago, layzie said:

I'm almost done with AFL broadcasts anyway. I didn't even watch last nights game. 

I dont know what JB said but it's probably not our place to say how he should feel or act in these situations.

 

Doubt Mark is thrilled that channel 7 interviewed Maynard post game in an effort to defend his actions, while his son was in the rooms with a possible career ending concussion. 
I know JB has literally no say in who channel 7 interviews post game tho, so it’s not like it was his call. 

[layzie 28,744]

12 hours ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

Michael Christian has more than overstayed his welcome as MRO. The system is terrible with one person effectively making the decisions and only reviewing things that are brought to his attention anyway. He is a boofhead whose sole credentials are that he played for Collingwood and was a commentator post-career.

Can you honestly say in the 5 years he's been in the job that things have gotten better?

I agree, it's time for him to go. Why did they go away from a panel in the first place? Too many chefs in the kitchen or some crud like that?

[layzie 28,744]

5 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Doubt Mark is thrilled that channel 7 interviewed Maynard post game in an effort to defend his actions, while his son was in the rooms with a possible career ending concussion. 
I know JB has literally no say in who channel 7 interviews post game tho, so it’s not like it was his call. 

Yeah probably not, also didn't realise that was a channel 7 interview so yeah thumbs down jerks. 

[DubDee 20,622]

4 minutes ago, PaulRB said:

A related aspect to Maynards cowardly assault on Gus is the impact it had on us winning that final, and the impact it may have on us in this finals series. Both detrimental.

So if the AFL is serious about stamping this out, they should be considering a "sin-bin" rule where if a player is concussed in a manner that is reportable then the reported player is removed from the playing field (subbed out) for as long as the injured player is...

After that hit, Maynard should not have been able to continue to play in that game.

The fact he did, while Gus didn't, was impactful on the team (Melbourne) that didn't break the rules (and spirit) of the game.

Still fuming.

Go Dees

100% it was a major factor in them winning the game

Maynard would have gone into the first quarter looking to make a statement by flattening someone. he’ll do it again too. it got them into a prelim

great system AFL. Just like in the 2000 GF the team that breaks the rules and does the cheap shots gets rewarded

maybe we join em if we can’t beat em?

 

[fr_ap 2,148]

1 hour ago, wisedog said:

I think that sums it up. If this was an innocent “footy act”, we would be seeing it a dozen times a game and multiple players concussed every week.

The vision of Kozzie show how players attempting to smother normally approach the kicker - that is to say - how players respond when they haven’t already decided to hit the kicker as hard as they can.

This kozzie vision is not helpful and you should stop sharing it. He's running at a 45 degree angle towards WHE and so of course misses him on the way down...it's entirely different to the angle Maynard was approaching from 

[The heart beats true 16,147]

26 minutes ago, ElDiablo14 said:

I know I would expect better from my uncle.

Don’t tell my nephews that. Lucky to get a Christmas card. 🤣

[ElDiablo14 3,062]

1 minute ago, The heart beats true said:

Don’t tell my nephews that. Lucky to get a Christmas card. 🤣

Teenagers? Kind of expected 😅

I believe Angus is close to JB, it seemed that way during the 2021 GF post match.