Clayton Oliver has a slight lead in the Demonland Player of the Year over Jake Lever and Christian Petracca. Please give us your votes for the Round 4 match against the West Coast Eagles. Your votes please - 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 …

6. Viney

5. Oliver

4. Grundy

3. Petracca

2. TMac

1. Fritta

6 Grundy

5 Viney 

4 Petracca 

3 Oliver 

2 T McDonald 

1 Hunter 

6. Viney

5. Grundy 

4. Petracca

3. Rivers 

2. Oliver

1.Tmac

Really difficult to decide

Grundy

Fritta

Oliver

Petracca

Rivers

Kozzie

6: Grundy
5: Viney
4: Fritsch
3: Petracca
2: McDonald
1: Oliver

6.  Grundy

5.  Viney

4.  Oliver

3.  Hunter

2.  Fritsch

1.  Petracca

TMac, Rivers, Sparrow unlucky.

 

Edited April 9, 20232 yr by Deeoldfart

7 minutes ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

Really difficult to decide

Grundy

Fritta

Oliver

Petracca

Rivers

Kozzie

So difficult you forgot number 7 Bitter! 

6. Brodie Grundy

5. Jack Viney

4. Trent Rivers

3. Lachie Hunter

2. Christian Petracca

1. Clayton Oliver

Special mention to Alex Neal-Bullen 

 

6. Jack Viney

5. Brodie Grundy

4. Clayton Oliver

3. Trent Rivers

2. Christian Petracca

1. Tom McDonald

6. Grundy 

5. Fritsch

4. Viney 

3. TMac

2. trac

1. Rivers

 

6 Grundy - dominant performance.

5 Viney -tigerish display.

4 Petracca - slow start but then took control.

3 McDonald - silenced the doubters yet again.

2 Oliver - influential but not quite at his best.

1 Rivers - rapidly becoming an automatic first team choice. 

 

6. Clayton Oliver 

5. Christian Petracca 

4. Brodie Grundy 

3. Trent Rivers 

2. Tom McDonald  

1. Jack Viney

6 - Grundy

5 - Jack

4 - Clarry

3 - Tracc

2 - TMac

1 - Riv

Another great team effort by the Dees no passengers.!!!!

6. Grundy

5 Viney

4. Oliver

3. Hunter

3. TMac

2. Fritsch

1. ANB

6 Grundy

5 Oliver

4 TMac

3 Viney

2 Trac

1 Rivers

 

6 Grundy

5 McDonald

4 Viney

3 Petracca

2 Rivers

1 Fristch

 

 

6. Viney

5. Grundy

4. Trac

3. Tmac

2. Rivers

1. Oliver

 

6. Oliver 

5. Grundy

4. MacDonald

3.Viney

2. Fritsch

1. Petracca 

Clarry

trac 

grundy

riv

TMac

viney 

Viney - gets six because where our class was on display was contested ball, he loves Perth. Another tackle for the JV made me cry thread.

Oliver - Contest king, if he’d had a few outside possessions we would be losing our minds, is sometimes hard to appreciate how good he is.

ANB - great effort, 111 tackles, huge pressure and km all day, having a killer season.

Grundy - a great display, but not against a recognized ruckman, so am paying those who won contests more, he did also crack in at ground level

Rivers - In everything down back. Will be a sneaky for AA squad this year.

Tmac - 4 goals, would have been higher if he’d snagged the 5th, also normally he’d have McGovern, did like the mark he took though, clean hands at the top of the balls’ arc. 

Stiff : Fritsch - just silk, pokes holes in the defense. McVee - very stiff, when does he get his rising star. The team all good, the tackle sheet demonstrates they are drinking Shiraz and not bath water..

6.Grundy

5. Clarry

4. Viney

3.Rivers

2. Trac

1. Tmac

 

I really don't understand all the Viney love here. He was ok, but top 2-3? I'd have Oliver, Trac, Grundy, Rivers and Fritsch ahead.

 

6. Grundy

5. Oliver

4. Petracca

3. Viney

2. TMac

1. Rivers

Viney

AnB

Oliver

Rivers

Tmac

McVee